Gransnet forums

News & politics

Scottish government Covid briefings on the BBC

(156 Posts)
Alegrias Fri 11-Sep-20 13:14:37

A thread on another topic kept straying into people's opinions about the Scottish Government's Covid briefings being dropped from the BBC schedules. It seemed to raise a lot of comment so I thought I'd start a new thread.

So, what does everyone think? Feel free to diverge into what you think of NS's performance smile Do you think the WM government should have more briefings?

Callistemon Fri 25-Sep-20 17:12:40

The sooner the better!

Elizabeth1 Fri 25-Sep-20 17:12:02

Go Nicola go.

Jaberwok Wed 23-Sep-20 10:09:08

Why don't you want to socialise with your cleaning lady Elizabeth? My mother had a cleaning lady for many years and after my mother died she cleaned for my step father and finally helped me enormously after he also died a year later with clearing the house and preparing it for sale. All those years of coffee break chat, and genuine welfare interest on both sides paid enormous dividends! She was a lovely lady now sadly dead, but it was a long time ago and perhaps we were just lucky.

Elizabeth1 Wed 23-Sep-20 07:32:23

I’ve got the answer yes my cleaner can continue as long as she’s covid free symptoms, wears a mask,has the windows open keeps six metres away from us and uses all the hygiene-methods advised anyway she’s not coming to socialise whew thank goodness for that

Elizabeth1 Wed 23-Sep-20 03:42:14

Can someone help me with knowledge of the most recent briefing. Can cleaners continue working in private houses.

Alegrias Tue 22-Sep-20 10:42:08

Here's a thought that occurred to me this morning; so many people say that they don't understand the rules, and why we are being asked to do things. Do you think more people would understand and comply if they heard them first hand from the mouths of government leaders and scientific advisers, rather than through the filter of the press?

For instance this morning, there is the intentionally leaked news about pubs closing at 10pm in England. If Johnson had announced this properly in his address to the nation, with rationale, would that have been a better approach, in terms of having people understand?

Alegrias Mon 21-Sep-20 18:59:31

Oops, yes, you're right Wheniwasyourage, he was an MEP, not an MSP. It was a typo, thank you for pointing that out.

Wheniwasyourage Mon 21-Sep-20 17:51:54

Alegrias, you're quite right about Alyn Smith's speech, but as I'm sure you know, and it's just a typo, his "leave a light on" speech was his last as an MEP, not an MSP. Very inspiring and moving.

G1asgowgal Mon 21-Sep-20 17:01:22

I think it’s appalling that the BBC are threatening to drop Scotlands Covid briefings by Nicola Sturgeon. They are broadcast on BBC Scotland anyway. But really I would like to know ...Why?? Is it because she is showing Westminster up by being up there every day telling us how it is.
I was not a lover of the SNP before and I am still sceptical but through this pandemic Ms Sturgeon has done a very good job in telling us how it is, and pulls no punches. That in itself is really refreshing from a politician. And be aware if Boris is still in power at the May elections, the chances are the SNP will win an overall majority here. And that will be the beginning of the end for the Union. Which will in my opinion be a great shame.

Callistemon Fri 18-Sep-20 17:04:00

I think it more likely that many are protesting about the pro-Tory, pro-Brexit bias that we have seen for the last five years, but looks set to become even more right-wing under the aegis of the new Tory chairman.

It's more likely people haven't paid the BBC licence fee because they don't watch much TV and they prefer entertainment on Netflix etc. They think that the BBC is dated and fuddy-duddy.
They probably couldn't care less about bias one way or another.

Alegrias Fri 18-Sep-20 16:58:19

twitter.com/AlynSmith/status/1306166603369910278

Alyn Smith is a superb politician. If you can, check out his last speech as an MSP; "leave a light on so we can find our way home"

biba70 Fri 18-Sep-20 16:50:41

Repeat from other thread: 'Brilliant speech in the HoC by Alyn Smith. Perhaps someone could share it here, I seem to be unable to.

Unelected politicians? You have seen nothing yet.'

varian Fri 18-Sep-20 16:06:17

The great TV licence turn-off: Figures reveal 237,000 fewer families have paid the BBC fee in the last year as viewers switch to Netflix

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8736711/Figures-reveal-237-000-fewer-families-payed-BBC-fee-year-viewers-switch-Netflix.html

It appears that these are households all over the UK, not just in Scotland, so the suggestion that they are all protesting about a perceived anti-Scottish bias is a bit absurd.

