Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Fiction reviews

(117 Posts)
HQ1 Tue 09-Jun-15 12:43:08

As part of our preparations to get the mobile site up and running we are changing the way we do reviews to make sure they work just as well on a phone or tablet as they do on the desktop site.

This means discontinuing the old-style review pages and moving them onto the forums instead. We will also be losing the product reviews topic on the forums as we reckon it's far easier to find reviews for beauty products, say, under 'Style and beauty' or great hotels under 'Travel' than it is to trawl through reams of things that are not relevant to your search.

That bit coming soon - but for now we will be reposting all your reviews for fiction on this thread so that the info is still available to anyone who'd like to use it. Of course if you have others that you would like to rave/moan about do feel free to add here too.

bumblebee Tue 10-Nov-15 23:45:42

Book Review: 'AND THE MOUNTAINS ECHOED', by Khaled Hosseini.

After the phenomenal success of 'The Kite Runner' and 'A Thousand Splendid Suns', selling 38 million copies worldwide, Khaled Hosseini returns with his third book. And just like his first two stories, 'And The Mountains Echoed' is a beautifully written epic, partially set against the backdrop of the last 60-years of the land of the author's birth, but additionally also in cities around the world as the narrative expands.
The story presents an interlocking series of events that span generations, about people trapped in the circumstances of their lives, who make life-changing decisions not because they want to, but, ultimately, because they feel they have to, but who do not grasp the grave consequences of these decisions until afterwards. Its characters are linked by blood, coincidence and by the way their lives seem parallel.

The book opens with the 10-year-old Abdullah joining his sister, 3-year-old Pari, and his father, Saboor, on a journey across the desert to Kabul. It becomes apparent that brother and sister are inseparable, and that Abdullah's deep love and sense of responsibility for his sister transcends time and space. It is also clear the family have known hardship their entire lives. The mother of the two siblings had passed away giving birth to Pari. They, along with their step-mother and baby half-brother, are supported by Saboor, who takes work where he can find it, often having to be away for days on end. However, job opportunities are scarce. The sheer financial burden they experience have led to this journey, along with the prospect of further impending struggles to come (another infant on the way, along with the harsh winter which had already claimed the life of Abdullah's and Pari's first half-brother two winters ago). Saboor has made a fateful decision. He must make a sacrifice to save the family. It is a decision that will 'echo' through time, generations, continents.
From this point, the author weaves a multi-layered narrative away from the siblings' plight through to characters you initially assume are merely foils, but whose own individual tales become key components of the book in their own right. Themes emerge: the separation of siblings, betrayal by fathers and mothers and sisters, the grief and resentments of children, the failure of early promise, the way all plans and ambitions can be undermined by sudden and astonishing events.
Hosseini seems to be fascinated by the accidental nature of life, by the way that whole decades of our lives can be shaped by events we do not understand or even know about, about how sometimes these multiple threads can be traced back to one cataclysmic moment in the past, one singular event, one momentous decision.

After two critically-acclaimed and financially successful book releases, it's safe to assume the author probably felt the weight of expectation on him when constructing this third book. However, Hosseini meets these expectations head-on. A terrific book from an author justifiably increasing in reputation as a great storyteller.

"An epic tale that transcends time, generations and continents. A top read!!! 4.5/5" 9 out of 10

wallers5 Tue 12-Jan-16 08:45:06

The Apothecarys Daughter by Charlotte Betts

Set during the time of the London Fire & around an Apothecary, love & danger all around. It takes you into another world.

bmacca Thu 14-Jan-16 12:13:57

Dragonfish by Vu Tran

This is a first novel from this author so I didn't know what to expect. I started reading it a few weeks ago but Christmas got in the way so only went back to it this week. Once I started reading it again, I couldn't put it down. It's essentially a mystery set in USA and the main character is an American cop. However it's far more than that, with great storytelling and full of characters. It has an engrossing plot, and vividly brings to life a dangerous Las Vegas but also has themes of loss and identity. The book involves Vietnamese immigrants and this made me think about their history and what they must have experienced. I would recommend this book as an absorbing read, and I'll be looking out for more from this author.

Lizanne Fri 15-Jan-16 13:45:55

All of the Case Histories series are superb. The TV series was disappointing.

