Gransnet forums

AIBU

Is it allowed?

(80 Posts)
DollyD Thu 16-Apr-26 14:46:59

I was watching a reality programme over the weekend and one of the contestants made an unintentional sexist remark, which made me roll my eyes but was nothing too bad just a clumsy way of expressing himself.
Some of the other contestants were laughing at him because of it and rolling their eyes but one kept shouting out, “You can’t say that! You can’t say that!” over and over , which grated on me at the time.
My thoughts are, yes, he should be able to say “that”, we can vocally disagree with him and otherwise disapprove of what he said, but surely, he is allowed to actually speak, as long as it’s not illegal in any way.

Wyllow3 Fri 24-Apr-26 10:58:45

One day some woman will assist him to realize he isn’t gods gift to womanhood 🤣

Dressagediva123 Fri 24-Apr-26 08:04:18

He needs calling out for sexists remarks - and sounds like someone did .

pea007 Mon 20-Apr-26 10:02:44

When Scarlet said “you can’t say that David”, it was her way of telling him that he can’t say that and not be judged for saying it. Which he has been, and quite right too.

Gizzy48 Mon 20-Apr-26 09:43:43

Whiff:
“If anyone hits you, hit them back” doesn’t always work, and it’s not civilised. Many’s the person who’s tried to hit back at a bully and been hit even harder as a result. Bullies not liking it is a myth. I once, and once only, told my 4yo, who complained that my 5yo had hit her, to hit her back. One minute later she came to me and said “she hit me again”

I was a primary teacher. I told my classes that hitting people was wrong, but hitting back was fighting. Our school had a policy that you report bullying, you don’t turn it into a fight.

Conversation between me and two kids:
“J, if M pushes you and you push him back, will it teach him a lesson or make him push you again?”
J: “Teach him a lesson”

Me: “M, If J says you pushed her, and she pushes you back, will that teach you a lesson or will you push her back?”
M: “I’ll push her back.”

QED I think.

As for the idea that if someone calls you bad names you can put a stop to it by badmouthing them back: sorry, but that’s ludicrous.

petra Sun 19-Apr-26 20:50:57

Kitty55

I believe respect for others starts in the home from a young age. Blame the parents. Lots of people think things but wouldn’t say it publicly. Long story short the man is a numpty.

I’m afraid to say that the views and opinions of their piers at school have far more sway than their parents.

petra Sun 19-Apr-26 20:47:05

DevonshireSalop

I think simply put, David Haye was talking off the cuff when he was trying to put across that his ex was beautiful to look at, but inside she is ugly. We can all think of something we wish we’d said better—with hindsight.

You have completely got it wrong.
What he inferred was, not such good looking women have to be extra nice to attract a man.
Back in the 60s it was the opinion of a lot of men that the not so good looking women were easy

Kitty55 Sun 19-Apr-26 19:54:03

I believe respect for others starts in the home from a young age. Blame the parents. Lots of people think things but wouldn’t say it publicly. Long story short the man is a numpty.

icanhandthemback Sun 19-Apr-26 19:15:16

David Hayes doesn't appear to be a i nice human being. Just watching him bullying Adam has shown him up for the nasty piece of work he is. I think the sooner he is tv, the better. I don't think he is a good role model for anyone.

Doodledog Sun 19-Apr-26 18:44:31

When did people start worrying over what is 'allowed'? It seems such a playground way to think, and it worries me that we are being infantilised. I know there are those who like to have hard and fast rules, so they know how to stay on the straight and narrow, but isn't it better to think for ourselves?

Of course there are (and IMO there should be) laws against inciting hatred or violence, but otherwise we are 'allowed' to say what we like, just as others are 'allowed' to object. People who consistently make comments that many consider offensive are likely to find themselves without friends, or they will gravitate to likeminded friendship groups where their comments and behaviour are acceptable. Otherwise, odd slip-ups are usually ignored, or a clumsy expression is explained away if it is pulled up. Also, people judge what is acceptable depending on the company - even children know what they can say in front of Granny and what has to be saved for friends only.

What do those wondering about what is allowed think will happen if someone steps over an imaginary line and says something forbidden?

FranA Sun 19-Apr-26 18:32:41

Interesting point. However if it was a public broadcast to someone who pays a licence fee, then surely she has the right to say that such remarks should not be broadcast.

