Gransnet forums

Chat

If you think GN can get a little heated.....

(154 Posts)
petallus Mon 07-Oct-13 16:59:00

I quite like a ding dong but only if it stays at a reasonably intelligent level. I can't see the point of just relying on personal insult to get your point across.

tanith Mon 07-Oct-13 16:45:47

Good for you Greatnan I admit I'm not very good in an argument and tend to opt for a quiet life but I do admire people who stand their ground and can have a good old ding dong with reasoned argument and come back for more. I can always think of the perfect riposte after I've lost an argument but I'm afraid my brain and my mouth are usually out of sync grin

Greatnan Mon 07-Oct-13 16:31:50

Oops , 'admit' not 'enjoy'.

Greatnan Mon 07-Oct-13 16:30:09

.....you should read some of the expat forums. Most of the protagonists are men. The arguments are sometimes ridiculous. For example, one person says Britain is rubbish and life in France is perfect. Somebody else replies that their life in France has been disastrous and they can't wait to get back to Britain, which is wonderful. If I try mildly pointing out that both countries have their good and bad points, and you don't have to hate Britain to enjoy living in France, I get jumped on from both sides!
And the political arguments can get really vicious, with personal insults flying around.
I have fallen foul of one member who is an ex-policeman and gets very annoyed whenever I mention some news story about police corruption or incompetence, misogyny, homophobia or racism, even though I always point out that the majority of police officers are probably perfectly honest and fair. He always says the offences are only 'alleged' and goes very quiet when they are found to be true. As an ex-teacher, I just feel sad when stories appear about rogue teachers, but I don't take them as a personal insult. He also objects to my atheism and left-wing views. I have to enjoy that I quite enjoy jousting with him. If I couldn't take the heat, I would stay out of the kitchen! However, he has been responsible for several members leaving the forum, especially women.

I find Gransnet to be a haven of polite, kind, intelligent people, mostly women, with a scattering of some very nice men.