Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Mind your own business is what I really want to say

(72 Posts)
Skydancer Mon 13-Dec-21 18:54:00

My elderly Mum lives with my brother 300 miles from me. I have to ring his mobile to speak to her. He is, and always has been, extremely greedy and mean. I can't stand it as I am the opposite. He is extremely wealthy and we are quite comfortable. Recently we helped my DD (obviously his niece) to buy a house. I haven't told him as I don't consider we are really part of one another's lives. However she's doing "change of address" and has to include him as he sends a card at Christmas. I KNOW this will mean, when I next speak to him, he'll ask everything about it including how we managed to get the money together and will say something like how I kept it quiet. What I want to say is: Mind your own business / you never show any interest in our lives / you don't tell me what you get up to / what is it to do with you? ... etc. All these answers are obviously rude but it's how I feel. Can you think of a polite way to deflect his (inevitable) questions about her house purchase and how we managed to afford it? I actually believe his obsession with money is an illness.

MayBeMaw Mon 13-Dec-21 18:58:17

I think “You’re breaking up” and “I’m running out of battery” might do it?

Sago Mon 13-Dec-21 18:58:33

How will he even know you helped her ?

Kim19 Mon 13-Dec-21 19:01:31

Evasive answers are the way go, I think. Aggression would get you nowhere other than hurt and uncomfortable. When he asks specifics (how rude!) you simply need to cover your answers with 'can't exactly remember' or 'bits of this'n' that'. Perhaps you can refer him to your husband if he can handle him better.

ElaineI Mon 13-Dec-21 19:01:37

Why does he actually need to know? My brother has never asked how any of our DC bought a house. He has only ever been pleased for them (we never helped them). I would never ask about my niece or nephew buying a house. Again I would be pleased for them. Just say they got a good deal or something.

Nonogran Mon 13-Dec-21 19:04:45

My response would be, to the first query he raises us “Why do you ask?”
Answering a question with a question is a good swerve!
If ferl compelled to answer just be economical with information.
You could feign that you don’t know how she afforded it, followed by “in any case it’s none of my business.”
For example,
When I get asked about my DD not having children I just say “I don’t know and I don’t like to ask because it’s none of my business”. That soon shuts them up.

Dickens Mon 13-Dec-21 19:11:48

... buy your mother her own mobile?

And cut him out of the conversations all together.

You can get one of those 'big-button' simple-to-use mobiles which are quite popular, unlocked and pretty cheap, if you think she's not able to manage a smart-phone.

And frankly, politely telling him that your financial arrangements between you and your DD are a private matter is not rude.

I would tell him that you don't feel it necessary to offer an explanation of how you "managed to afford it". If he's not in any way involved financially, then it really is none of his business.

... or, tell him that you forgot to mention you'd had a huge win on the Lottery and bought your DD a house with it and... "can I speak to Mum now, please" smile.

You don't need that kind of pressure, and shouldn't have to put up with it.

Dickens Mon 13-Dec-21 19:16:00

Nonogran

When I get asked about my DD not having children I just say “I don’t know and I don’t like to ask because it’s none of my business”. That soon shuts them up.

... how rude, and what an intrusive question for people to ask you about your DD. Prying, probing busybodies really are the pits.

Shropshirelass Mon 13-Dec-21 19:16:27

We managed quite easily would be my answer for both questions. It really isn’t any of his business and don’t tempted to explain anything. Yes, a bad line breaking up works wonders too. Good luck.

Farmor15 Mon 13-Dec-21 19:17:40

Agree with Elaine1 - if he asks, say "why do you want to know?" My mother had an inquisitive relative and sometimes used this tactic. It needs to be said in a non-aggressive way, as if you are just curious.

M0nica Mon 13-Dec-21 19:18:28

Why not just ignore the question and follow up with something anodyne about the house

Bro: How could she afford that? How much did you give her?
You: Yes, it really is a lovely house but she will need to redecorate to get it to her house

And do that everytime he asks.

M0nica Mon 13-Dec-21 19:18:57

Listen to any politician being interviewed, you will soon get the hang of it.

Farmor15 Mon 13-Dec-21 19:20:01

Sorry, it was Nonogran who suggested "why?" but Elaine and others have good ideas too.

MerylStreep Mon 13-Dec-21 19:34:24

As he’s a mean person I would tell him oh, the money was just sitting in the bank, we don’t need it and they may as well have the money now instead of waiting ‘till we’re gone
I really really hate mean people so when the opportunity arises to wind them up, I do.

Germanshepherdsmum Mon 13-Dec-21 19:35:10

Don’t I remember you from a while back? Obviously Mum still hasn’t got her own phone. Why not just tell him he’ll have to ask your daughter about the house as it’s her business not yours. And do get Mum her own phone!

Smileless2012 Mon 13-Dec-21 19:44:31

You could just tell him to mind his own business; I would.

Skydancer Mon 13-Dec-21 19:44:52

Some great answers here. I am ready!

oodles Mon 13-Dec-21 19:46:14

Maybe if he does you could say something simple like she's careful with her money, isn't it lovely that she has been able to get herself a nice place
If he persists, maybe say are you wanting to make a contribution, I find you her bank details if you want or maybe you could just pop a cheque into her Christmas card lol

JaneJudge Mon 13-Dec-21 19:48:39

I hate controlling siblings

Peasblossom Mon 13-Dec-21 19:50:19

Smileless2012

You could just tell him to mind his own business; I would.

Me too ?

Pammie1 Mon 13-Dec-21 19:53:02

If he is rude enough to ask, then I don’t think any of the answers you’ve quoted are rude. It is, as you say, none of his business. I wouldn’t tell him that you’ve contributed - it’s not relevant. If he assumes you have or if your DD lets it slip and he asks, then I think that’s the time to firmly tell him that the details and reasons are between you and your DD.

nadateturbe Mon 13-Dec-21 19:57:34

M0nica

Why not just ignore the question and follow up with something anodyne about the house

Bro: How could she afford that? How much did you give her?
You: Yes, it really is a lovely house but she will need to redecorate to get it to her house

And do that everytime he asks.

I'm with Monica. Just refuse to answer. If he keeps on asking, in the end just say I don't really want to discuss it. Nosy beggar!

Gingster Mon 13-Dec-21 20:05:37

A friend of mine always avoids answering anyone’s nosiness by saying ‘Oh don’t ask’, in a jokey , polite way? It usually stops the conversation in its tracks and then changes the subject.

Dickens Mon 13-Dec-21 20:10:42

Farmor15

Agree with Elaine1 - if he asks, say "why do you want to know?" My mother had an inquisitive relative and sometimes used this tactic. It needs to be said in a non-aggressive way, as if you are just curious.

... "why do you want to know?" That sounds like a good tactic!

I'm curious about your name... "FarMor" is a Swedish abbreviation for "father's mother"!

Audi10 Mon 13-Dec-21 20:19:19

Well I would say it’s none of your business