Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Mind your own business is what I really want to say

(73 Posts)
Skydancer Mon 13-Dec-21 18:54:00

My elderly Mum lives with my brother 300 miles from me. I have to ring his mobile to speak to her. He is, and always has been, extremely greedy and mean. I can't stand it as I am the opposite. He is extremely wealthy and we are quite comfortable. Recently we helped my DD (obviously his niece) to buy a house. I haven't told him as I don't consider we are really part of one another's lives. However she's doing "change of address" and has to include him as he sends a card at Christmas. I KNOW this will mean, when I next speak to him, he'll ask everything about it including how we managed to get the money together and will say something like how I kept it quiet. What I want to say is: Mind your own business / you never show any interest in our lives / you don't tell me what you get up to / what is it to do with you? ... etc. All these answers are obviously rude but it's how I feel. Can you think of a polite way to deflect his (inevitable) questions about her house purchase and how we managed to afford it? I actually believe his obsession with money is an illness.

hollysteers Wed 15-Dec-21 19:24:36

MayBeMaw I love your answer.
Shout ‘Hello? Hello?’ Down the line if that question comes up.
Problems with the line, stick with it and no one upset.

Mummer Wed 15-Dec-21 17:56:12

I tell you what IS rude! Asking someone about their personal finance arrangements!!! What an absolutely revolting man, if you excuse my displeasure? I would look at his fizzog-grin and say"wouldn't you love to know?!" Then ignore him! How very very rude of him! Don't let him bully you any more that's my advice! It's your business darling nobody else's

Mariew1 Wed 15-Dec-21 13:09:36

Best answer, works every time.

Nannagarra Wed 15-Dec-21 09:09:37

The ploy of “forgetting” relevant details works well.
Suggesting to your brother she’s inherited the gene to be careful with money might flatter and distract him.
Claiming to have no knowledge as someone else has been involved removes responsibility from you. Refer your brother to your husband as he alone has discussed the purchase of the house with your daughter.
Alternatively, massively exaggerate your contribution so it is clear to your brother it’s untrue and therefore no longer a subject to be discussed.

welbeck Tue 14-Dec-21 23:43:37

i disagree with some these approaches, not in a theoretical but a pragmatic way.
he has control of the OP's mother.
she can only communicate with mother through him.
maybe mother cannot operate a phone.
if he chooses, he can cut off OP from speaking to mother.
they are 300 miles away; she cannot just pop over to see her.
so, for her own reasons, i think it wise to keep on the right side of him.
avoid too much directness, which does sound rude.
be vague, yes, she's very fortunate. how's things in mother's house?
that's what i think anyway.
good luck Op.

Coco51 Tue 14-Dec-21 23:27:22

Just say you are not privy to the ins and outs of your daughter’s finance, and would not be so rude as to ask her!

grannygranby Tue 14-Dec-21 22:30:30

'What do you mean?' is a good one for awkward questions.

Urmstongran Tue 14-Dec-21 21:12:56

M0nica

Listen to any politician being interviewed, you will soon get the hang of it.

??? love it MOnica!

coastalgran Tue 14-Dec-21 20:21:50

If he enquires ask him what he has been spending his money on, how did he afford the car, house, sweater etc that should shut him up or tell him the accountant you now have wants to go over mother's finances to make sure they are in order and that any pension etc she is due is in her bank. You probably will never see/hear from him again.

Allsorts Tue 14-Dec-21 18:48:14

Just say, mind your own business. He likes or lumps it.p

tictacnana Tue 14-Dec-21 18:44:39

If he isn’t part of your lives, then tell him to mind his own business or wind him up by saying”Wouldn’t you like to know?!”

Pinnywinch Tue 14-Dec-21 18:32:47

What is a DD? I'm presuming it's a daughter but why the double D?
A DC?

Caro57 Tue 14-Dec-21 15:40:13

It’s rude to discuss money but if he feels it’s his right to know / ask he should speak to the property owner!!

colliemum Tue 14-Dec-21 14:37:12

grandtanteJE65 It is the OP's daughter, not her brother's.

4allweknow Tue 14-Dec-21 14:13:43

They obviously found ways and means and as it is their business I haven't asked would be my response.

Smileless2012 Tue 14-Dec-21 13:48:47

"housewarming present" great idea Jessgrin.

Jess20 Tue 14-Dec-21 13:45:20

I can't see why this bothers you unless there's some sort of family competition over the moral highground by emphasising the richer and poorer theme - if it's simply at the level of him being a nosey git then tell him he can ask her if he's interested, not you. He surely won't know if it's bought or rented will he? Unless he does some significant detective work on Zoopla etc.... Personally, if confronted directly, I'd try and turn the conversation to the housewarming present he's obviously planning to send her as that's the only real reason he needs to know.

win Tue 14-Dec-21 13:14:09

Danish Farmor15
I am Danish too

Cid24 Tue 14-Dec-21 13:13:55

My daughter has a great response if I ask a question too far
“‘I think you’ll find its none of your business!” Said with humour but gets the point across !

Sandrahill Tue 14-Dec-21 12:44:58

Great reply Nonogran. I would say same!

Granny1810 Tue 14-Dec-21 12:37:28

He doesn't have to know if he asks just say she's moved. He wouldn't know if she has rented or not. As the other have said buy your Mum her own phone.

Daisend1 Tue 14-Dec-21 12:20:07

It is no ones business whoever they may be WHAT you do with your money.What you want? to say ?then say it
What can he do about it Start as you mean to go on. Once you
give in to his questions and comments it will never end.

jaylucy Tue 14-Dec-21 12:12:54

It's probably being mean that has given him the lifestyle he loves so much!
As others have suggested, why not buy your mother her own phone ? There is a range of phones available that are just basic , without all the bells and whistles and with a larger screen, and keys and also compatible with hearing aids.
If by any chance he queries how DD can afford to buy her own place, beyond commenting that it is none of his business, you could always say that you were happy to help her out, you can't take the money with you, and you are happier seeing her enjoy your support now.

DiscoDancer1975 Tue 14-Dec-21 12:06:47

Why do you need to be polite. Surely it just encourages him. You don’t need to be rude, but just say what you’ve said here...” its none of your business, go away!”

Lulubelle500 Tue 14-Dec-21 12:05:37

I think what's it got to do with you? is entirely appropriate. I mean, what has it got to do with him? It's your DD (and I must say you sound like a lovely mother!)