Gransnet forums

Chat

How accurately does this describe your family?

(36 Posts)
Daddima Mon 19-Oct-20 10:50:39

For me, first and second child not exactly, but it’s number 3 to a tee!
For my brothers and me, it’s scarily accurate!

Marydoll Mon 19-Oct-20 10:51:28

Not at all! grin

Elegran Mon 19-Oct-20 10:58:38

Not mine either, Marydoll.

Rosalyn69 Mon 19-Oct-20 11:00:49

My son is an Only and the only trait he has on that list is Private. More information comes out of North Korea.

anna7 Mon 19-Oct-20 11:01:58

Not my family either. Couldn't be more wrong.

dontmindstayinghome Mon 19-Oct-20 11:07:48

I'm the middle one and it describes me very well.

The first is completely wrong, no similarities at all to my kind and gentle big Sister.

The third is a bit hit and miss but they've got self centred and financially irresponsible spot on!!

vampirequeen Mon 19-Oct-20 11:10:13

Yes this describes me DDs

vampirequeen Mon 19-Oct-20 11:10:47

or even my DDs lol

EllanVannin Mon 19-Oct-20 11:12:06

Doesn't ring true.

GrannySomerset Mon 19-Oct-20 11:13:47

DH and I, both only children, are a mix of first and only. DGD1 is also an only child and ticks most of the boxes in first and only categories. DD, first child, is certainly well described; DS, number two of two, is hard to categorise.

Lots of research evidence to support the view that first and only children are often over achievers so maybe that is because parenting the first child is a more anxious process?

geekesse Mon 19-Oct-20 11:16:43

Spot on for me and my brothers!

kittylester Mon 19-Oct-20 11:23:22

Not at all for my children but quite well for me and my youngest brother.

aggie Mon 19-Oct-20 11:26:52

I am the eldest , it doesn’t reflect me , nor my adult children

Chewbacca Mon 19-Oct-20 11:28:30

Not one of the examples fits any one of my family.

aggie Mon 19-Oct-20 11:31:46

Nor does any of the rest of my family fit into this

Franbern Mon 19-Oct-20 12:15:44

Not mine, but my second child, and eldest girl definitely fits as the eldest on that list. None of my others really fit any of them.

Callistemon Mon 19-Oct-20 12:29:03

I thought Yes, for some but not all of the traits , but then swapped the titles around and some of the traits also fit even then.

Lucca Mon 19-Oct-20 12:31:32

Not at all, not for me and my siblings nor for my children !

Davidhs Mon 19-Oct-20 12:41:02

Eldest child fits me, my eldest daughter and eldest grandson.

The arguments get quite heated!. LOL

3nanny6 Mon 19-Oct-20 12:48:51

The first one fits my youngest child quite well, and there are quite a few of the first one that fit my first child.
My middle child has more of the last child descriptions for her. The descriptions for middle child do not fit any of mine.

SueDonim Mon 19-Oct-20 13:45:36

The First Child description could be my third child, while my fourth child fits the Only Child description best! Neither of my first two children fit any of the categories.

Esspee Mon 19-Oct-20 13:54:00

No, sorry. I have looked at a number of families to compare it to that summary and see no correlation whatsoever.

PinkCakes Mon 19-Oct-20 14:46:20

I was last in my family. I'm all of those things except self-centred.

Grannybags Mon 19-Oct-20 14:51:50

Nothing like us not for me and siblings or my children!

FlexibleFriend Mon 19-Oct-20 15:29:07

Nothing like me or my siblings.