Gransnet forums

AIBU

Why do womens clothes designers do this?

(93 Posts)
BlueBelle Thu 31-Mar-22 19:16:38

I went to buy a jumper online today and the size choices given were 12/14 or 16/18 why do so many manufactures leave out the 14/16 size
A 12 would be too small for me but an 18 huge is it too much to ask for a 14/16 size ?

Amalegra Sat 02-Apr-22 12:20:30

Quite agree! I am a size 8/10 but so many brands lump together 6/8 and 10/12. The former is too small, the latter too large especially round the hips. I often end up buying a size 10 dress for the bust and taking it in round the hips as dresses, however they size them, are my particular nightmare. All except ‘Next’ whose size 8 dresses do actually fit!

Happysexagenarian Sat 02-Apr-22 12:21:43

I'm a size 16-18 depending on the brand and style. I often see clothes in the M&S Per Una collection that I like but I have to buy size 22 or 24 for them to fit! I bought a few things last year from Roman which were a good fit and true to size.

Kamiso Sat 02-Apr-22 12:41:11

I keep getting ads that look interesting only to find the only size available is an 8! Ancient history for me!

knspol Sat 02-Apr-22 13:05:16

Have been buying size 14 for last few yrs but in the last couple of months size 14 's have proved too big in both M&S and Hobbs - I haven't changed size or shape at all in fact 2 lbs heavier! If men's sizes are accurate and constant why on earth can't women's sizes also be the same?!

123kitty Sat 02-Apr-22 13:27:45

I don't think anyone from our clothing stores bothers to read Gransnet, how stupid when they would have all this free market research!

kevincharley Sat 02-Apr-22 13:41:38

And bra sizes are a nightmare too! Tried on 5 recently, all marked the same size. Not one of them fitted but all for different reasons!

grandtanteJE65 Sat 02-Apr-22 14:09:33

Here it is difficult to get women's clothing in the smaller sizes, whether they are simply marked XS, S. M, L and XL or numbered.

The explanation given is that adult women are generally too large to fit into a size 36 or 38 any longer and even size 40 is in little demand, so these sizes are mainly used now for clothes intended for 15-16 year old girls.

Looking at the general population, I feel that the makers have a point. Where I live, few women over the age of 18 would have any hope of fitting their backsides into a pair of size 36 jeans!

Few women below the age of 70 need the smaller sizes, and of course no designer or maker of clothes takes into consideration that the 70-80 age group might not want to go around in teenage schoolgirls' hand-me-downs.

Supergran1946 Sat 02-Apr-22 14:22:34

One of my favourite brands does jumpers in 10/12 or 14/16. I am more a 12/14 so feel reluctant to buy online as I cant be sure 10/12 will fit ok. Why cant they stick to being able to buy 10,12,14 etc

ourjude Sat 02-Apr-22 14:54:35

According to clothes manufacturers I'm a 13 year old girl - that's if I don't want sleeves down by my knees and jeans/trousers that have to be turned up several times!

I'm 5'2", a size 12 and take a wide size 3 shoe. Weirdly for wellies I have to take a size 5... And people wonder why I hate clothes shopping!!

M&S has usually been one of the best shops for clothes that fit me. H&M (where I shop only occasionally) I have to often go up 2 'dress' sizes and Primark short jeans/trousers would be regular length in other shops. These days I'm more likely to shop for clothes in the charity shops because I don't mind losing £3-5 on clothes that don't fit. I just donate them back to the charity.

As for shoes, well, unless I want something like pretty little butterflies on them (needless to say I don't) I'm very limited.

Having said all that, a nice thick 'standard' size winter jacket does have it's uses when it is cold - the sleeves are so long they more than cover my hands (so gloves not always necessary grin) and my backside is kept nice and warm by the extra length...

AreWeThereYet Sat 02-Apr-22 14:56:10

I buy quite a few M&S high waist jeggings. It was quite interesting (to me, anyway!) that on occasions where I have bought two pairs at a time they often fit differently, and can be different lengths. I have noticed that often one pair will be made in China and one in Pakistan or Bangladesh. It would be logical that all suppliers would use the same measurements for each size, but I don't think the quality control aspects are there to actually check that the sizes are correct. Despite being labelled as a 16 on one occasion the jeggings were at least a size smaller and had to be returned. I don't take any notice of what size I buy any more - I start trying on the size I expect to fit then just work up or down until I find one that does.

OnwardandUpward Sat 02-Apr-22 14:58:10

The absolute worst I have seen is Goose Island where I saw a top sized as 8-16! Being an actual size 16, I would never shop there.

It allows for shoddy workmanship, too, no doubt because usually clothes are made to a pattern thats dictated by it's size. It just means it will look loose and cool on the size 8 and the size 16 will look squashed and stressed out.

