Gransnet forums

AIBU

Being dropped by a friend for something better

(74 Posts)
MirandaIV Thu 18-Sept-25 10:05:34

I have been in a regular group of four people playing a sport for a year now.
We have a WhatsApp group of just the four people involved that we use to organise the event and people usually let me know a week in advance if they can’t do it due to a holiday or work commitments, et cetera, which I considered to be perfectly reasonable.
This week, two days before the event, I asked everyone to confirm that were okay to do it and one of the group said no, because she had chosen to play a game with some other people that she deems better than us. (They are also better than her but needed someone to fill-in that week). She is very ambitious to get into the club teams and play with better people and literally just dropped us because she thought this was a better option.
I had to scramble around to try to find someone else to fill-in and to be honest was extremely hurt as I had considered her to be a friend. We have been for dinner at each other’s houses several times and have had long personal chats. I have been a bit shocked at times as to how bitchy she is about other people, but stupidly thought I was different and that she valued friendship with me.
I’ve been pondering this for several days and to be honest I’m still hurt. She has made no attempt to apologise, although on the day she did say jokingly in a message on the group that she ‘felt guilty’ and I replied with ‘you should!’ Which was probably read as a joke (or not), however, I have heard nothing from her and not had an apology.
I now have a dilemma. I have another lady who is happy to play instead, but probably won’t be a long-term option as she may be moving away soon. Generally, I can find someone else though.
Personally, I feel like I can’t just pretend this never happened, but I hate the thought of the confrontation of speaking to her or removing her from the WhatsApp group so that it’s obvious she’s no longer playing with us. On the other hand, I no longer want to play with her or be friends if this is how she treats me. I have also heard her talk about other peoples groups in a derogatory way and lie to get out of playing with them, so I know that she’s quite brutal about it.
It’s now time for me to organise next week’s group and I am seriously wondering whether I should remove her from the WhatsApp group, as otherwise I feel she will just assume she can join in with us again when it suits her and she has nothing better to do. I have already asked the other lady to play again but need to confirm the other players as usual. So far, I’ve been an absolute coward and asked them individually outside the WhatsApp group.
I honestly consider her behaviour to be selfish and bad mannered and hurtful.
If she had even apologised to me, I might be able to get over it, but she hasn’t even tried.
Lots of people don’t like her, and I now I understand why.
Could I ask for advice as to how you would handle this?
I will definitely bump into her quite often at the club and will sometimes have to play with her in group sessions, et cetera. However, I do feel that I could cope with being superficially friendly in those situations.
Am I being over reacting to this?
Other friends at this club have said that it’s dreadful and not acceptable behaviour at all.

Polly7 Fri 19-Sept-25 14:50:27

...I'm sure you will find a way, diplomacy always good. Iv a group of coffee mates. One in particular talks about others and yet is very liked ( it's like 2 faced).she controls a lot without considering or asking others views or feelings. I'm told it's ocd that causes her to be like this!? As she needs things to go her way or anxiety is too high 🤷‍♀️. Just hard as sometimes feel really offended and wonder if it's personal ?

icanhandthemback Fri 19-Sept-25 14:55:28

I think you are getting friendship and sports mixed up. They are 2 different arenas so keep them as that. You seem to have reacted quite badly to her not telling you more than 2 days before but maybe she was trying to find a way to tell you but then you popped the question so it was easy for her just to say no. If she wants to improve her game by playing for a better group when she can, why shouldn't she? It shouldn't make any difference to a true friendship; you should be pleased that she is getting opportunities that make her happy.
As for her being a friend, she doesn't seem to have deliberately done anything heinous to you, she just hasn't acted the way you might have done. Either continue the friendship and accept her for who she is or walk away because you don't want to end up with her talking behind your back or lying to you. At least you know what you are likely to get if you remain closer friends.
At the end of the day, you have a choice to decide whether to escalate this or just accept that this is what happens in Sports' Groups. I see it all the time in my friend's group but she doesn't take the lack of availability personally no matter what the reason unless people continually let her down.

