Gransnet forums

Books/book club

New Monthly Book Club

(36 Posts)
Urmstongran Mon 27-Sept-21 11:55:56

I read ‘The Vanishing Half’ last year Early so I’m ready to join in on 1 November! Thank you for starting this on-line book club. It should be fun!
??

Early Mon 27-Sept-21 11:30:41

The Machine Stops conversation is up and running over on another thread. Thanks Casdon for joining in. It's a quick listen or read. Plenty of time for others to tag on through October. All welcome.

The Vanishing Half? That's great, LadyGaGa and thanks for your suggestions for 2022.

LadyGaGa Mon 27-Sept-21 08:53:09

Just about to order the book. Going to work hard to finish the one I’m reading so I can crack on.

NotTooOld Sun 26-Sept-21 15:33:25

Sorry, Casdon. I didn't notice that.

Casdon Sun 26-Sept-21 15:25:11

Does anybody know what happened to the discussion last week about he book choice being ‘The Machine Stops’ ? I read it in anticipation, but nothing has transpired yet?

NotTooOld Sun 26-Sept-21 15:20:13

The Vanishing Half is available on Kindle for £4.99. I have just downloaded a sample. Look forward to joining in on November 1st.

Early Sun 26-Sept-21 13:10:36

I haven't run an online book discussion before so I am in unchartered waters.

I'm planning to start a new thread for The Vanishing Half on 1 November so that people have a month to discuss it. If people see the thread, haven't read the book but feel inspired to do so then there's still time to join in.

There's no way of closing a thread here so it could just run on beyond that but to get a good discussion going it would be great if several of us were ready with something to say as soon as we kick off on the first of the month.

I don't want to be too prescriptive and in charge as such. We'll find our way and see what happens.

What I do quite like is when group members ask one another questions to prompt the discussion.

There are several themes going on in this book: racism; the bond of twinship and what happens when that is broken; love; discrimination; tolerance; acceptance and forgiveness are just a few.

Desiree and Stella are the central characters, the twins at the heart of the story but Jude and Reese, Blake, Loretta and Kennedy are key too.

If anyone is really keen they might also like to read Dorothy West's Virago classic The Wedding. It also concerns a (wealthy in this case) light-skinned black family. There are a lot of parallels in the two stories. I bet Brit Bennett has read it.

LadyGaGa Sun 26-Sept-21 12:11:45

Hi. Yes, this sounds like a great idea, but I too have never done it before so would like some pointers. Looking forward to it.

ixion Sun 26-Sept-21 12:06:30

Sounds good Early.
I have never done Book Clubs on line before -
Do we just comment throughout the month as we go along on a dedicated thread?
And does that thread close on the day the new book starts?

Look forward to developments!

Kestrel Sun 26-Sept-21 09:44:58

Sounds good smile

Early Sun 26-Sept-21 09:41:31

I’d like to start a monthly book discussion group here. I believe these did happen in the past but have fallen by the wayside. There have been a few recent threads about starting something again but things have stalled for one reason or another. Let’s try again.

I’m thinking along the lines that we try out a couple of books in what remains of 2021 to see how it goes. If there’s sufficent interest we could have something more structured for 2022 - invite title suggestions and pick twelve books for the year - one discussion for each calendar month. This approach would leave plenty of time to get hold of the books and good for those who like to read ahead.

With millions of books to choose from, we have to start somewhere so I'm going to plunge in. Two books that were featured on Sara Cox’s BBC Between the Covers TV programme back in May were:

The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett and

Should We Fall Behind by Sharon Duggall

I’ve read both and think there’s plenty to discuss.

Briefly, The Vanishing Half is the story of twin girls, black but very light-skinned, who grown up in poor small town America where opportunities are few. They escape to New Orleans where they lose contact and their lives take dramatically different directions. One lives her life passing as white, a major theme of the book.

Should We Fall Behind is the story of a young man from a troubled home who leaves and ends up living on the streets. He meets a young woman, also homeless, who just as soon vanishes from his life. His search to find her leads him to a busy urban community, most people struggling to get by in one way or another. The book tells their stories, their attitude to the young man and how they interact with him.

We could discuss The Vanishing Half from 1 November and Should We Fall Behind from 1 December.

Meantime, I’d like to invite people to suggest books we could read and discuss in 2022. Rather than clutter the thread, can I ask people to send me a personal message. Three suggestions maximum and maybe a little bit about why you think they’d be good to discuss. It could be classic or contemporary fiction from any genre and we could include some biography and non-fiction. It would be great to have a wide selection - maybe read some books that take us outside our usual choices and comfort zones. I’ll make a list of all the titles and then pick twelve from a hat.

I do hope you will join in.