Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Poetry Appreciation

(82 Posts)
JessM Tue 04-Dec-12 18:13:49

Lots of poets on GN which is nice but not much talk about poetry.
This is a suggestion - that someone suggests an interesting poem every few weeks and we have a discussion about what we like about it or don't like about it. I am going to be seasonal and suggest TS Elliot's The Coming of the Magi. Anyone want to play?

Jodi Fri 14-Dec-12 01:01:19

Perhaps GNHQ might look favourably on a poetry forum?

Greatnan Thu 13-Dec-12 20:15:49

How about a separate thread for each poem so people could go on commenting on each one for as long as they liked, without causing confusion.
I will be nominating a difficult poet - Gerard Manley Hopkins - for the wonderful use of language. My favourite is Inversnaid because it reminds me of the peaty streams on the Yorkshire Moors. This is one of his less obscure poems. I had not met his work until I studied it as part of my Eng. Lit degree course.

Mishap Thu 13-Dec-12 18:24:20

Happy to do that. Any chgance Hunt that you could reproduce the poem here for us please?

JessM Thu 13-Dec-12 17:34:22

Anyone else got comments on Ludaig? I think it is short and evocative. Almost Japanese.
If not, Hunt has made a suggestion. Shall we get that one off the shelf and have a go?

CHEELU Thu 13-Dec-12 17:06:01

I have had a couple of poems published and have been writing poems since I was little so I would def be interested...

JessM Mon 10-Dec-12 18:20:23

Kind of a low key, remote, flurry though isn't it. the first verse. And then a sort of sigh into the second. He has you sitting there looking at it, doesnt he. As you say, in such a few words. less is more and all that.

Mishap Mon 10-Dec-12 16:53:12

I love the Ludaig Jetty - it is so simple and uses so few words, but paints a wonderful picture - or two pictures really. There is the flurry of morning activity of the first verse, then the wonderful tranquility of the second.

I am glad that you enjoyed it.

annodomini Mon 10-Dec-12 16:14:13

I think it's probably just as it appears, Jess.

I tried to write an appreciation of the Betjeman poem but it ended up sounding like something an English teacher would write. That's not what you want here - believe me!

JessM Mon 10-Dec-12 15:54:32

That is delightful Mishap - a word picture as Soop would say.
Just a few words but he evokes tranquillity.
Anyone help us with the pronounciation of "Ludaig" please?

Mishap Mon 10-Dec-12 09:56:44

How about we move on in positive fashion and discuss this poem or simply enjoy it if that is what you prefer.....?

Ludaig Jetty

The small motorboat has puttered its way
out to the fishing
the bus has passed by
to collect the children for school
the red postal van
has delivered the mail

now here at Ludaig jetty
there is only
the wind and the light
the cry of a peewit
and the lip-lip-lipping
of grey water on white sand.

It is by Scottish poet Kenneth White. I think it is lovely and hope you enjoy it too.

Jodi Sun 09-Dec-12 21:49:52

ariadne I'd like you to stay on this thread if possible.

Ariadne Sun 09-Dec-12 20:59:28

No, it shouldn't. Enjoy it.

Mishap Sun 09-Dec-12 19:37:22

Me too crimson - I would not like this thread to fade away.

crimson Sun 09-Dec-12 19:33:12

Granset is a sum of many parts. To me some threads are like sitting with a group of friends chatting and,during the course of the conversation we move from one subject to another. But others are like going to a talk about something and, when that happens the point of the thread is to discuss the subject in hand which, in this case is poetry. I don't know much about poetry which is a shame as I've inherited a lot of poetry books from a departed friend who would have loved this thread. I can't say that I like The Coming of the Magi, and I found the end, with it's reflection on death strange because, as a non Christian I still feel that the birth of Christ is a celebration of birth and childhood and hopes and dreams. I also found the descriptions odd and found myself questioning how the author could have known what they saw on the way [ok I know it's a fictional account]. I would like to learn more about poetry though and look forward to reading more poems put forward.

Ariadne Sun 09-Dec-12 19:13:03

Oh, and gaga thank you too; I don't take fright, or the hump, just withdraw. Quite happy.

Ariadne Sun 09-Dec-12 19:11:19

I am here. But think I'd rather not join in, thanks.

JessM Sun 09-Dec-12 17:57:05

What about a separate thread where we do the list so that it does not get lost in this one?

Mishap Sat 08-Dec-12 15:56:06

Thanks for that idea Hunt - I will google it. I do not know of it. Great idea to have a list of poems to work through. We need a Keeper of the List!

Hunt Sat 08-Dec-12 15:30:34

Are we starting a list of poems to be considered ? If so I would like to put forward 'When I was young and fair' which is attributed to Elizabeth 1st. I find this very moving now that I am old.

JessM Sat 08-Dec-12 15:09:39

It is in my nature to try to steer the direction of activities if they have a serious intent. You would see me doing the same thing if we were having a real-world meeting, whatever the topic - I would be working at trying to keep discussions on track and in line with the agenda and purpose.
If we were in other contexts you would not see me doing this. So I make no apologies.
Maybe if you jo could put your thoughts in fewer one-line posts it would be less irritating for other members.

soop Sat 08-Dec-12 14:39:34

I agree with jings...to wander off at a nostalgic tangent, isn't a big deal.

jO5 Sat 08-Dec-12 14:17:09

You can't put beloved poems like these on screen and then expect older people not to give in to a bit of nostalgia.

jO5 Sat 08-Dec-12 14:14:25

That is so hurtful.

jO5 Sat 08-Dec-12 14:13:39

hat is so unfair jess! The poem evokes memories for me. I am just expressing those feelings.

Are contributors to this thread going to have to sit an exam at the end of it?

Gagagran Sat 08-Dec-12 14:13:16

JessM you seem to be in real control freak mode today! Surely Jingle can post what she wants - you don't own the thread! I think Ariadne has taken fright at the severity of your reprimand. Lighten up! smile