specki4eyes
I run a needlecraft group and we are all of the same mind about this show. We learn nothing from it; none of us would be seen dead in any of the garments they make; the camerawork and musak are positively schizophrenic and as for the so called pointless comedienne...she's so unfunny she makes us want to cry.
If only the BBC would take a lesson from Sky Arts and create some craft programmes that are educational, informative and entertaining.
Yes, but. Do all the worthy sewing programmes on Sky Arts get as many viewers as the Sewing Bee? Are they as entertaining?
You and your group are also watching the progamme from a pedagogical view, not an entertainment view. Would you watch Masterchef in order to learn to cook or Top Gear if you wanted to learn to drive? I doubt it The Sky programmes and Sewing Bee are doing 2 entirely different things, and you cannot compare them.
Sewing Bee has changed and adapted over the years to meet its audience and increase the number of viewers. To begin with its aim was to star the country's best home sewers but after the first couple of years, sewers were queuing to be on it, but the better the sewers, the harder the tasks got so that the contestants had very little time to interact with the camera and compere and the finished garments, although often technical masterpieces were very uninteresting.
So, I seem to remember, the programme had a year off and came back with the concentration on having a diverse range of contestants, even though their sewing skills, though excellent were not necessarily professional level. Personally, I think it makes for a much more entertaining prgramme
As for the clothes they make, if none of your class would wear any of the clothes made on the programme, what on earth do they wear? The range of clothes that have been made over the programmed is wide and diverse, I would agree that the makeover round is pretty dire. It has only once in my memory produced a wearable garment.
But both the pattern round and final round often produce very wearable clothes. In my time I would have undoubtedly have worn some of the Regency heroine dresses made last week. In fact I have a photograph of myself at my graduation ball some 60 years ago wearing a long evening dress very similar to most of those on show last week, which I had made myself.