Gransnet forums

AIBU

AIBU to start thinking about self defence in the home and when I am out and about?

(116 Posts)
Sago Tue 30-Jul-24 20:12:04

In the light of recent events, I have started to think about what I could do to defend others and myself in the hopefully unlikely event of an attack in my home or elsewhere.

Before you start to judge, I have had a knife held at my throat and been threatened with death, this happened when I was a hospital patient and defenceless.
We were also victims of a serious burglary, thankfully we were out.

Am I alone in thinking this?

MissAdventure Tue 30-Jul-24 23:08:07

I think it's a good idea.

Not lessons full of fancy moves, but techniques so that you can at least have a go at getting away, should the worst happen.

Chestnut Tue 30-Jul-24 23:36:40

Out and about I used to walk with confidence but no more! Now I feel totally vulnerable, but I've always felt my only hope would be to talk my way out of it (like in the movies). I couldn't possibly fight them off physically but maybe mentally. Hopefully my razor sharp mind would outwit them and make them change their mind about attacking me. 😎

RosiesMaw2 Tue 30-Jul-24 23:45:17

No.
Unless you are Superman or Wonderwoman , you will come off worse- maybe a lot worse if you attempt to fight back, sad but true.
When the girls went travelling in dodgy parts of the Far East they were advised to keep some small change, maybe a library card or bus pass in a purse which they could afford to lose- throwing loose change on the ground a short distance away might prove enough of a diversion to enable them to run. Real money of course lived in a body belt under their clothes.
But do consider preventative action regarding your personal safety -
do not carry unnecessary cards on you - and be prepared to hand over your purse or bag without a struggle -
don’t have your address on your key ring,
don’t use a backpack in urban areas,
don’t look bumbling or frail, stride out confidently
It goes without saying not to go down lonely alleyways night or day
always let somebody know if you are heading out alone especially to unknown places
keep your car doors locked when you are driving, handbag out of sight eg in the footwell
especially in summer when we may be leaving windows and patio doors open -just don’t!
Oh and don’t leave your daughters Land Rover Discovery in your drive unlocked for 4 days! (Got away with it though) grin

Galaxy Tue 30-Jul-24 23:50:20

Dont walk your dog in the daylight either.
Sorry but it's just a way of hoping it will happen to someone else.

RosiesMaw2 Tue 30-Jul-24 23:51:22

Galaxy

Dont walk your dog in the daylight either.
Sorry but it's just a way of hoping it will happen to someone else.

What?
I don’t actually understand either statement.

Galaxy Wed 31-Jul-24 00:04:53

The woman murdered the other day was killed walking her dog in the morning. Perhaps we shouldnt do that either. We imagine that we can keep ourselves safe if we do x,y, and z, it just doesnt work like that.

Catterygirl Wed 31-Jul-24 00:14:19

Hmmh, difficult. When young was taught judo and ju-jitsu by my stepdad. In my twenties, boyfriend was an army physical trainer who taught me aikido including how to protect me from a knife attack. In my thirties was attacked from the back when returning home from the local butcher in West Hampstead. I went into defence mode as heavily trained and grabbed him from the back of his neck and went into a forward roll on the pavement but before I could complete the move he let go and ran away. It took me ages to tell my husband and to recover mentally.
In my sixties I tried tai chi and the teacher was enormous. He taught me how to disable a big guy like him. I did it. However, what if they have a knife?

HattieTopper Wed 31-Jul-24 00:14:43

I feel exactly the same as SAGO, very wary when I am out and about and when at home, my doors are always locked. We were burgled a few years ago. Our sons tell me that my home is like Fort Knox and I am being over cautious because if I had a fall, no-one could get in, but I prefer to sleep in my bed and know I have done everything I can to ensure my safety.

I don't think there is much we can do to ensure our safety when we are out and about apart from keeping our noses out of our mobile phones and being aware of what is going on around us. I now only use cards for paying for goods so I am not standing at an ATM machine getting cash out. I have an account with our local taxi company so when I book a taxi it is pre-paid so I am not carrying cash around with me. My card is in a RFID blocking case attached to a zip in my cross body bag so it cannot be cloned by someone passing me with a cloning machine.

