Gransnet forums

AIBU

Put out that light!

(60 Posts)
DotScot Mon 15-Sept-25 15:54:27

This perhaps seems quite petty, but it is a real bone of contention in this house.
My husband is in his early seventies and is becoming more and more of a ‘grumpy old man’. He should have been born pre WW2, so that he could have been an Air Raid Warden. He’d have loved it as his favourite phrase is ‘Put out that light’! I realise that a lot of families have a father like this, but now that our children all have their own homes, it is me who collects the complaints.
I have a timer plug on a lamp in the front room so that if we are out, or at the back of the house, it comes on and looks from the outside as if someone is at home. It switches off later automatically. If my husband finds it on when he is at home, he often switches the lamp off, doesn’t tell me, and then of course, it cannot switch on automatically when we are out. It also means that I can’t switch it on with the app if I am returning home at night on my own, when I would like to put the light on to feel more secure coming into an empty house.
I have tried to explain all this to him, but he just keeps saying 'It shouldn’t be on when it isn’t needed.' I have explained that ‘need’ is not just an immediate thing, and it’s not just his ‘need’, but he refuses to discuss it further.
I try not to be wasteful, but it’s one light with a low energy bulb. It might be on, on its timer, when we are in the house, (ie 'unnecessarily') for about 4 hours, perhaps a bit longer in winter when it gets dark earlier. Am I really wasting a huge amount of electricity? Am I being unreasonable?

StripeyGran Mon 15-Sept-25 15:58:09

Blimey! Put out light on. I dare say you have worked all your life one way and another.

Sorry about your unhelpful partner.

Aveline Mon 15-Sept-25 16:04:36

DH is being unreasonable and, basically, a bit stupid! Sort him out!

petra Mon 15-Sept-25 16:05:41

Assuming it’s a 40w? If so it is costing a fraction of a penny to run.

Babs03 Mon 15-Sept-25 16:07:49

Your DH is being a pain, over to you with how to deal with it.

pably15 Mon 15-Sept-25 16:12:07

I agree with what the others say, it happens so often, houses being burgled when there are no lights on when the owners are out, he'd have something to grumble about then.....leave it on..

Shelflife Mon 15-Sept-25 16:14:57

No you are not being unreasonable! If he is unable to grasp your explanation is he confused? Hope not , but my husband has Alzheimers and for a few years prior to diagnosis there were times
when he just couldn't understand my reasoning.

Georgesgran Mon 15-Sept-25 16:15:48

Leave it on!
I’ve outdoor dusk to dawn lights which cost next to nothing to run and give me a bit of security in my dark corner.

grumppa Mon 15-Sept-25 16:19:16

DH is being totally unreasonable.

Astitchintime Mon 15-Sept-25 16:25:21

Blimey! He would be really annoyed if he lived near us………the number of street lights lit up in daylight hours is off the scale!

GrannyGravy13 Mon 15-Sept-25 16:58:15

I am frightened of the dark (I know it’s silly) I like outside lights and hall stairs and landing lights on as soon as it becomes dusk.

I couldn’t live with someone constantly overriding my wishes/needs.

I hope you can come to a compromise with him.

Granmarderby10 Mon 15-Sept-25 17:14:48

Crikey!! What decade was he born in?
Just tell him the light’s for you and that you matter. And to stop behaving like some throwback Dad.

windmill1 Mon 15-Sept-25 17:24:24

Lord, what a Grumble Guts! (Apologies). But you have to turn a deaf ear to his whinging and grizzling or, before you know it, he'll reduce you to a single candle in the living room which he will STILL grouse about as he sits in 'his' chair, wearing his greatcoat, stovepipe top hat and fingerless mittens!

Mt61 Mon 15-Sept-25 17:34:54

Tight bugger. LED lights hardly cost anything to run.

eazybee Mon 15-Sept-25 19:26:39

My father was exactly like this; he would switch all the lights off except the one room we were in, and if I had a light and a lamp on he would switch one off; hall and landing lights out, no outside lights, and when he was in my house he would turn out any lights out he saw, which was why the boiler was switched off and the central heating. He turned the light off on the brand new freezer he had bought, so when they returned from holiday all the contents were ruined and the stench was awful.
There was no reasoning with him: you don't have to pay the bills was his response.

Grandmaofone Mon 15-Sept-25 19:39:14

This is in my experience a ‘man thing’ as women do not do this

Grandmaofone Mon 15-Sept-25 19:39:52

or what Mt61 said

PaynesGrey Mon 15-Sept-25 19:58:29

A 40W bulb equivalent is 470 lumen. Typically it consumes about 6-9 watts of electricity.

Here's how to work out the cost.

Convert watts to kilowatts: 6 watts / 1000 = 0.006 kW

Calculate daily cost: 0.006 kW x (say) 8 hours/day x (say) £0.25/kWh = £0.012 per day i.e just over a penny for 8 hours.

(At the moment, I pay 0.2216 per kWh.)

Calculate yearly cost: £0.012/day x 365 days/year = £4.38 per year.

valdavi Mon 15-Sept-25 20:17:53

I turn off lights that DH leaves on. He doesn't really like turning anything off - likes the TV on constantly when he's home, even if he's in the garden & not likely to watch it for ages.
I'm not like OP's husband - if we're downstairs I'm OK with the kitchen, hall and living room lit, but I'll switch the upstairs lights off.
All that to say, not always a man thing!

Visgir1 Mon 15-Sept-25 20:56:22

You GNers are so kind.
I would tell him if he turns that light off again, I will unplug it and hit him with it so it's definitely off.
Now I know that sound violent, but it might get the point across!

DotScot Mon 15-Sept-25 23:50:59

Thanks to you all for your supportive and amusing messages. It is reassuring to know that I'm not being unreasonable. I smiled at some of your suggestions, although I may not act on all of them wink
Thanks to @PaynesGrey for the calculation I was after. I will have that up my sleeve the next time the conversation arises!
@GrannyGravy13, I am also afraid of the dark, and also know it's silly, but. (I try to take the bins out when it's still light, but if I've left it too late, I have to steel myself to do it.) Having lights on in the house really does help.
@Shelflife I don't think he has Alzheimer's but I do think that he is unnecessarily worried about money. We're not rich, but we have enough. My view is that the money we have should be being used now in a way that aids our comfort, helps us to enjoy life and makes memories for us and our children and grandchildren while we can. We can't take it with us, as they say.
On a practical note, perhaps I will tape the light switch on the lamp so it can't be turned off!

icanhandthemback Mon 15-Sept-25 23:58:57

I once had this with my ex-husband after I put the bills in his name. He made such a fuss about it, I turned on everything I could in the house before I went out to work and left them running all day. He was livid but the next day got his own back when he took the fuses from the fuse box to work! I'm not sure that is any help to you but it probably isn't worth getting into too much of a fight about.

Grannycool52 Tue 16-Sept-25 09:25:31

I agree that OP's husband is behaving outrageously.
OP, would your children collectively sit down with him and explain?

Oreo Tue 16-Sept-25 09:44:50

I thought the OP had something to do with Dad’s Army from the title😂
I’m a great switcher off of lights in empty rooms but need lots of light in a sitting area.

mabon2 Tue 16-Sept-25 13:51:01

I have always switched off lights going from one room to another. My Pa used to say "Who do you think is paying for the electricity?