Gransnet forums

News & politics

Thank you Britain for signing up to destroy my home

(63 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sat 01-Apr-23 06:04:15

Where shall I go once it is all gone?

The UK’s latest trade deal with Asia will see the UK abandon European regulations and previous tariffs on palm oil at the behest of Malaysia – a country notorious for its rife logging, resource extraction, exploitation, corruption and land-grabbing.

Signed today, the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) will bring a mere 0.08% to Britain’s economy at the expense of environmental safeguarding against a product linked to mass deforestation.

The demand for palm oil has decimated forests across south-east Asia.

HousePlantQueen Sat 01-Apr-23 15:28:53

I try very hard to avoid buying any products containing Palm Oil, irrespective of any trade deals, but it can be very difficult. My heart breaks when I see what is being done to this planet; it is rarely to feed people who are starving or who need sustainable crops, but to fill the pockets of those with wealth beyond avarice or to sustain the political careers of those with no concern other than their own.

choughdancer Sat 01-Apr-23 15:44:38

HousePlantQueen

I try very hard to avoid buying any products containing Palm Oil, irrespective of any trade deals, but it can be very difficult. My heart breaks when I see what is being done to this planet; it is rarely to feed people who are starving or who need sustainable crops, but to fill the pockets of those with wealth beyond avarice or to sustain the political careers of those with no concern other than their own.

Well said HousePlantQueen!

Callistemon21 Sat 01-Apr-23 15:48:52

MerylStreep

Callistemon
Do want the short answer or the short answer: no and, eh, no.
Sad but true.

Too true!

Oreo Sat 01-Apr-23 15:49:03

MerylStreep

Callistemon
Do want the short answer or the short answer: no and, eh, no.
Sad but true.

Agreed.
The EU imports a lot of palm oil so being in or out of the EU makes no difference.
Palm oil isn’t a bad product and some countries rely on the money it brings in.
If giving aid and advice to Malaysia doesn’t work ( about loss of habitat for orang utans) then what else can be done.

Oreo Sat 01-Apr-23 15:50:44

HousePlantQueen

I try very hard to avoid buying any products containing Palm Oil, irrespective of any trade deals, but it can be very difficult. My heart breaks when I see what is being done to this planet; it is rarely to feed people who are starving or who need sustainable crops, but to fill the pockets of those with wealth beyond avarice or to sustain the political careers of those with no concern other than their own.

Hang on, it brings money into the country for Malaysia and gives people much needed jobs ( palm oil.)

Freya5 Sat 01-Apr-23 16:02:15

You think your beloved EU does not import goods that contain palm oil.
Shall asked my family to check in their area.
Personally do not buy anything with palm oil in.
Always choices to be made.

Allsorts Sat 01-Apr-23 17:03:37

If there wasn’t the demand we wouldn’t need palm oil. It’s awful any species being affected by man. I’m sure we all avoid such foods and buy seasonally, I wish.
However, when people say they ho on holiday to far flung places, do they never think of their carbon footprint.

CoolCoco Sat 01-Apr-23 17:05:49

Its not just about palm oil, though. is it? Its the whole ridiculousness of trumpeting a trade deal with countries the other side of the world that will have little impact on our economy and in no way is better economically or environmentally than being a member of the biggest trading bloc on the planet that is on our doorstep. Plus - why didn't we have a referendum about whether we wanted to join???

ronib Sat 01-Apr-23 19:41:18

Richard North writing today in Turbulent Times - Brexit:conflict of interests points out that

The immediate impact of joining CPTPP is slight as we already trade with 9 of 11 countries. Apparently it’s about the geopolitical dynamic in world trade over next 20 to 30 years.
By the end of this decade, CPTPP will be the largest trading system by a margin.

Well maybe yes and maybe no is my first reaction.
Prior to joining the EU I thought we traded quite well with Australia and NZ so long distances weren’t necessarily a huge problem?

Since we have definitely left the EU, I think it’s about time to take the next steps rather than be stuck in some limbo of indecision and inactivity.

As for the palm oil question, surely it’s upto Malaysia to recognise and take responsibility for its own geography? I don’t think that the UK will have a surge in demand for its product?

Dinahmo Sun 02-Apr-23 16:32:20

ronib

The following is taken from Sky News website. There is only one perspective. Forests are being destroyed and as a consequence orangutans are losing their homes and many are losing their lives.

"How does palm oil production affect orangutans?

Forests are bulldozed to make way for palm oil plantations, displacing orangutans who then try to find food in the new plantation areas.

Between 1,000 and 5,000 orangutans are killed each year to protect the crops, the Orangutan Foundation International said.

Indonesia and Malaysia produce more than 85% of the world's palm oil and are the only remaining home to orangutans, with fewer than 118,000 currently surviving, according to the World Wildlife Fund. "

In 2022-2023, Malaysia produced 18.8 million metric tons of palm oil, which is used in about half of supermarket products from shampoo and cosmetics to chocolate, peanut butter and cereals.

Dinahmo Sun 02-Apr-23 16:41:17

The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has identified deforestation as the main threat to 85% of all species described in its red list.

Here's a link to its website: www.iucn.org/resources/conservation-tool/iucn-red-list-threatened-species

As an aside - we eat a lot of peanut butter and it is quite easy to buy brands that are free of palm oil.

ronib Sun 02-Apr-23 17:52:50

Dinahmo Well in the UK, families are being destroyed by the cost of living crisis. I am sorry that orangutans are under threat of extinction and from now on, shall try not to buy products containing palm oil. But there has to be a limit on my personal responsibility for the actions of foreign governments.

I don’t accept that a zero tariff dropped from 2 per cent is going to have a significant impact on the lives of orangutans.

It is the responsibility of Malaysia and Indonesia to tackle deforestation with the help of conservation organisations surely?