I purchase most things online and to be honest, I would never have to set foot outside my home ever again if I didn't want to.

I am over cautious but I would rather be that way than not. We are living in a terrible world now, a world we have never seen the likes of before in my lifetime anyway. I am not talking about wars, I am talking about violence from young people who do not care who they hurt, kill, rape or rob.

Deedaa Wed 31-Jul-24 00:37:17

A friend of mine who lived in a remote farmhouse told me that,if her husband was away, she always wore knickers under her nightie in case there was a fire and she had to be carried over a fireman's shoulder. I think she was quite disappointed that it never happened.

OldFrill Wed 31-Jul-24 00:46:15

It's prudent to have the odd item around the place that could be useful if self defence if necessary.
Personally I've got a terrier.
grin

Callistemon213 Wed 31-Jul-24 07:50:34

I don't think there is much we can do to ensure our safety when we are out and about apart from keeping our noses out of our mobile phones and being aware of what is going on around us.
It's worrying seeing young people (women and girls especially) out running or walking and looking at mobile phones or with ear buds in, oblivious to the world around them.

M0nica Wed 31-Jul-24 08:49:58

We are living at a time that is what the world, including the UK, has always been like. It is just that we have had a century of exceptional domestic peace.

Despite 4 break-ins, none now for over 25 years. I have never been afraid inside my house or outside and DH in his working days travelled a lot. All the break-ins were opportunist and, as the police said to us, the burglar, if you had disturbed him would have been more afraid of you than you would be of him.

if you have valuables that are known about and will attract theft; expensive jewellry (think footballer's partners) or works of art, or are known to keep seriously large sums of money in the house, then that is different and you will need serious security.

But we cannot live our lives in a country as peaceful as the uk is - and it is - is a state of fear about something that is unlikely to happen. You could be living in Gaza, the Congo, Somalia or some of the many teaming cities of the developing world.

PamelaJ1 Wed 31-Jul-24 08:51:55

Boz

I thought you were talking about karate and that sort of self defence, which at 80 I won't be taking up.
It may be a good idea to keep a knife or gun in the house, but would you have the strength or courage to use it?
It must have been truly awful to have a knife held to your throat so my sympathy for your fear.

Firstly I presume we all have a knife in the house. I’ve got lots and some are very sharp. They are in a drawer in the kitchen, not exactly handy if an intruder comes in the front door? Are you suggesting that we have one strapped round our waist?

Re. Guns, my DH has just got rid of his. They were kept in a locked gun safe and I never knew where the key was kept. Cartridges were kept in a separate safe. We have lived in the country all our married life, my DH worked in farming so guns were almost mandatory.
So in our house , full of guns and knives, were we any safer than those who don’t have our armoury? I don’t think so.

Chestnut Wed 31-Jul-24 08:54:51

I agree with all the preventative measures, but then people start accusing you of victim blaming. Why should you have to do this, or that? This especially applies to the way women dress. Why shouldn't young women go out in what is effectively their underwear? Well I believe common sense should tell them it's provocative, just as common sense tells us to lock our front doors and keep our phones and purses out of sight in a crowded place. Of course we shouldn't have to do all these things but sadly we do, otherwise we risk becoming a victim.

kircubbin2000 Wed 31-Jul-24 08:58:36

Shut those little top windows too. I forget their name. My friend lost all her good jewellery after we passed 2 young lads on bikes as we left her house. They were slim enough to enter through the bathroom window.

kircubbin2000 Wed 31-Jul-24 09:00:49

Yes Chestnut. My neighbours 18 year old has developed a very curvy figure and set off yesterday in what looked like knickers.A lot of new young men around now.

fancythat Wed 31-Jul-24 09:04:39

Sago

Elegran

Someone posted mentioning keeping a knife or gun in the house. There are two relevant points here. One is that unless you know exactly what you are doing with a gun (or a knife, come to think of it) it would be another danger rather than a defence. You should warn an intruder that you have a gun and are prepared to use it before pulling the trigger - and if you sound less than 100% confident in your ability, a determined attacker would just reach out and take it from you, then threaten YOU with it.

