Gransnet forums

Education

Scylla and Charybdis

(143 Posts)
Esspee Thu 22-Oct-20 18:01:41

When Boris referred today to travelling a middle course between Scylla and Charybdis little did he realise that he leads a country which has been so poorly educated that most of them hadn’t a clue what he was referring to.
I bet a high proportion of us over 70s understood him perfectly.

Shrub Thu 22-Oct-20 18:48:16

Well I'm sorry but I must have been poorly educated! angry. What we need these days is more politicians with a science background, not useless Greek and Latin!

From behind sofa with tin hat on!

fiorentina51 Thu 22-Oct-20 18:51:28

I'm obviously a thick oik. I will go and sit on the naughty step.?

eazybee Thu 22-Oct-20 18:53:21

Many younger people will have spent time studying 'The Greeks' as a topic for a term at least during their Primary schooling. Reading books and school libraries are full of books containing myths taken from Greek and many other cultures.
Whether people remember them is another matter.
Possibly it will inspire people to look up the reference; so easy nowadays with a phone; my son, a very reluctant reader, does so all the time.
Then there are Stephen Fry's recent popular books about Greek mythology. He isn't ashamed of his learning.

Nightsky2 Thu 22-Oct-20 18:59:49

Shrub. My son would disagree with you.

NfkDumpling Thu 22-Oct-20 19:02:35

Nope... they dint learn yer Greek at my Sec Mod.

Lucca Thu 22-Oct-20 19:04:20

“ Then there are Stephen Fry's recent popular books about Greek mythology. He isn't ashamed of his learning.”
Sorry but who said anything about being ashamed of their learning?
The issue is whether not knowing Greek myths etc means being poorly educated. No.

varian Thu 22-Oct-20 19:04:30

There is a serious problem with the English education system which allows a narrowing down at the age when pupils absolutely need a broad range of knowledge., such as they might get if they studied for the International Baccalauriat, or even the Scottish Highers.

Alegrias2 Thu 22-Oct-20 19:11:24

I knew what he meant - but only from The Police song from the Eighties, Wrapped around your Finger.

Not the best way to communicate with the people of the country if most of them have to go and look it up to understand what he meant. Shows just how out of touch he is.

BlueBelle Thu 22-Oct-20 19:16:49

No clue what you are talking about I did Latin and French and went to a grammar school but never touched on Greek so what I thought was a pretty reasonable education...obviously wasn’t
Agree totally gagaJo

SueDonim Thu 22-Oct-20 19:17:35

I know of them as my ex-RN dh served on sister ships to the splendidly names frigates, HMS Scylla & Charybdis.

I don’t think not knowing something makes anyone poorly educated. It simply means they don’t know a particular thing. They might know lots of other things that you don’t know.

NfkDumpling Thu 22-Oct-20 19:17:52

Its not as narrow as it was in the 60s Varian, when for more than 90% of girls in my area went to a sec mod and didn't even do maths or science past age twelve. (We did Human Physiology and Hygiene and Business Arithmetic!.)

Spangler Thu 22-Oct-20 19:18:13

Poorly educated, not exactly. He is however foreign, he was born and raised in New York before relocating to Brussels where his father, Stanley Johnson, was made Head of the European Commission's newly-established Prevention of Pollution Division. Johnson went to school in Brussels where he learned to speak French. He is steeped in the EU, through and through.

He comes across as shambolic, clownish and a buffoon, but he's nobody's fool. As well as being fluent in French he's also fluent in Italian and he can speak two of the three classical languages, namely Latin and Greek, and he's studied Hebrew too.

Later on Johnson won a scholarship to attend Eton, that's not easy, the scholarship was set up to capture the brightest who didn't have the financial means, he then went on to attend Balliol College, Oxford, where he became president of the Student's Union.

But to get back on track, I agree that Scylla and Charybdis is lost on youngsters, most of whom will think it might be an unsociable disease. In fact if you ask many whose education is of the last twenty five years, they won't be able to explain that the last four months of the year do not synchronise with their Latin names. Tell them that January & February are two added months and you will get blank looks.

Go further and prove that January is named after the two headed god, Janus, one head looking back at the old year, whilst the other head looks forward into the new one and you will get: "You what?"

NfkDumpling Thu 22-Oct-20 19:23:30

But I did learn that last bit of your post Spangler about the origins of the months of the year. And, we did black history about slavery, where black slaves came from and came to become slaves and other sorts of slavery from serfdom onwards. I also had practical experience of the workings of a car engine! But I still don't know which order to do plus/minus/times/divide!

varian Thu 22-Oct-20 19:47:10

Let's just have a better definition of a good education.

Ancient Greek and Latin, but no science or maths beyond O level is not a braid education.

Callistemon Thu 22-Oct-20 19:49:29

Ellianne

Not a clue! Are they names of grape wines?

grin

Love it!!

Callistemon Thu 22-Oct-20 19:52:45

not useless Greek and Latin!

Latin is not useless
And we could learn a lot from Ancient Greeks and indeed from legends.

Aesop's Fables anyone?

suziewoozie Thu 22-Oct-20 19:54:37

There’s nothing eduacated it intelligent about using a reference many your audience won’t ‘get’. It’s yet another example of his emotional stupidity that he though we might be impressed.

Callistemon Thu 22-Oct-20 19:54:42

between a rock and a hard place

Is that ok?

grannyqueenie Thu 22-Oct-20 20:10:07

Indeed suziewoozie, just a wee bit elitist methinks and sign of how out of touch with the majority he really is!

Spangler Thu 22-Oct-20 20:10:23

varian

Let's just have a better definition of a good education.

Ancient Greek and Latin, but no science or maths beyond O level is not a braid education.

How about university degrees in science and law, is that a good education?

Callistemon Thu 22-Oct-20 20:11:41

A moot point, Spangler as it neglects the Arts and the Classics.

sparklingsilver28 Thu 22-Oct-20 20:16:34

My seventeen-year-old GS reading Greek mythology as part of his A Level English Literature Course and loves it all. I did ask him the other day why as he is studying English Literature no English authors in the reading list. He said if it had been Jane Austen or Shakespeare he might well have considered giving up. I have to admit both bore me silly!

MissAdventure Thu 22-Oct-20 20:20:55

Nope.
Never heard of any of it.

varian Thu 22-Oct-20 20:21:49

I didn't know that BJ had degrees in s science and law, like Margaret Thatcher. She went to a state school, and ended up with a much better education, although she did get a lot wrong when it came to politics.

sparklingsilver28 Thu 22-Oct-20 20:22:18

BJ's buffoonery a clever cover for not answering the question or subject being addressed to him.