Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Looking for a Christmas read

(65 Posts)
Daffonanna Sat 29-Nov-25 09:58:08

Every December I read or listen to A Christmas Carol . I like to immerse myself in Charles Dickens journeys through the Victorian Winter in all its variety . I enjoy a good book that is set in this time of year , but they all seem to be fluffy sugar coated romances with not much narrative and tediously predictable endings. Has anyone read anything a little more immersive , seasonal without the schmalz? I found " The housekeeper " Leona Grace , which is a bit sugary, but rather more spookily satisfying . "Also Miss Marley" Rebecca Mascull . Type Christmas fiction in any forum , I find that none of these show up . Any ideas ?

Aveline Sat 29-Nov-25 10:09:34

Try Trollope - Christmas at Thompson Hall. He's wordy but the stories are good and I always like his characters. I prefer him to Dickens.

Wheniwasyourage Sat 29-Nov-25 13:51:53

Have you tried "How Far to Bethlehem?" by Norah Lofts? She has written stories of some of the characters in the Nativity story, starting with Mary, and how they get to Bethlehem. I read it most years, and love it.

eddiecat78 Sat 29-Nov-25 14:59:39

I recommend A Redbird Christmas by Fannie Flagg; and Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm by Stella Gibbons

Overthemoongran Sat 29-Nov-25 15:02:56

Another vote here for ‘How Far to Bethlehem’. It’s my favourite Christmas book. I hardly ever read a book twice, but this one comes out every two or three years, I love it.

Aveline Sat 29-Nov-25 15:11:33

Oh yes 'A red bird Christmas' is lovely. You must read it!

J52 Sat 29-Nov-25 15:31:23

The Winter Ghost by Kate Mosse is a good story. Not too long either.

Harris27 Sat 29-Nov-25 15:34:02

It’s funny reading this post as I gravitate to my old miss read books every Christmas. And a winter solstice by rosamunde pilchard. My tradition.

keepcalmandcavachon Sat 29-Nov-25 16:10:48

I tend towards an unsettling read for this season, a bit of contrast to all the frivolitygrin, so would recommend MR James - The Turn Of The Screw, The Woman In White by Wilkie Collins, The Small Hand by Susan Hill or Sophie Hannah's The Orphan Choir. The dark afternoons & twinkly lights are perfect these I think.

keepcalmandcavachon Sat 29-Nov-25 16:13:36

But my heart warming choice is always The Christmas Angel by Marcia Willet!

Oreo Sat 29-Nov-25 17:22:42

keepcalmandcavachon

I tend towards an unsettling read for this season, a bit of contrast to all the frivolitygrin, so would recommend MR James - The Turn Of The Screw, The Woman In White by Wilkie Collins, The Small Hand by Susan Hill or Sophie Hannah's The Orphan Choir. The dark afternoons & twinkly lights are perfect these I think.

Christmas ghost stories are perfect for December aren’t they?
Unless you live alone and are of a nervous disposition.

Grannmarie Sat 29-Nov-25 18:38:58

Another vote for How far to Bethlehem. I'll start re reading it tomorrow, first Sunday of Advent. Perfect pre Christmas read.
I also enjoy Christmas crime/ ghost stories.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 29-Nov-25 20:15:12

I like a 1930s Christmas murder mystery, usually set in a large country house.

Aveline Sat 29-Nov-25 20:53:34

Me too WWM2. I don't know why but I do!

grandMattie Sat 29-Nov-25 21:05:06

My vote too, for “how far to Bethlehem”!

PaynesGray Sat 29-Nov-25 21:14:32

How about The Penguin Book of Christmas Stories?

Truman Capote makes whisky-soaked fruitcake in Alabama; Laurie Lee slides across a frozen pond in Gloucestershire; and Shirley Jackson is outwitted by a wily Santa Claus at the bank. Ghosts haunt the Christmases of Muriel Spark and Elizabeth Bowen, while Dostoyevsky, Daphne du Maurier and Italo Calvino take a cynical view of the season and Selma Lagerlof and Angela Carter celebrate its miracles. Ranging from Cork to Lagos to the Wild West and from Paris to San Paolo to outer space, this is Christmas as imagined by some of the greatest short-story writers of all time.

Available in paper book and audio book formats.

TerriBull Sun 30-Nov-25 08:07:28

I've earmarked a book for December, The Land in Winter by Andrew Miller, nominated for the Booker. I've recently read a good book by this author. This one is set in the harsh winter of '63. Possibly not a Christmas theme though. I'd also go with WW's suggestion, vintage crime in a big house to evoke a specific seasonal feel.

Greenfinch Sun 30-Nov-25 08:32:18

Another one for Miss Read. I love her stories of gentle country folk and their Christmas activities.

Clawdy Sun 30-Nov-25 08:36:47

Christmas Jigsaw Murders by Alexandra Benedict is good fun, full of puzzles.

teabagwoman Sun 30-Nov-25 08:38:48

Glad to be reminded of the Miss Tead books, I will seek them out, but at Christmas I’m another one who likes a Golden Age type crime set in a country house.

Witzend Sun 30-Nov-25 08:52:42

Aveline

Try Trollope - Christmas at Thompson Hall. He's wordy but the stories are good and I always like his characters. I prefer him to Dickens.

As a Trollope fan I’ve got his complete works on my Kindle but don’t ever recall seeing this! Must have another look….

Maggiemaybe Sun 30-Nov-25 08:53:22

I’d recommend Hello from the Gillespies. A harassed mum sends out the wrong Christmas round robin - the one she typed out in a rage, that tells about the family’s life as it really is.

Aveline Sun 30-Nov-25 09:02:33

😂 that sounds like fun Maggiemaybe

keepingquiet Sun 30-Nov-25 09:15:29

Dark Matter by Michelle Paver. Not Christmassy as such but quite scary.

Oreo Sun 30-Nov-25 10:05:48

keepingquiet

Dark Matter by Michelle Paver. Not Christmassy as such but quite scary.

Well….there is snow!
A very scary story indeed, that stays with you.