Gransnet forums

Books/book club

I want a very depressing book

(130 Posts)
ochia03 Tue 30-Dec-25 11:36:42

Ive always loved reading really depressing books, since I'm a rather happy-go-lucky person, so most of the ones I read don't make me feel very sad. So that's where I employ all of you great people, to find me a book that will make me rethink why I created this post. Please and thank you smile

NotSpaghetti Wed 31-Dec-25 00:02:19

Germinal by Émile Zola

nanna8 Wed 31-Dec-25 00:13:55

Hamnet is coming out as a film,too. Just been and watched Nuremberg, that’s depressing but what a good actor Russell Crowe is as Göring. I get quite a few books online and if you look for psychological horror novels most are depressing. Also Thomas Hardy novels - king of the depressives !

Purplepixie Wed 31-Dec-25 00:17:07

Try reading 1984.

nanna8 Wed 31-Dec-25 00:20:36

Too close to home these days, isn’t it Purplepixie?

Marilla Wed 31-Dec-25 12:21:31

A Long, Long Way by Sebastian Barry is set in World War 1 following the life of young Willie Dunne. It is a beautifully written book and yes it is terribly sad. It is a haunting story which will stay with you.

Sparklefizz Wed 31-Dec-25 12:22:12

MayBee70

Sparklefizz

Maybee70 I thought A Thousand Splendid Suns was uplifting

While I was reading it, I spent most of the time in tears. It's one of the saddest and most upsetting books I have ever read.
Perhaps it would suit OP's requirements.

I was numb at the end. Reminded me of films that I’ve been to see where I had to stay in my seat for a while after the film finished ( eg Brokeback Mountain).

But you said it was "uplifting" in your earlier post MayBee70

nadateturbe Wed 31-Dec-25 12:25:28

"But You Did Not Come Back"Marceline Loridan-Ivens .
So sad and depressing two friends couldn't finish when I lent it.

Shel1951 Wed 31-Dec-25 12:27:29

The boy in the striped pyjamas....John Boyle

MollyNew Wed 31-Dec-25 12:30:04

Is Dr Zhivago the novel as depressing as the film?

Fallingstar Wed 31-Dec-25 12:34:24

The Road by Cormac McCarthy
Woman at Point Zero by Nawal El Sadaawi

Fallingstar Wed 31-Dec-25 12:43:00

Crime and Punishment by Dostoevsky, or any of his other works.

Magenta8 Wed 31-Dec-25 12:56:43

Somebody recommended 'The Gambler' by Dostoevsky to me as being "A great laugh." All I can say is either they must have read a different translation to the one I read, or I lack a sense of humour. I know Russian humour can be very bleak.

mumofmadboys Wed 31-Dec-25 13:21:13

In the springtime of the year. By Susan Hill. About bereavement.

Fallingstar Wed 31-Dec-25 13:42:44

On The Beach by Nevil Shute

M0nica Wed 31-Dec-25 13:55:51

Madame Bovary, any novel by Russian writers, A ale of Two Cities

Les Miserables, the book, Germinal, by Emil Zola, I believe Zola wrote a lot of miderable books, bu Germinal sufficed for me.

vegansrock Wed 31-Dec-25 14:23:03

The Narrow Road to the Far North by Richard Flanagan is unremittingly grim about Japanese prisoners of war camps

NotSpaghetti Wed 31-Dec-25 16:08:24

Madame Bovary and several others here are amongst my favourites.

I think we all have different ideas regarding shat is a very depressing book
grin

Esmay Wed 31-Dec-25 16:34:29

Madame Bovary is depressing and so is Therese Raquin - another woman set to self destruct .

Greenfinch Wed 31-Dec-25 17:05:06

I’m the King of the Castle by Susan Hill. A very dark book dealing with the cruelty and malevolence of children but also their vulnerability.

Maremia Wed 31-Dec-25 18:07:58

'Diary of Anne Frank'

Maremia Wed 31-Dec-25 18:11:12

If you 'enjoyed' Germinal, then why not try "Earth', also by Emile Zola?

CabbageWars13 Wed 31-Dec-25 18:19:50

How about "Frozen In Time" (1985) written by one of the team of archeologists who uncovered three of the graves of seamen who perished on the Franklin expedition to discover the NorthWest passage.

It's both fascinating - a damn good read - and pretty depressing as the team uncover more information about the fate of the entire 129 officers and crew. Not one came back.

MayBee70 Wed 31-Dec-25 19:31:44

CabbageWars13

How about "Frozen In Time" (1985) written by one of the team of archeologists who uncovered three of the graves of seamen who perished on the Franklin expedition to discover the NorthWest passage.

It's both fascinating - a damn good read - and pretty depressing as the team uncover more information about the fate of the entire 129 officers and crew. Not one came back.

The Terror was my favourite tv series from a couple of years back. Made even more fascinating by the fact that they found the remains of ( I think?) The Erebus (sp) round about the same time.

Fallingstar Wed 31-Dec-25 19:37:20

W.Somerset Maugham
Liza of Lambeth
Of Human Bondage

Poppyred Wed 31-Dec-25 19:40:22

The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold. Wanted to end it all after reading it! Book club choice by Richard and Judy. Says it all really…..