Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Are You a Lady? ?

(238 Posts)
grannyrebel7 Mon 30-May-22 12:51:23

I don't like being called a woman. It has negative connotations to my mind. Don't mind lady as it's more respectful , but would much prefer to be a girl or a guy!

BlueSky Mon 30-May-22 12:51:10

No lady sounds too old. I rather be called a girl, (and I call my friend girls too) not offensive to me at all! I’m with lovebeige’s MIL here. Sorry to make you cringe Elizabeth!

FannyCornforth Mon 30-May-22 12:45:09

OakDryad that’s why I suggested its ‘reclamation’

OakDryad Mon 30-May-22 12:42:44

Absolutely not. It is riddled with socially divisive woman who is class association, entitlement and privilege c/f these dictionary definitions (OED):

The female head of a household; a woman who has authority over servants, attendants, or slaves.

A woman who rules over subjects, a queen; a woman to whom obedience or feudal homage is due.

Used when speaking of or to a woman who is of high rank, esp. a member of the nobility.

Prefixed to a title of honour or designation of office as an added mark of respect. Now only in fixed collocations e.g. Lady Mayor.

A woman having the characteristics traditionally associated with high social standing; a refined or genteel woman.

FannyCornforth Mon 30-May-22 12:42:42

Kim19

Wouldn't bother me particularly. Think woman is my preference.

Another ‘Me too’

But you can’t really say / type ‘what do you women think?’
And it’s not a sexist thing,
because like wise you wouldn’t say ‘what do you men think?’

Or would you?
I’ve always struggled with plurals for people. I hate guys, and find folk the best available word

FannyCornforth Mon 30-May-22 12:39:01

Galaxy

Ha I have never been a lady. I have done most of what lovebeige has described, except the spitting.

Me too!
I still think that I’m a lady though (well, actually I think that I’m a perpetual 11 year old girl, but that’s another thread)

eazybee Mon 30-May-22 12:38:47

Unquestionably.

Purplepixie Mon 30-May-22 12:35:19

I really dont mind just as long as someone speak to me and isnt rude.

Elizabeth27 Mon 30-May-22 12:33:28

Woman is my preference but would prefer lady to girl, it makes me cringe when older women call themselves girls.

Galaxy Mon 30-May-22 12:30:08

Ha I have never been a lady. I have done most of what lovebeige has described, except the spitting.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Mon 30-May-22 12:28:24

I don't mind at all being called a lady. I don't swear in public, get drunk or show my knickers off and never spit. Other criteria must be available.

OTOH my late MIL made a right song and dance about being called a lady, preferring to be called a girl despite surviving to her mid-nineties.

Kim19 Mon 30-May-22 12:24:25

Wouldn't bother me particularly. Think woman is my preference.

FannyCornforth Mon 30-May-22 12:20:28

Hello!
(No, don’t worry, it’s not about toilets.)

What do you think about being called a lady?

I’ve found myself using the plural on a few occasions on here;
and I always slightly feel as if I should apologise, or ask permission.
In fact, in the past, I have done the latter.

As a young 80’s feminist, I used to really dislike the word; and I would berate my poor mother for using the word (what a flipping sanctimonious child I was!)

But now, I don’t mind lady at all, in fact I like it. Perhaps we should reclaim it…

So what do you think? Yay or nay?
(Now would be a fantastic time for the Mumsnet voting buttons - forget a like button, we need those bad boys)

Thank you smilebrew