Eloethan
I agree with many of your choices, I thought the Secret History was brilliant, but nothing she’s written since, has come close to it.
Love Anne Tyler, Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant probably my favourite, but I loved Digging to America.
Never really got into Tracey Chevalier.
Only came across Joyce Carol Oates a few years ago, but really enjoy her books.
Nick Hornby, great.
Anita Brookner, wonderful, I have all her books, I was always so exited when a new book came out, comfort reading at its best.
As we clearly have similar tastes I’ll be trying the other writers on your list.