Gransnet forums

Chat

Are daughters better at caring for parents?.

(55 Posts)
HUNTERF Fri 11-Jan-13 19:53:28

I shared by table with another man who was widowed and a lady today in a cafe which was full today.
The other man had 2 daughters and I have 2 daughters.
She said that we will be ok for care as we have daughters who will never let their old Dad's down where as a son is less reliable.
I am not sure if I agree as I cared for my father ( in all fairness my daughters and son in law did help out ) and I know of a few examples where sons have cared for their parents or in laws.
Do you agree with this lady or me.

Frank

Nanado Sat 12-Jan-13 14:56:25

To the drugs etc I mean, no toy boy available sad

Mishap Sat 12-Jan-13 15:09:46

Lots of love and supportive thoughts merlot.

I am not in a position to know who might be best as carers - I only have daughters - but I have to say they are truly wonderful and have been totally loving and supportive during recent trials and tribulations. And they are very emotionally on the ball and able to empathise with and imagine our feelings and are sensitive to these. They also bring humour - much needed sometimes! - and are generous in sharing the fun of the GC. We are truly blessed with our family.

jeni Sat 12-Jan-13 15:12:04

How does one obtain a toy boy? On amazon or would you try toys r us?
I could do with one!

kittylester Sat 12-Jan-13 15:21:23

merlot flowers

I'm inclined to agree with Ella. My brothers are supportive of Mum and of me but are useless at things like toiletries or clothes shopping and, because they both have jobs and I don't, it is me who does the dogsbody stuff, runs the bank accounts etc. smile

Mishap Sat 12-Jan-13 15:22:44

A toyboy? - not sure I could keep up!

annodomini Sat 12-Jan-13 15:32:26

kitty, not having daughters, I wouldn't be able to make a comparison, but it's impossible to generalise about the male of the species. DS2 would certainly stock me up with toiletries - he goes to Sainsbury's and snaps up trolleyloads of special offers so that their bathroom is full of shampoos and shower gels not to mention toilet rolls. And as for what he comes home with from his bi-annual outing to the Next sale... And DS1 would keep me fed. I think I will have to find an oldies' flat somewhere between Sandhurst and Didcot, assuming that neither of them is going to move.

Nanado Sat 12-Jan-13 15:38:17

jeni no such site. Just googled it to be sure grin

kittylester Sat 12-Jan-13 15:38:49

Different ages possibly anno? You presumably didn't go in for gender stereotyping as much as our parent's generation. When my brothers and I were young I did all the washing up while they cut the lawn between them. When I complained Mum, scandalised, said that boys couldn't be expected to wash up! confused

annodomini Sat 12-Jan-13 15:40:32

kitty, not having daughters, I wouldn't be able to make a comparison, but it's impossible to generalise about the male of the species. DS2 would certainly stock me up with toiletries - he goes to Sainsbury's and snaps up trolleyloads of special offers so that their bathroom is full of shampoos and shower gels not to mention toilet rolls. And as for what he comes home with from his bi-annual outing to the Next sale... And DS1 would keep me fed. I think I will have to find an oldies' flat somewhere between Sandhurst and Didcot, assuming that neither of them is going to move.

annodomini Sat 12-Jan-13 15:41:36

Sorry about this double post. The phone rang just after I'd done it, then I forgot I had....

Jodi Sat 12-Jan-13 15:57:15

Neither could I mishap wink
Did you try toyboys R us?

Jodi Sat 12-Jan-13 15:57:55

That last bit was to jeni

cheelu Sat 12-Jan-13 15:59:35

I dont think it is about wheter it is a daughter or a son I think it is about what kind of person they are as an individual...

Ana Sat 12-Jan-13 16:05:56

This looks like a good buy for those in the market for a toy boy!

Grow your Own

Nanado Sat 12-Jan-13 16:15:00

ana I don't know what you've heard about us but I think we'd all agree....even if we can't afford to be choosy, a minimum requirement in a man....he must have a pulse! grin
Though I don't know if I speak for everyone???? wink

Ana Sat 12-Jan-13 16:18:27

Huh! At least he's cheap and can't answer back.

Actually, I'd like mine to have more than a pulse.....wink

jeni Sat 12-Jan-13 16:23:19

Ana I've sent off for him. I'm that desparate!

Nanado Sat 12-Jan-13 16:27:33

I don't know who's shocked me more but I think jeni wins by a short head.

Ella46 Sat 12-Jan-13 16:30:04

My dd is going on a training course at the end of this month, to be a part time carer. She has always had leanings that way but has been running a business with sil up to now.
Both my ds and dd are quick to offer to look after me (very rarely need it!), and both helped with my dad, showering him etc. and making him lunch, coming to hospital at short notice and being generally as supportive as they could be.
I'm very lucky.

jeni Sat 12-Jan-13 16:43:11

It's not his head I'm interested in.




It's his brainsgrin

Nanado Sat 12-Jan-13 16:48:39

JENI shock

Ella46 Sat 12-Jan-13 16:51:02

I thought you had norovirus last night jeni ??
It obviously suits you! wink

Ana Sat 12-Jan-13 17:00:13

Yes, it's obviously given you an appetite, jeni! (Not for food, though...wink)

jeni Sat 12-Jan-13 17:41:36

I haven't had anything to eat since Thursday! Still not very hungry (for food) might scramble an egg white later.(egg yolk allergy)

jeni Sat 12-Jan-13 18:12:42

That should be Wednesday and I only had 2fishcakes then!