Polly7 Fri 19-Sept-25 15:00:40

Sometimes it's better not to make a crises out of drama
Maybe take a step back put yourself in a bubble from her, be yourself. Go silent if she offends you or gossips It will sort out. If you ever have a need to say anything pls ensure it's in quiet soft tone without any emphasis. That way you keep your counsel politely. In my experience turning other cheek is better than being judgmental of her. We all can be this or that to do with bringing, events, traumas etc. look for the good points. We all have them

win Fri 19-Sept-25 15:14:15

You are definitely over reacting it is a weekly arrangement but hopefully not set in stone. People should be able to say I can’t play next week, her reason why is none of your business

LemonJam Fri 19-Sept-25 15:15:29

Yes I do think you are overacting a little.

You asked for suggestions:

1) - organisation of the next group meet up: Just send a polite group WhatsApp message as you would normally do and ask her if she enjoyed playing with the other group last time and whether she would like to continue playing regularly in your group or instead join the other group. Her decision. Explain you managed to get someone to fill in for her last time but it would be helpful for her t6o update the group as to her plans going forward. Plus explain you will need to find someone else to take her place again if she is not planning to join the group next week, to make up numbers.

2) How did you take on this organisation role in the group? Do you want to continue? You could suggest taking it turns to organise the sessions, ie a shared approach where all are equally engaged and involved?

3) Do you see yourself continuing your "friendship' with this lady. Sounds like you will have difficulty as you now describe her as selfish, bad mannered and she's hurt you. Be civil to her, in line with your view that you feel able to maintain a "superficial" friendship with her as you may need to play future games with her as part of your club. Just see what happens...and what you want to do once your hurt feelings have died down a little.

4) Personally I would avoid talking to other people in the club about this incident and your hurt feelings, that runs the risk of people taking sides etc.

I hope she replies in good faith to your group message and in a civil manner. If not or she ignores your group message, that will also help "the group" decide how to go forward and to look for her replacement. The 2 men will also see that you have been calm, reasonable and polite- the bigger person.

It will work itself out one way or another....

lainieb56 Fri 19-Sept-25 15:30:55

Of you mentioned what the group.actulay did when it met up, it.might bring a better prospective on why she went elsewhere.
Ot could be anything from a card foursome to a tennis group. Or maybe, as she's been you yours, a dining group!

Mojack26 Fri 19-Sept-25 15:51:33

Sorry, I think you aretotally over reacting. Yes she should have let you know but if she wants to progress I get it. I was actively involved in all racket sports, at a competitive level, mainly tennis
and badminton. I always played a level above when I could as I wanted to get better. I hated playing with people who werenot as good,no challenge.... I would find someone else if you are playing for enjoyment...someone that would fit in your group

GrammarGrandma Fri 19-Sept-25 15:52:16

BlueBelle you are right. TLDNR stands for Too Long: Did Not Read.

chattykathy Fri 19-Sept-25 15:57:41

I think I would be tempted to line up someone else if possible and the put a message on WA saying Hi XXX just to let you know I've managed to put a four together for next week so you don't have to worry about letting us down again.

Snowbelle Fri 19-Sept-25 17:31:56

It isn’t making sense therefore it’s not true in my opinion.

If she’s a real person she’s one of many other people and not your problem. She’s presumably an adult so let her go and live her life in whatever way she chooses and stay out of it, only keep good people in your life. If people let you down (which they will) move on they are not worth your time and energy. Enjoy your game of whatever it is.

Danma Fri 19-Sept-25 17:59:00

You say she’s a friend, dinners together and personal chats, so why not just talk to her and clear the air

Robin202 Fri 19-Sept-25 18:02:59

Just ask her if she intends to play in your group anymore as if not there is someone else waiting to join you. If she says she prefers her new team. delete her from your whatsapp group.