CleoPanda Sat 02-Apr-22 15:08:28

I used to fit size 11 jeans from M&S in the days they did all sizes.
Agree that sizing is rubbish these days.
Another huge bugbear of mine is dress lengths. Spent 2 hours online looking at dresses.
“Knee length” - whose knees? My 5’4” friend or my 5’ 8” friend. No measurements given.
“Model is 5’ 11” and wears a size 8” the dress is “knee length” - Great! If the dress is just below her knees, will it trip me up?
On one site, Some of the dresses had Approx lengths - so why were some of the “Midi” dresses longer than the “maxi” dresses? Why were the “mini” dresses barely long enough to reach my hips?
I gave up - irritated, annoyed, angry!!
What a fiasco. Do people just order, unpack and realise it would swamp a giant, repack and return? Try again and find it reaches to their mid thigh when they wanted a below the knee dress.
What a waste of time, energy, transport, costs .

OnwardandUpward Sat 02-Apr-22 15:11:59

LovelyLady

Antonia
I’m a large lady needing outsize clothes.
M&S did fit me when their sizing was generous. Sadly now their sizing is inconsistent. I bought 2 multi packs of pants same size yet 2” difference.
I tried to buy a petticoat and told they didn’t have my size and was directed to their on line provision. I do try to support the local store and don’t feel, on line shopping does give them support.
Where are the shops for bigger sizes?

If you're looking for fun or funky tops, Tee Public shop.teepublic.com/ sizing go up to 5XL.

Redbubble www.redbubble.com do an A line dress that goes up to 4XL and they have thousands of prints to choose from. These choices are probably best for youngish at heart people wanting something a bit different, though.

For more traditional clothing , Landsend www.landsend.co.uk/ is brilliant as they go up to size 28-30 and Yours Clothing yoursclothing.co.uk is pretty large sizes too- they cater for sizes 14-40!
Simply Be is sizes up to 32 as well! www.simplybe.co.uk/

Lots of choices out there, but all online as there doesn't seem to be anything worth buying on the high street, sadly.

annodomini Sat 02-Apr-22 15:23:40

The Roman Originals on-line catalogue has a 'Curve' range that goes up to size 26, with some lines up to 32

GreenGran78 Sat 02-Apr-22 15:23:54

I once did my own 'size survey' in our local supermarket. I'm 5' 0", and buying clothes is a nightmare. Waistlines around my hips, sleeves and legs far too long, and that's without the actual sizing problems you all mention.
I stood for 10 minutes, and counted how many women of around my height walked past me, and was amazed at just how many there were.
I wrote to some of the popular outfitters, pointing out my research, and that they were missing out on a huge market by not catering more for short women. Most didn't reply, and those that did said that they would 'bring the matter up with our buyers'. Needless to say, nothing has changed. The cost of dealing with so many returned items must make quite a dent in their profits, but they don't seem to realise this, and sort out their sizing.

TwiceAsNice Sat 02-Apr-22 15:40:19

Years ago M&S did 11/13/15 and they fitted perfectly. I am not short 5ft 5 but their regular trousers are too long. Some of the short are just right sole are too short.

When I buy in Boden sale ( too expensive full price) their 14 or Medium is perfect. I agree Iwoah other shops would do 12-14 instead of 14-16 .

Musicgirl Sat 02-Apr-22 15:42:06

I like 12-14 rather than 14-16 as that is exactly my size on the top half. I am also ok with S,M,L etc. I find M&S medium is a perfect fit as it is in many shops but I ordered Woolovers and found their idea of medium in most of their cardigans and jumpers was enormous and small fits perfectly. In Zara I would probably need XXXL! Fat Face is very generously sized too.

Musicgirl Sat 02-Apr-22 15:46:30

Also, why are M&S trousers so long? Do they think we are all about 6 feet tall? Previously regular length was generally fine for my average height and my mother had short. Now we need short and extra short respectively.

granjan Sat 02-Apr-22 15:49:06

Casdon

What drives me mad about M&S at the moment is the length of the jeans and trousers. I’m regular length, but now some are too short, some are too long, some are perfect. I even picked up three pairs of identical design jeans yesterday in three different colours, put them on one rail to decide which to have - and there was a two inch length difference between the pairs. I’m taking a tape measure with me next time..

Yes! M& S jeans!!
It’s driving me mad, have several old pairs of M&S jeans, size 8 regular length, all fit perfectly. Any new jeans I have tried on from M&S, size 8 too small, and far too long even the short length. Size 10 tends to be loose, and of course, far too long. I haven’t shrunk!! Must check the lengths when I go to M&S next time!

fluttERBY123 Sat 02-Apr-22 16:08:28

Size 18/20 and proud. I am only 7 lbs overweight. Puzzled by pictures of obese people who bemoan being a size.22. It's all very confusing. I have lost 3 stone but have only gone from being a 20/22 to an 18/20. Cotton Traders, used to get M n S.

Kathmaggie Sat 02-Apr-22 16:14:22

I bought jeans from next 2 years ago in a size 11 they were perfect!

Caleo Sat 02-Apr-22 17:24:44

They should enter the sizes in inches or cms as do more helpful sellers on Ebay. For instance, armpit to armpit is very useful to know. Also crotch to waist seam.

Caleo Sat 02-Apr-22 17:28:07

I have given up about getting the right leg length and always keep iron-on hemming web in the house.

Wendy Sat 02-Apr-22 18:21:38

I find 10/12 and 14/18 when I want 12/14 a pain.

harold Sat 02-Apr-22 18:24:42

I think that M&S trousers are too long because they have a delusion that we all go around wearing 3 - 5 inch high heels.