I think it more likely that many are protesting about the pro-Tory, pro-Brexit bias that we have seen for the last five years, but looks set to become even more right-wing under the aegis of the new Tory chairman.

Alegrias Fri 18-Sep-20 15:30:50

Jane10

'Other voices and perspectives will now feature alongside' at last!

Well there was nothing stopping the BBC doing that in the first place Jane10.

No comments about the U-turn from anyone else who was so adamant about the briefings being a bad thing?

stewaris Thu 17-Sep-20 20:57:42

paddyanne I probably know a lot more about the water industry in Scotland and the state it's in as I worked their for 17 years. The east of Scotland has always been incredibly drier than most people suppose. Scottish Water are frequently issuing statements/bulletins about being careful with water. Have a look here to see what I mean and I have seen reservoirs in the Pentlands in the same state. In fact, I was part of a group looking at the effects of drought in Scotland round about the mid 2000's. www.heraldscotland.com/news/18405259.drought-warning-water-levels-record-low/

stewaris Thu 17-Sep-20 20:50:59

Granny23 I've just read this from the Helensburgh Advertiser and it doesn't mention anything about a deep water port. In fact it says Astute class submarines will be based there.
www.helensburghadvertiser.co.uk/news/18165391.faslane-naval-base-growth-vital-argyll-bute-future/

Jane10 Thu 17-Sep-20 20:34:52

'Other voices and perspectives will now feature alongside' at last!

suziewoozie Thu 17-Sep-20 20:19:38

Oh dear quick get the smelling salts for certain posters.

ptarmigan Thu 17-Sep-20 20:16:54

Good news ! smile

Alegrias Thu 17-Sep-20 20:15:29

I think we'll call this a victory, shall we ladies?

news.stv.tv/politics/bbc-to-continue-broadcasting-coronavirus-briefings?fbclid=IwAR11ZbJ9ARalgQkc8I46AmSmiNJvDTXceIuGZ2_qDvYK2H7mhH9rxWCLzWM&top

varian Thu 17-Sep-20 10:47:48

Is that 237,000 households in Scotland Paddyanne or in the whole of the UK?

paddyanne Thu 17-Sep-20 10:20:43

the commonwealth is just a way of keeping the "empire" image making "Britain" feel its still important ...its not! Barbados is ditching Lizzie next year ,wait for the domino effect as other nations realise they neither want nor need to be tagged as "british"

paddyanne Thu 17-Sep-20 10:17:41

Elizabeth 237000 households have cancelled ,we dont want or need anti Scotland propoganda every hour in so called NEWS .

paddyanne Thu 17-Sep-20 10:15:34

Stewaris The Scottish government was acting in the "four nation approach" to covid ..hence late lockdown until Bojo gave the say so ,no financial aid until Bojo said so and yes the care home issues were 4 thats FOUR nation approach too.Check the massive numbers of deaths in care homes not just in Scotland but the other 3 nations in teh UK and WORLDWIDE.as the family who lost an uncle in April in a cre home I can assure you I am in no way defending that policy .But to lay it at the door of ONE of the 4 natons is ridiculous .

I will ask you IF Scotland was already an Independent country would you vote Today ..to join a union making the UK .Wpild you hand over your income and get half(?) back ,let someone take your assets and add them to THEIR export figures allow them to make decisions about the people who live here when they know nothing about us and care less ...oh and the biggyHand over the rights to our Water ,power ,fishing and farming for them to bargain with ..sadly England is running out of water and will be in dire straits within the next 30 years WE have more fresh water in ONE loch than there is in the whole of England ....you happy to hand it over and pay to supply them? Not me ,I've never been happy about us PAYING to be added to the national grid either ..while the other "nations" get PAID FOR THE SAME THING .This is NOT a union its a hostage situation and from what I can see many are suffering with Stockholm syndrome ....maybe you need help.Independence IS coming ,it has long been needed.

Elizabeth1 Thu 17-Sep-20 09:53:45

lots and lots of folks today are no longer paying their bbc tv licence they’re making a statement hooray grin