Gransnet forums

Chat

Would you pay this price?

(98 Posts)
grannyactivist Tue 23-Jun-20 22:10:37

I'm looking for a new colander. It needs to be sturdy, fit over a brewing bucket (I'm trying my hand at making wine for the first time) and preferably made of stainless steel. I intend to buy one from my local cook shop (we have two excellent ones locally), but I wanted an idea of cost and design, so I googled - and saw this 5 quart 18/8 Oxo Good Grips colander on Amazon. It costs an eye watering £81.29 (& FREE Delivery)!! Further down the same page is a very similar one that costs only £11.99 and looks to be very well made and good value.

It got me thinking about who it is that buys such very expensive items, someone must do so - is it you?

annodomini Wed 24-Jun-20 10:52:16

Dunelm has quite a large enamel colander for £8.

readsalot Wed 24-Jun-20 10:52:26

John Lewis has an OXO plastic colander with soft, silicone handles for £12. Pretty colour too.

rowanflower0 Wed 24-Jun-20 10:57:48

For winemaking, I use one like this:
www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Stainless-Steel-Fine-Mesh-Strainer-Kitchen-Bowl-Drainer-Vegetable-Sieve-Colander/1

Thecatshatontgemat Wed 24-Jun-20 10:58:31

I make wine, and not sure why you need a colander, but if you do, as long as you make sure it's stainless steel, it will do the job at whatever price you pay.
You might consider plastic, but make sure its clear or white, as colours in plastic sometimes react with the wine and leach into it. Which you don't want!
Good luck with your endeavor, you won't regret it. ?

nipsmum Wed 24-Jun-20 10:59:49

Professional establishments buy things at highly inflated prices. Its not their own money being spent . They tend not to shop around and they think they get better quality if they pay lots of money.

Gwenisgreat1 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:00:06

I would only pay that much for kitchen equipment if it was all singing dancing and would fetch the ingredients!!! My stainless steel colander - can't remember where I bought it or how much I paid, unlikely to have cost more than £5, more likely £2 or £3.

grannyscott Wed 24-Jun-20 11:01:49

I just googled it and saw a great one for £10 from John Lewis. The oxo one was £35 so do a little more research.

readsalot Wed 24-Jun-20 11:02:17

The same Oxo colander is available on Amazon for £26.76 free p&p, different supplier.

Dorsetcupcake61 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:05:56

Good grief I would expect it to come with a chef at that price!grin

Hetty58 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:13:35

OXO Good Grips stuff is great, nice and sturdy, well designed and ergonomic. I'd pay the £26.76 for the quality and ease of use- and this example just illustrates how very important it is to compare prices (including delivery) before ordering online!

Hetty58 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:21:40

btw I have their dish drainer, sink mat and shower plug cover!

Beanie654321 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:41:58

Try Wilko. Xx

Nannan2 Wed 24-Jun-20 11:49:51

Look on Lakeland online, they do good grips but i doubt theyre priced as dear as on amazon- (filled with idiot 3rd party sellers who think we're stupid enough to pay whatever they demand!) But they do all their own Lakeland stuff, and joseph joseph, and other more reasonable prices too, and all guaranteed at least 3 years i think. smile

grannybuy Wed 24-Jun-20 12:24:13

If it's the exact same one, I'd let the company know how inflated their price is.

grannyactivist Wed 24-Jun-20 12:30:14

I've just had a five minute tea break so came back on here to read the comments and it's been an interesting exercise; I had no idea that so few people read a whole thread. grin

I was only looking online to gauge prices and check out designs - I had no intention of buying, but was shocked at some of the exorbitant prices I saw.

I need a colander for my wine making because I used 4kgs of mixed berries, I used a (plastic) colander first and then strained the resulting juice through my trusty muslin contraption that I have for making jellies. The weight of the berries meant that my colander kept slipping off the bucket - it's a great colander, just not designed for this job.

It's my first go at making wine. I have so much soft fruit this year that I have a freezer full of berries, I've already made copious amounts of jam and so I decided to have a bash at wine making. A friendly allotment neighbour lent me a lot of his kit to get going and as I'm enjoying the process so much I've decided to invest in my own. Hence looking for ideas about which colander to buy.

Unfortunately I haven't found anyone in town who supplies wine making ingredients, I know it's all available from Wilko or specialist home brew outlets online, but my son lives very close to a shop in the city that supplies all the sundries for wine and beer making and is happy to pick things up for me.

Dottynan Wed 24-Jun-20 12:30:42

Robert Days Stainless Steel £5.99 24 cm

Rumpunch Wed 24-Jun-20 12:56:06

Do you actually need a colander? When I was making wine I used a very fine straining net or muslin, which you can get quite easily often with the jam making. You can also get a frame for it to hang from. I believe Dunelm do one and places like John Lewis and Lakelands

Bathsheba Wed 24-Jun-20 13:18:34

Bathsheba

I remember reading somewhere that when an eBay seller is out of stock of an item, they change the price to a silly amount so that no one orders anything until the item's back in stock. It keeps their listing active, because there is no facility to show an item is temporarily unavailable. Also, if they withdraw the item from their 'shop' then they lose everything associated with it, e.g. all the 5* reviews, 'best match' on eBay and in Google searches and so on.

Maybe it's similar with Amazon partners.

Judging by the number of posts still expressing shock at the exorbitant price, it seems that no-one has bothered to read my earlier post, which clearly explains it all!

newnanny Wed 24-Jun-20 13:19:30

About £20 is plenty to spend on a colundar in my opinion. I would not use it much and like Bridgeit would prefer to spend money on a takeaway.

Boolya Wed 24-Jun-20 13:59:53

I bought a blue plastic one when we were given some money as an engagement present. It’s now 50+ years old and shows no sign of falling apart. Not so good for wine making I’ll concede!

Aepgirl Wed 24-Jun-20 14:01:17

A lot of money for a bowlful of holes! Shop around - Lakeland, Ikea, HomeSense, and also local ‘cheapy’ shops. Why pay so much just for a trial go?

Kim19 Wed 24-Jun-20 14:05:57

No, I wouldn't spend that much for myself but, if someone dear had requested same as a gift, I would certainly come up with the goods even though I thought they were dotty. This causes me to smile because dear friend offered me anything I wanted up to £10 as a wedding gift. I chose a non-stick combination frying/poaching pan. I could tell she was absolutely horrified at my 'extravagant/trivial' selection. Old faithful is still going strong and used regularly 53 years on. Love it.

Bijou Wed 24-Jun-20 15:16:14

I too used to make a lot of wine and strained the fruit through a muslin bag.
Some of my kitchen pots and utensils are over fifty years old. I have a mincer that is seventy years old and still serviceable.
Saw a similar one in a museum in USA..

Uninspiringcowkeer Wed 24-Jun-20 15:51:20

Before lockdown I used to buy a lot on amazon. I now buy on eBay. Loads cheaper. Things may take a bit more looking for but worth it. A muslin bag works well for draining fruit etc for wine or a large laundry bag.

suelld Wed 24-Jun-20 18:30:59

Good price BUT I suspect that as this is a US company the shipping cost will increase the price dramatically??