Greyduster Mon 18-Jan-16 13:33:29

Just finished another of Manda Scott's books "Into the Fire". The story alternates between 21st century and 15th century France - specifically Orlean, where a female police officer is tasked with investigating a series of catastrophic fires which are claiming lives, and which are tenuously linked to the history of the martyrdom of Joan of Arc. I quite often find books that switch back and forth between eras irritating, but a gripping story unfolds throughout this book and it become 'unputdownable'.
Manda Scott has a wonderful grasp on history, meticulously researched. Her characters are so beautifully and carefully wrought you feel you have known them for years. They leap out of the page at you and stay with you for a long time after you put the books down. Her Boudicca novels are rivetting (i was pleased to see they are optioned for tv) and whether she is writing battle scenes or love scenes she never misses a step.

NanKate Mon 18-Jan-16 22:34:43

I shall look out for that book Greyduster the cover is very graphic, which I like.

Different from you I just love books that switch between eras, so this might suit me nicely. Thanks. flowers

grammargran Tue 19-Jan-16 16:25:49

I really enjoyed that book Greyduster and love nipping between eras like NanKate - Barbara Erkskine's good at that as well as a bit spooky!
However, I've just found myself a new author - Jane Bailey - and have skittered through two of her books: "Tommy Glover's Sketch of Heaven" and "Mad Joy". Both deal with the war years but not in that slightly mushy way that happens with a lot of evacuee war stories. The story lines in both books are much more robust with more than a touch of thriller type mystery about them. They are both books that make you wonder why the writers for TV or film drama haven't picked up on them. Of course, you can't be objective in cases like this - so a lot of you out there may think I'm talking rubbish - but I loved them both. (The fact that the main action takes place in my native Gloucestershire may have something to do with that, of course!)

NanKate Tue 19-Jan-16 17:17:29

I love Barbara Erskine too Grammargran. Have you discovered Diana Gabaldon and her Outlander series, they are fabulous and have been turned into a mini series on Amazon Prime ?

grammargran Wed 20-Jan-16 13:09:56

I'll give her a go NanKate!

grammargran Wed 20-Jan-16 13:11:34

Forgot to mention, NanKate, did you know Barbara Erskine's got a new book coming out at the end of June? "Sleeper's Castle" Apparently, it's 30 years since "Lady of Hay" was first published.

Greyduster Wed 20-Jan-16 16:01:10

grammargran i couldn't get on with "Lady of Hay" - not because of the switching between eras, but because i couldn't warm to any of the characters except Mathilda. I nearly gave it up a few times, but i was so curious to see how it would end that i stuck it out!

NanKate Wed 20-Jan-16 17:10:55

GrammarGran no I didn't know there was a new Barbara Erskine due, I will put it on my To Do List to treat myself grin

I don't know if you have discovered Elly Griffiths her stories about Ruth Galloway starting with book 1 'The Crossing Places' are excellent.

Greyduster I read 'Lady of Hay' about 25 years ago and loved it. I thought when it was the 25th anniversary I would read it again and I just couldn't finish it and wondered why I had loved it so much before. I suspect I have changed a lot over the years and my reading tastes have changed.

grammargran Sun 24-Jan-16 12:30:02

For goodness sake NanKate, stop recommending books and authors to me, my house is already totally neglected through my reading habits - I just blow on the dust before settling down. You've so hooked me on the Outlander books - and I'm still on number 1 but I know it's going to be a lifetime affair - I've ordered the DVDs for holiday viewing. I've just read the blurb about Ruth Galloway and I'm a lost cause already!

NanKate Sun 24-Jan-16 14:53:47

S*d the housework Grammargran and get down to some serious reading. I have restarted reading the Diana Gabaldon books they are so good, I feel sure you will become equally hooked having read book 1.

Have I mentioned to you that the second of the Outlander series is in production and I tell you I've loved the first series almost as much as reading the books and that says something.

Shall I keep quiet for a bit ? grin

grammargran Mon 25-Jan-16 09:37:44

You're my sort of woman NanKate, and give sensible advice. Will the next series of Outlander be on Amazon Prime? Didn't they do Ripper Street when the BBC gave up on them? And now, no more from you, I need to wash up at least!

NanKate Mon 25-Jan-16 15:00:51

Well I have given you the morning free of me Grammargran but only because I have been perusing my other great love in life Tennis. Been watching the Australian Open and I have fitted in a visit to Keep Fit.