The other is that in the UK, guns are not in common use, unlike in the USA. Because householders do not normally have a gun to hand as a planned defence strategy, housebreakers do not normally carry one as an attacking weapon. The result is that homicide using firearms is a rare event in the UK. If the general public were to adopt them, the incidence of gun deaths would start to rise, and violence would escalate. We would all be MORE at risk of attack, not safer.

To own a gun in the UK you have to have a license, this is not easy to obtain.
If you have a license your gun must be kept in a locked cabinet the ammunition must be in a locked safe separate to the gun cabinet.
A gun cannot be propped up by the bed ready to go.

And they take a long while to get a licence as well.

fancythat Wed 31-Jul-24 09:07:16

Chestnut

Out and about I used to walk with confidence but no more! Now I feel totally vulnerable, but I've always felt my only hope would be to talk my way out of it (like in the movies). I couldn't possibly fight them off physically but maybe mentally. Hopefully my razor sharp mind would outwit them and make them change their mind about attacking me. 😎

"Do I know your mother?" is supposed to work.
Never had to use that, so no idea if it would work in practice.

Callistemon213 Wed 31-Jul-24 09:09:47

kircubbin2000

Shut those little top windows too. I forget their name. My friend lost all her good jewellery after we passed 2 young lads on bikes as we left her house. They were slim enough to enter through the bathroom window.

I locked myself out many years ago; returning from dropping DC1 at playgroup, I had invited other mums and younger babies and toddlers in for a coffee, only to find I had no keys.
Someone went to her house and phoned the police, they said they'd come and break a window! DH was somewhere in the Far East.
Another agile friend climbed in through the downstairs loo top little window.

It doesn't make a difference, though. A jemmy can be used to force a window open. PVC replacement windows are quite easy to force.

Galaxy Wed 31-Jul-24 09:10:15

Crikey goodness knows how those men manage on the beach with all those women in bikinis. Maybe they (the men) shouldnt be allowed it if that's the case.

NotSpaghetti Wed 31-Jul-24 09:25:16

You say self defence and the defence of others In the light of recent events...

I'm assuming you mean protecting the person, not just stuff?

Scooter-driver "bag grabs", pickpocketing and warm weather burglaries I think are more likely than a massacre to be honest. Though these are more usual by people we know than "outsiders"

If you want to take a personal safety course I'd go for it.

The way to protect groups of small children (if that is where this comes from) is probably to have a very secure entry system and I'd think a known "emergency" drill for the children.

You could fit a panic alarm in your home if you wished. Ours used to have one with a panic button in each downstairs room.

Chestnut Wed 31-Jul-24 09:35:36

Galaxy

Crikey goodness knows how those men manage on the beach with all those women in bikinis. Maybe they (the men) shouldnt be allowed it if that's the case.

Well there's a time and a place. I think everyone expects swimwear on the beach and around seaside areas, but it's not so clever when young women are walking around near naked in a city or town.

Callistemon213 Wed 31-Jul-24 09:38:56

Re burglaries. Do you have Neighbourhood Watch schemes set up where you live?

pascal30 Wed 31-Jul-24 09:49:24

I remember we all had to do a self defence course when I was training as an RMN.. I went home and showed my young son who immediately overpowered me.. so sensibly I decided I'd just try to get out of the way in the event of an attack..

Luckily I never feel unsafe in my home and stick to lighted streets, preferably busy, if I'm out at night..

henetha Wed 31-Jul-24 10:19:33

The downside of living alone (which I like now) is that I'm nervous at night. I use chains and bolts wherever possible, and lock doors at all times. And I have an alarm.
I think it's too late for me to learn self defence, but I strongly believe that younger people should learn some self defence moves. My grandson goes to a class every week and I really wish my granddaughters would too.