I agree with Brenda ( and others), despairing about any criticism of Israel's actions being shouted down as anti Semitism. This is not true, certainly not in my case and is disingenuous. To a certain extent, I an sympathise with Israeli Jews who were born there and have had to live with hostile neighbours all their lives, but sadly the most vociferous seem to be almost professional Zionists, people born elsewhere who have chosen to live in Israel. They are partly responsible for the illegal land grabbing due to the housing demands and are the loudest when it comes to accusing those who do not agree with their policies of aggression. Greg Dyke said the same thing on Any Questions on Radio 4 yesterday. To be honest, like the LibDem MP said, if I lived in Palestine, I would fire rockets. It has made us all take notice.