You may wonder when I fit in housework and other boring jobs. I wonder that too. grin

Finally yes Ripper Street is on Amazon Prime. Do you remember 'Life on Mars' just watched that series on AP, very good.

Over and out.

NanKate Mon 25-Jan-16 15:01:38

I am hoping the next series of Outlander will be on AP.

grammargran Mon 25-Jan-16 23:08:29

Yes, I do remember 'Life on Mars' NanKate, also 'Ashes to Ashes' - still on the same theme of slipping through holes in time. I've just remembered another author who wrote on that theme: Diana Norman (wife of Barry Norman, the film critic). Have you read her? Fitzempress' Law - I read it some years ago and very much enjoyed it. Glad you had a happy morning with the tennis. It's wall to wall rugby in our house. Having had a few months to recover from the World Cup, I'm now bracing myself for the Six Nations. Perhaps a quick flick round with the feather duster, followed by a few lunges with the vacuum cleaner - and that's the house sorted for the duration!

NanKate Tue 26-Jan-16 06:44:05

Thanks for the suggestion of the Diana Norman book I will check it out Grammargran.

Also thanks for the reminder of the up coming Rugby, we like that too. Oh and we have the Rio Olympics to look forward to as well.

I have a question for you. In many, many years to come when you are ready to shuffle off this mortal coil, will you be saying 'I wish I had found time to fit in more housework' or will you be saying 'I wish I had read more books' ? So next time you have the housework v the reading dilemma, it will make it much easier to make your decision. I have to admit I am quite tidy which detracts from the dust. grin

quizqueen Thu 28-Jan-16 10:17:30

Your Truly, 2095 by Brian Paone

Even if you're not that keen on Sci Fi this is a really easy and, at times, amusing read by a new author

quizqueen Thu 28-Jan-16 10:25:03

Your Truly, 2095 by Brian Paone

Even if you're not that keen on Sci Fi this is a really easy and, at times, amusing read by a new author

bmacca Tue 02-Feb-16 15:07:24

Coffin Road by Peter May

I had not read a Peter May book for some time, and this book made me realise I've been missing out. The stories of a man washed ashore with no memory of who he is, an emotional and rebellious teenager and a police officer are intertwined to good effect. The characters are well formed, and the descriptions of the wild landscape and sea add to the story's suspense. The unfolding mystery at the heart of the story is very interesting and thought provoking. This is another example of Peter May's great writing and I'd recommend it

grandMattie Fri 05-Feb-16 13:55:30

Burial Rites by Hannah Kent

THe story of a real woman, the last to have been executed in Iceland in 1829 or thereabouts.

The author spent some time in Iceland and kenw about Agnes Magnusdottir, who was executed for murdering her lover. It had passed into Icelandic folkelore, but the author could find very little else indeed about this woman. So she added loads of flesh to the bones of this unpromising story.

Although the tale is oneof woe, it gives the flavour and smells of the island in the mid 19th centuray, the poverty of the farmers and general population, the hold Denmark had as the colonial overlords, the universal [continuing to the present day] gossip about this and that, and belief in "urban myths". the prose is exccellent and the word pictures tangible.

We had it for our most recent book group and every last member said how glad she had been to read the book , although "enjoyed" was too strong a word to use.

keriku Tue 09-Feb-16 21:12:58

THE CUCKOO WALL by LILLIAN KING
Usually when a book starts in a graveyard, you would expect it to be a murderous detective book, but this is a book about three generations of women from one Edinburgh family. Ten year old Minnie rattles between her mum's large, gloomy home and her gran's cosy flat, meeting all kinds of interesting characters along the way. The fourth character in this book, is Edinburgh itself. Lillian has a great gift for dialogue and leads us from Newington, to Royal Terrace, via Portobello and Princes Street, offering marvellous glimpses of her gran's eccentric friends and the Jenners Ladies who make a career from choosing hats and reading romantic magazines!
The book explores the secrets and lies that parents and grandparents hide from different generations. Despite some harrowing chapters, the book is infused with great humour, If you want to know the origins of the title, you will have to buy the book!

starbird Tue 01-Mar-16 16:16:42

I loved this - sad, human, heartbreaking at times, a story of human resilience. Be grateful for what you have.