Dreadwitch Sun 19-Apr-26 18:00:15

We all the right be be offended, but we also have the right to say what we want so long as it's not illegal. I think we've taken it all a bit too far now, if I want to say women are lousy drivers then I can, same for men should be doing the decorating lol if that's sexist and offensive then that's on whoever takes it that way not me.

WithNobsOnIt Sun 19-Apr-26 17:56:46

This man is obviously an insulting
nob and very old school. In that he is still judging women by their looks.
But at least he is being honest.in his ignorance. And sone may say real.

It is still very entrenched unfortunately and has got worst due to on demand porn and idiots like Andrew Tate.

I would be annoyed and angry if he said that about me. But that would be my business and no one else's. And l would not want them to take offence on my behalf.

I live my life based upon my values and experiences.

Do you think this sort of deeply rooted male mind set really went away due to the Woke and Thought Police. Who know better than everybody else about everything. And have the divine right to impose their views

I find the Wokes to be deeply creepy at some level in their judgements. And the way they want to control people's behaviour. Holier than thou. On size fits all

Like a sort of deep gratification and pleasure they obtain through fear and Social Brainwashing.

I think Skinner and Freud would have found them interesting subjects

We have become a Nation of little frightened mice who do not have the courage to speak up and express different opinions.

As the old song used to to go.

It's illegal,immoral or it makes you fat.

Mojack26 Sun 19-Apr-26 17:18:46

I don't really watch any reality tv..hate most of it. We are living in that kind of litigious society now...you can't say anything for fear of offending someone and suing you or taking you to court!!! People need to grow a thicker skin

rafichagran Sun 19-Apr-26 17:11:07

I can't say I was offended, what he said was unpleasant and misogynistic, but as much as he can say it. I have the right to disagree.
What he said was clumsy abd very badly put, but it gave Bev and Charlotte the right to call it out.
To be brutal what he said came across as clumsy and to be honest made him look thick.

Dulostwo11 Sun 19-Apr-26 16:54:53

what is sexist remark ?

Babsbada Sun 19-Apr-26 16:49:46

Sexist comment is never never acceptable. End of story.

GANNET Sun 19-Apr-26 16:11:18

DollyD

^Graphite^says:
“As a woman, I claim the right not to have to listen to a man making derogatory comments about a woman’s appearance.”
The point is you haven’t got the “claim to right”, you can disagree verbally when you hear something sexist, you can ignore, walk away but you have no claim or right to restrict what someone says, unless it’s actually illegal.

Absolutely. The Hayes clip was just funny - he was just really clumsy and stupid and kept digging a bigger hole. What he said was actually accurate. For both males and females if you are perceived as less attractive than your good looking friend then you do tend to need to be funnier, wittier, or kinder to get noticed. Some people have to make more effort than others. Sadly it is a fact of life - having watched The Other Bennet Sister this was the case completely. It’s not right or fair but that’s generally the reality.

AJKW Sun 19-Apr-26 16:08:53

I don’t watch TV, but if you wish to live in a democratic country then freedom of expression is an absolute must even when you don’t like what is said.

Realky Sun 19-Apr-26 15:44:11

Her own words, not mine!!!

Realky Sun 19-Apr-26 15:43:15

Free speech didn't doesn't mean that we have to live in a society where you can be insulted by anyone who wants to insult you. Dolly is one is the ugly minded brigade who believes that the weak should put up with verbal bullying.

Realky Sun 19-Apr-26 15:39:12

Frankly, I think Dolly believes that anyone who calls her an ugly bird is entitled to do so. I have to agree about that. I mean I can say that they shouldn't, but why should I when she can't be bothered to stand up for another woman? That's her argument after all.

HobbyCat Sun 19-Apr-26 15:15:31

I’m glad he was allowed to say it because it clearly demonstrated the type of man he is to a large audience. I already thought he was a prick and it confirmed it.

Essexgirl145 Sun 19-Apr-26 15:11:33

Why object, if you watch that kind of rubbish, be prepared to accept anything.

knspol Sun 19-Apr-26 14:32:40

Don't watch reality progs so never heard the remark. I would say it shows the people on these shows as what they really are and unfortunately there are many people who look up to and try to emulate these so called celebs.
If you don't like the comments don't watch the programmes, perhaps the fewer people who tune in then the fewer such progs will be aired.

monami Sun 19-Apr-26 14:13:06

its all gone too far, we will be born without voices in the fure