Gransnet forums

Chat

Thinking of what you should have said way too late.

(54 Posts)
Lizzies Thu 07-May-20 12:02:41

When I was just 18 I applied to be a helper at a school holiday club. One of the questions at the interview was “What would you do if you were outside with a group and some older teens started hassling you?” I, being shy and inexperienced, said I would call the police! I didn’t get the job. This morning while walking the dog, over 40 years later, I think I came up with the right response. I should have said “Do you want to come over here and I will look after you until your Mummies and Daddies can come and get you because behaving like that you are obviously not old enough to be out by yourself.” What do you think? And have you ever thought of the perfect response way too late?

vampirequeen Thu 07-May-20 12:05:13

I haven't done that but I do find myself tossing and turning at night replanning lessons in my head and thinking how much better my new idea would have been. I retired 9 years ago hmm

Elegran Thu 07-May-20 12:09:04

I do it all the time! I wish we could do an action replay and edit it.
I believe the French call it something like "Esprit d'escalier" or "Staircase wit" - the perfect retort, which occurs to you after you have left and are on the way home.

sodapop Thu 07-May-20 12:21:02

Happens to me all the time in conversation with French neighbours. Once I have moved on the light suddenly dawns and I realise what they actually said. I just hope I never inadvertently offend anyone.

JenniferEccles Thu 07-May-20 12:40:59

Oh we ALL do this I am sure!

We get home seething at a comment made possibly only a few minutes ago, and lo and behold, a suitable cutting reply comes to us!

Wouldn’t it be wonderful if the perfectly phrased response came to us instantly, but our brains don’t work like that, especially if we have been stunned at what was said or what happened.

Floradora9 Thu 07-May-20 15:54:04

My mother was in hospital quite ill . She had had a chest infection and had been on antibiotics and while we were visiting she kept having to ask for a bedpan . Eventually the nurse smiled at me and said " she thinks she has cystitis "
How I wish I had said at the time that she probably did as she always got this after a course of antibiotics. The nurse regarded her as a muddled old lady while I knew , apart from her deafness , she was compleyely lucid. I have never forgotten this .

AGAA4 Thu 07-May-20 16:00:44

I can't count the number of times I have the perfect quip too late.
Some people seem to have it inbuilt and I envy them.

polnan Fri 08-May-20 09:37:24

oh yes, sure every human being does this at some time or other
and yes, I mull over things during the night

apparently it is described as "monkey brain" so I am practising mindfulness and meditation, said to help

Calendargirl Fri 08-May-20 09:43:04

And I’m sure we have all said certain things, thinking it sounded witty, clever, funny at the time, then lain awake squirming at the recollection, thinking what in heaven’s name possessed me to say that?

timetogo2016 Fri 08-May-20 09:47:02

Luckily i am very quick witted.
A good friend of mine has said so many times how she wished i had been with her when someone said something untoward.
I think i am that way because i was bought up in pubs/clubs where my parents worked.

Candelle Fri 08-May-20 09:58:52

Lizzies, I'm obviously not the only one to dwell on situations that happened scores of years ago!

I think the current parlance is 'let it go'... but 'they' seem to have nowhere to go to!

micky987 Fri 08-May-20 10:00:10

I’m the same, I always come up with something smart/cheeky/sarcastic/very clever, AFTER the incident. I think that people like me who are maybe a bit soft/nice/descent are so shocked that someone would say something rude or blunt, that we’re taken aback. We are so shocked by what has been said that we’re not capable of a retort until the shock has worn off a bit and we’ve had time to think about it.

Tea and cake Fri 08-May-20 10:01:56

I tend to respond immediately and automatically, perhaps not always wisely!

mrsgreenfingers56 Fri 08-May-20 10:16:02

I spent a lot of time in Germany and the Germans say "The clever one gives in" and I always think of this when I feel I should have come up with a quick retort.

cas58 Fri 08-May-20 10:17:37

I have off and on days. Some days I am on form and can think on my feet so quickly, then, other days not a clue and too slow, then dwell on it.

I work with a guy who is a bit of a jackass and a pretty woman was in the office one day and after she left he rushed in asking who was that!? - I said, that's outta your league, he started swearing at me and I just said - so you kiss your blow up doll with that mouth. He didn't speak to me for a couple of days. My boss was there and he almost pissed himself laughing.
Good times (grin)

cas58 Fri 08-May-20 10:18:19

dang, did the grin wrong grin

SueWll Fri 08-May-20 10:35:55

Daughter in buggy, we were in a mall cafe sharing a table with a young man. He spilt his coffee down his front. Quick as a flash my mouth said "would you like a spare bib?" My brain said OMG. Then mouth and brain working together "I keep it for my husband"
25 years ago and I still cringe/laugh.

Grannynannywanny Fri 08-May-20 10:38:39

Calendargirl I know exactly what you mean. I’m still think “what possessed me to say that” since an encounter with a farmer on my daily country walk last week.

I had been fascinated to see, in a field of sheep, a black ewe with twin lambs. One black and the other white.

I took the chance to ask the farmer across the hedge. He said the ewe must have been served twice in the same day by 2 different rams.

I quipped “ lucky old girl!

I’m still cringing now thinking about it

Quizzer Fri 08-May-20 10:45:27

So many times!
However once I came up with a quick response I was so proud of.
I was in the supermarket when I met an acquaintance who was the world's worst male chauvinist. We were both comparing the prices of washing liquids, different offers, different sizes etc. He condescendingly said "You would need a maths degree so work out the best buy "
" Probably" I replied, fluttering my eyelashes," luckily I have one".
Funny, he hasn't tried to put me down since.

Lizzies Fri 08-May-20 11:00:28

Quizzer I love that, put him back in his box properly.

Oldwoman70 Fri 08-May-20 11:09:44

I am rarely quick with a come back but I recall one time when I managed to leave the office "joker" speechless. I was talking to a client when this colleague joined us, I happened to be bearing a red dress and he said did I know that red was a sexually aggressive colour. I slowly looked him up and down and said "I think you are safe". The client almost choked trying not to laugh.

Leah50 Fri 08-May-20 11:16:00

A supermarket checkout operator friend said to our little queue 'Last shift before I go on holiday, 'where are you going dear, Benidorm?' sneered the man in front of me. 'Patagonia actually,' she replied smiling, 'I've been round the world twice.' I've never forgotten the look on his face.

Moggycuddler Fri 08-May-20 11:43:38

Your retort would have been perfect for the teenage thugs. Or "Oh dear. Have you children lost your mummies?" In my experience at that age they do hate anything like that. Although to be honest I think the answer your interviewers would have been happiest with would have been that you would ignore them and move yourself and the children away if possible. And yes, call the police if things got worse.

Lettice Fri 08-May-20 11:55:17

My mother was an absolute ace at this sort of thing. One I remember is when a young lad was shouting and swearing (f word) in the street. She called to me "Come over here, love, and listen. This little boy has just learned a new word" And then she stood and clapped him. He went puce. She didn't smile.

NannyG123 Fri 08-May-20 11:58:45

I was in a discount warehouse quite a while ago, where they used to leave a trolley at th the bottom of the escalator with bargain goods in them. And one day I saw a trolley there and started to rummage through it. When a lady rushed up glaring at me and asked what I was doing going through her trolley. Without thinking I said I'm sorry I thought this was the cheap trolley. My daughter then about 10, ran and hid with embarrassment. I smile now when I think about it.