Gransnet forums

Chat

GNHQ please make it clear that these forums are public!

(418 Posts)
Grannyknot Tue 15-Aug-17 16:25:44

I am forever warning people that these forums are public and a thread may end up on Facebook.

I really think that GNHQ should put a note on the Forum home page to that effect in big, bold, text - red, underlined, anything to draw attention to that fact. Put it in the welcome email too. Especially as some posters are not only new to GN, but new to forums.

I can't bear to think that an already stressful situation is made worse for someone because their posts are used as a "trailer" on the Facebook page.

(Writing this because I noticed that someone has been caught out by this, how upsetting).

Wheniwasyourage Wed 16-Aug-17 14:31:06

I'm another one who avoids FB and Twitter from choice and I do not want anything I say to be put on to them as a matter of course. I am well aware that anything one puts on the internet cannot be regarded as private, but that's not the same as having ones's posts deliberately given to other social media. Obviously I am not the only one who chooses not to engage with these media and who will be much more guarded about what I say on GN in future.

gillybob Wed 16-Aug-17 14:32:50

Totally agree Wheniwasyourage

Anniebach Wed 16-Aug-17 14:38:22

Best we stick to the weather, recipes and TV and books

Wheniwasyourage Wed 16-Aug-17 14:40:07

But remember not to say in too much detail what your weather is like in case someone can identify you from that...

gillybob Wed 16-Aug-17 14:48:03

Well the weather where I live is always amazing. 30 degrees sunshine every day. I have 5 children and 18 grandchildren. I am 72 years old, took early retirement at 45 (I was an astro physicist). I love opera music, worldwide travel and I'm not ashamed to admit I am very wealthy too.

gillybob Wed 16-Aug-17 14:52:42

Just removed my profile. sad

annsixty Wed 16-Aug-17 14:53:21

Well gilly as you once said, which sticks in my mind forever, only because I wanted to say it myself but was too scared, my dad's bigger than dad, so there,?

gillybob Wed 16-Aug-17 15:00:41

Bless him, my dad has shrunk considerably since I said that annsixty smile

FarNorth Wed 16-Aug-17 15:19:44

"maybe we should have a closed group on facebook instead."

On facebook, people usually use their real names so that would have drawbacks too.

MargaretX Wed 16-Aug-17 15:21:42

Since I have been aware that everything we write on line is public I have deleted quite a few posts before sending them.

I have always been amazed at how open a lot of posters are about very intimate details of their life. This was not the feeling I had when GN began and because we are an interesting group of people with more to say than most under 45s FB can get a bit of quality onto their pages.

Good point made grannyknot

gillybob Wed 16-Aug-17 15:22:31

I believe there are already one or two on the go FarNorth .

MissAdventure Wed 16-Aug-17 15:24:56

Well, I don't use Facebook, which is why I objected in the first place. Oh well..
I'm no more inclined to start using Facebook, just less inclined to use gransnet.

Eloethan Wed 16-Aug-17 15:33:50

Are you saying that all threads, in their entirety, can be accessed on Facebook? I too wasn't aware that anything from here went on Facebook.

I'm not particularly concerned about it because I don't post much personal or sensitive information, other than a personal profile which I'm not that bothered about. But I agree that there should be a clear warning on the site that everything written by posters on any subject is available to whoever chooses to look.

FarNorth Wed 16-Aug-17 15:49:38

GNHQ puts quotes from selected threads on Facebook. Each quote includes a link to that thread and you are then on the GN site and able to see anything that's there.

Crafting Wed 16-Aug-17 18:43:37

Keep this thread at the top of the page so others know this too

seacliff Wed 16-Aug-17 18:45:46

It will sadly stop a lot of people asking for help and advice, fb is just too public, even with real names not shown.

Jalima1108 Wed 16-Aug-17 19:52:11

On a lighter note - Jalima, have a lovely time in Crete, but don't tell Gransnetters when you go unless you want FB to know
Thanks dbDB grin
I'll let you know when I come back - WARNING - never post your holiday pics on any forum when you're away - wait until you come home again (if at all).

Now, where're my holiday brochures?

Jalima1108 Wed 16-Aug-17 19:58:52

And gillybob appears to be guilty of identity theft as she has described me exactly.

She forgot to include my hobby of skydiving.

Crafting Wed 16-Aug-17 20:08:03

I was just going to post a supportive comment to someone where I was going to include my own experience but then realised the information may go to FB so I didn't post. This is so sad that people who need help are going to go without support because of what you are doing GNHQ

Moocow Wed 16-Aug-17 20:22:01

QUESTION for GNHQ --- why are gransnet posters not allowed to change their username as easily as mumsnet users?

Jalima1108 Wed 16-Aug-17 20:26:14

I am just searching the site to try to find out the terms and conditions of posting as I'm sure I read ages ago that all posts belong to Gransnet and can be used for whatever purpose, ie media articles etc.
However, perhaps I was mistaken as I can't find it now.

grumppa Wed 16-Aug-17 20:26:59

On the face of it, there is a confidentiality problem here as many more people look at Facebook than at Gransnet. But most people who find Gransnet on Facebook and look at the links are likely to be grandparents and potential Gransnet members anyway.

However, people do reveal their identity through what they write and what they call themselves, even when they are being discreet - not to everyone, but to a few people they may actually never have met. As an example, DW and I worked out exactly who one GN regular was even though we had never actually set eyes on her/him. And obviously, exposure via Facebook increases the risk of this happening.

So, be very, very careful.......

Jalima1108 Wed 16-Aug-17 20:28:17

By submitting user content to us, simultaneously with such posting you automatically grant to us a worldwide, fully-paid, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive, fully sublicensable, and transferable right and license to use, record, sell, lease, reproduce, distribute, create derivative works based upon (including, without limitation, translations), publicly display, publicly perform, transmit, publish and otherwise exploit the user content (in whole or in part) as Gransnet, in its sole discretion, deems appropriate. We may exercise this grant in any format, media or technology now known or later developed for the full term of any copyright that may exist in such user content.
www.gransnet.com/info/terms-of-use

FarNorth Wed 16-Aug-17 21:56:20

Well, I was thinking there seems to be another deafening silence from GNHQ, but I guess that quote from the terms and conditions will do instead.
Thanks, Jalima1108

Anniebach Wed 16-Aug-17 22:03:25

I cannot chat about my grandchildren anymore and they are the centre of my world , but two are on Facebook , and my daughter .