I didn’t win a copy of ‘After the End’ but another Gransnetter and I exchange books if one or other of us is successful in the monthly draw!
Like other Gransnetters, I read this book in a couple of days. I quickly became engrossed in the lives of the central characters Pip, Max and their young, desperately ill, son Dylan. They were portrayed with heart-breaking realism and I did feel drawn into life in the Paediatric Intensive Care Unit (PICU).
In my opinion, the book was very cleverly constructed. The first 25 chapters - ‘BEFORE’ - highlight the strength of the relationship between Pip and Max, the deterioration in Dylan’s condition and the dedication of the PICU staff. Events are told in a straightforwardly and in chronological order. This section culminates in the Court Case held to determine Dylan’s future treatment, as his parents disagree on what course of action would be in Dylan’s best interest.
The outcome of the Court Case is never disclosed, rather the second part of the book - ‘AFTER’ - moves between two different scenarios. In one, the outcome of the Court Case is that there should be no further medical intervention to prolong Dylan’s life (in line with Pip’s belief that Dylan should be allowed to die), whereas in the other the Court decision is to allow Dylan to travel to US for proton beam treatment (in line with Max’s belief that while there is any possibility that any treatment will prolong Dylan’s life, it should be explored).
Chapters alternately progress the story from Pip’s and Max’s points of view, Dylan has no further treatment and Dylan travels to US respectively. The timelines are not chronological and the dialogue twists and turns between present events and those in the past which still bear influence. I found this style of writing quite fascinating and, although requiring concentration on whose story was being played out and when, I found this added to, rather than distracted from, the story.
Undoubtedly, this was a challenging book for Clare Mackintosh to write, just as it was at times challenging to read. However, I feel the outcome is an important and successful book which will stay with me for some considerable time.
I would like to ask Clare how important she thought it was to give one of the PICU doctors, Leila, a significant role not only in the ‘BEFORE’ section of the book, but also in the aftermath of the Court decision.