Gransnet forums

Books/book club

I want a very depressing book

(130 Posts)
ochia03 Tue 30-Dec-25 11:36:42

Ive always loved reading really depressing books, since I'm a rather happy-go-lucky person, so most of the ones I read don't make me feel very sad. So that's where I employ all of you great people, to find me a book that will make me rethink why I created this post. Please and thank you smile

GoodAfternoonTea Wed 31-Dec-25 20:30:53

The Tobacconist by Robert Seethaler

Esmay Thu 01-Jan-26 12:20:13

A Fatewell To Arms , which is on TV now is another deeply depressing book.
It 's a long time since I read it.
The film reduced ne to floods of tears when I saw it .
I didn't know that it's semi autobiographical. .

Kapitan Thu 01-Jan-26 13:41:16

Try The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant by Stephen R. Donaldson. Very depressing in places.

Sanmrbro Thu 01-Jan-26 13:44:01

Another vote for The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah. A bleak read.

Moggycuddler Thu 01-Jan-26 13:45:40

Cancer Ward, Solzhenitsyn. The Grapes of Wrath. Mostly, I try to avoid very depressing books. Life is too short!

Grandma600 Thu 01-Jan-26 13:47:14

Me Before You by Jojo Moyes.
Badly written AND a depressing tale, so win-win!

schnoodlelove Thu 01-Jan-26 13:51:23

the latest Karl Ove Knausgaard: 'The School of Night' will definitely put you on the right track. it will dig deep.

Spec1alk Thu 01-Jan-26 14:00:54

Down to a sunless sea. Gulp!

Moggycuddler Thu 01-Jan-26 14:01:09

Books by the Brontes, specially Wuthering Heights.

lainieb56 Thu 01-Jan-26 14:41:06

I found The Silence Factory by Budget Collins
very hard going. Actually couldn't finish reading it. Give it a go, see what you think.

Jacksgrandma123 Thu 01-Jan-26 14:43:45

I think there’s a difference between a book that has bleak subject matter but is worth reading and beautifully written or one that you can’t wait to finish as it is mindnumbingly terrible , either as a story or how it is written . A recent one that for me fills this latter criteria is surprisingly (or not!) on this year’s Booker shortlist !

GrannaKaye Thu 01-Jan-26 15:24:54

The Road by Cormac McCarthy...the epitome of bleak...

Shawlands2000 Thu 01-Jan-26 16:39:32

Definitely "Shuggie Bain" by Douglas Stuart. The most depressing book I've ever read, but funnily enough, I enjoyed it.

Graunty7 Thu 01-Jan-26 16:39:33

The lovely bones

Lucky

Elinor oliphant is ok

A kidnapped mind Pamela Richardson

Transcend Thu 01-Jan-26 16:51:14

The book is no longer in print. Last I knew it was available used on Amazon. It was about what happened to my loving parents, sister, his wife and kids after my brother shot his 4 neighbors. It took me ten years to write. And even if it was available new I could not mention the name here. It would violate the agreement with Gransnet and it would reveal my name, which is not safe. It destroyed my family.

Shill29 Thu 01-Jan-26 16:55:51

Not sure if you could call it depressing exactly but “Me Before You “by JoJo Moyes is incredibly sad………

mistymitts Thu 01-Jan-26 17:09:45

I saw A little Life on Stage with James Norton playing the lead.
It is utterly depressing and bleak. His performance was a masterpiece as was on stage the whole time, about 2 and a half hours. Due to his diabetes he had to have sugary snacks hidden on stage to keep his levels up. It leaves you numb and wretched.

Chaitriona Thu 01-Jan-26 17:19:51

I have just read "Crooked Cross" by Sally Carson. She was an English woman who was in the habit of visiting Bavaria and who wrote the novel in I934. It describes the life of an ordinary German family in a small town in Bavaria in the six months between Christmas Eve 1932 and Midsummer Eve 1933 as Hitler came to power and everything changed in Germany.

The book was more or less lost to history but had been reprinted this year by Persephone Press and has sold well.

What is amazing is that this novel was not published after the war and the liberation of the death camps but at the beginning of what was to come but was prescient.

It is painful and shocking to read but it is a most powerful and beautiful novel. The heroine Lexa's brothers, friends, parents all believe in the new creed. But she is engaged to a young man who is a practicing Catholic but whose father is Jewish.

It is a book about moral courage but none of the characters are treated as anything less than human.

I would strongly recommend it.

barbaraellen Thu 01-Jan-26 18:38:05

Gulag Archipelago by Aleksandr Isayevich Solzhenitsyn.

Shizam Thu 01-Jan-26 19:03:38

The Redemption Trilogy by Pat Barker. It’s about the First World War. Found it so profoundly sad and depressing, couldn’t pick up another book for ages. It is brilliant, though, if you face it. 😳

GrandmaRosie Thu 01-Jan-26 19:10:28

MayBee70

If ‘Never Let Me Go’ is anything like the film it should fit the bill….

Loved this book and the film, but so sad 😢

AuntieE Thu 01-Jan-26 19:29:37

Anne Frank's Diary?

grannybuy Thu 01-Jan-26 19:57:10

It seems ambivalent to say that enjoyed A Little Life as it was bleak, and sad. Just when I thought things were beginning to look up, it plummeted again. Though it’s not a happy story, I couldn’t stop reading it. I do recommend it. I’ve just finished reading The Book Thief, another heart wrenching story that you want to read to the end.

vampirequeen Thu 01-Jan-26 20:04:50

Hard Times by Charles Dickens or, as my study group called it , Hard Going.

So depressing to read that we ended up forcing ourselves to read a chapter a day just to get through it.

Crossstitchfan Thu 01-Jan-26 20:08:41

Grandma600

Me Before You by Jojo Moyes.
Badly written AND a depressing tale, so win-win!

Try ‘me AFTER you’, then! That should finish you off nicely!