Flippinheck Fri 19-Sept-25 18:12:12

A calm, honest conversation would do much to clear the air.

Hellsbelles Fri 19-Sept-25 18:24:28

I was dear to my ' friend ' .
We'd go out for long days , whatsapp several times a day , be in Facebook contact daily etc.
Dropped like a hot potato once I became ill and not so available / drive us places .
We still see each other occasionally & she likes to tell me how great her social life is with her new friends .

Scribbles Fri 19-Sept-25 21:22:44

@BlueBelle: TLDR = Too long, didn't read.

@crossstitchfan: It wasn't intended to be "rude"; it was a statement of fact. I got halfway through the rambling first post and it all sounded like a primary school playground squabble. I just couldn't be bothered to read any further but, if the OP had been a little more succinct, I might have read to the end and been able to state an opinion.

hellymart Fri 19-Sept-25 22:36:08

I can understand that you are hurt and upset by your 'friend' (o former friend)'s behaviour but I think it's time to let it go. I also play in a tennis club (I'm guessing this is a mixed doubles four) and I know how incidents like this escalate and somehow get blown out of all proportion. And I know what you mean about not getting the men involved. Men are, on the whole, much more straightforward in their friendships and are often mystified by women's complicated relationships (at least, in my experience!!). Try to be the better person and rise above it. It sounds as though it might be the time to introduce the new lady to your four and let this 'friend' go and play with other people. A quick text to clarify if she wants to be involved in the future or not, might solve it. You're spending a lot of mental time and energy on her and she's really not worth it. Hope it all works out and you continue to enjoy your games, which is the main thing!

Sueinkent Fri 19-Sept-25 22:41:28

Drop her. Play with someone else. Life is too short to bother with people who don’t bother with you.

Lathyrus3 Sat 20-Sept-25 09:50:29

I’m mystified by the OP and others saying, don’t get the men involved.

They are involved, this is their foursome as much as the OPs.

Why do people think they’ve got no voice in what happens? I think people would be up in arms if the OP was here saying that one of the men had decided she wasn’t part of their foursome anymore and had got someone else to play instead!

Doodledog Sat 20-Sept-25 09:59:05

I don't think you can expect total loyalty from someone who plays sport with you, although I do understand being irritated at being let down at the last minute, if it meant you might not be able to play.

Having said that, if she knew that you would react as you have, maybe she was scared to let you know her plans.

In your position, I think I would do as others have suggested, and explain that you and the other players were inconvenienced by her dropping out, and ask for a commitment by a sensible deadline. You can make it a two-way one - you need to know that you have a full team, and if she hasn't responded by Tuesday (or whatever) you will find another player.

Shandy3 Sat 20-Sept-25 11:41:00

Make a new WhatsApp group without her

sparkle1234 Sat 20-Sept-25 12:02:17

Personally I hate users . I would feel like you do and have been treated like this myself . I would add the new player to the group and give her priority over the other one . Let her see on there that you will only use her in the future to fill a gap as the last resort . In effect use her back . She's not a friend I'm afraid , people like her don't have any .
Play the game with her if you need her for it and don't socialise with her outside of her .
I hate the absolute arrogance of some people who think they are so important they can just pick up and drop people to suit themselves

whywhywhy Sat 20-Sept-25 13:40:45

You all sound like a bunch of kids! Just delete her and move on. She’s rude.

Delila Sat 20-Sept-25 14:36:28

This sounds like a lot of upset about very little. You knew her before this latest incident and continued your relationship with her - so no new shock discoveries about her character. On this occasion she is teaming up with another group, she gave notice, said she felt guilty, caused inconvenience, etc., but I really doubt she actually said she deems the other people better than your usual group. I suspect that’s your interpretation, but this may well turn out to be a one-off and, until you know better, I’d leave it at that and carry on with the usual arrangement.