Gransnet forums

Chat

Do we need the monarchy in this day and and age?

(722 Posts)
maddyone Wed 23-Feb-22 11:48:54

Okay, it was suggested on a different thread that a new thread should be started about this, so here goes.
So do we need a monarchy today? That’s it really.

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 14:01:12

Rubbish, trisher

Nice try, though.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 25-Feb-22 14:04:10

I shall continue to read the post as I believe it was intended. Whether anyone else wants to make something out of it and call out the poster who I believe meant no offence is their business.

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 14:11:55

Well, I guess we can all decide for ourselves whether any offence was meant when a poster tells us to stop whingeing and implies that we don't appreciate the sacrifice of people who died in wars.

trisher Fri 25-Feb-22 14:23:41

Callistemon21

Rubbish, trisher

Nice try, though.

If I wrote about Christian celebrations and wrote
"celebrations of, say the 25th of December Christmas carol singing" would you then claim there was no link between celebrations and Christmas?

snowberryZ Fri 25-Feb-22 14:28:07

No.
They're all a waste of space especially Harry and Megan grin get rid of the lot of them I say.

Viva le Republique!

Jaxie Fri 25-Feb-22 15:47:46

To Germanshepherdsmum, Why am I being ridiculous? All kinds of buildings such as redundant mental institutions, barracks etc have been adapted to accommodate those who can’t afford to buy housing. What is wrong with the royal family offering some of their excess property to poor people or refugees?

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 15:53:04

trisher

Callistemon21

Rubbish, trisher

Nice try, though.

If I wrote about Christian celebrations and wrote
"celebrations of, say the 25th of December Christmas carol singing" would you then claim there was no link between celebrations and Christmas?

It's getting ridiculous now.

If you don't know the difference perhaps you need to do some research!

JacquiG Fri 25-Feb-22 16:11:20

I prefer that the armed forces would not have to pledge allegiance to the likes of Bozo. On the other hand, she did allow Bozo to prorogue Parliament which was the start of the rot.

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 16:25:06

They could pledge allegiance to us. The people.

Just a thought.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 25-Feb-22 16:31:01

The armed forces pledge allegiance to the monarch not the PM.

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 16:40:45

Germanshepherdsmum

The armed forces pledge allegiance to the monarch not the PM.

And if there was no monarch?

That's the point.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 25-Feb-22 16:43:57

Apologies for missing the point.

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 16:45:46

trisher

Germanshepherdsmum

‘Celebrations of’ is distinguished from ‘the Nov 11th parade …’. Note the comma. You wouldn’t say ‘the celebrations of the Nov 11th parade in honour of those who died’. You don’t celebrate a parade.

celebrations of say the November 11th
It's the say that links it.
Good try at supporting the insupportable though!

Yes, it's the say that links Armistice Day and Remembrance Sunday with eg Christmas celebrations etc when there is no link at all.

You cannot link two disparate things.

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 16:47:27

volver

They could pledge allegiance to us. The people.

Just a thought.

To the country, if that would not be considered jingoistic.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 25-Feb-22 16:48:01

Jaxie

To Germanshepherdsmum, Why am I being ridiculous? All kinds of buildings such as redundant mental institutions, barracks etc have been adapted to accommodate those who can’t afford to buy housing. What is wrong with the royal family offering some of their excess property to poor people or refugees?

Redundant mental hospitals and MoD sites have been sold to developers for market housing. I’ve dealt with the purchase of several.
Your suggestion that royal palaces should house the homeless would go down well in a communist country.

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 16:51:53

All kinds of buildings such as redundant mental institutions, barracks etc have been adapted to accommodate those who can’t afford to buy housing
But if done properly the accommodation tends to be upmarket and very expensive flats or apartments.

If carried out cheaply for emergency accommodation for eg asylum seekers it is often claimed it is not fit for purpose.

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 16:57:41

Germanshepherdsmum

Apologies for missing the point.

?

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 25-Feb-22 17:00:23

Spot on Callistemon. The most you’d get is a requirement for a proportion of ‘affordable’ housing amongst the expensive open market stuff and the developer would fight like hell for that not to be rented accommodation.

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 17:04:44

I saw a rather lovely house which had been part of a mental hospital (where a colleague worked) on Escape to the Country for around half a million £!

Kdaking Fri 25-Feb-22 19:26:30

I totally agree with the ‘monarchists’! If we did away with the Royal family who would we replace them with. Worth every penny. We could get a ‘Boris’, god forbid

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 19:28:55

And here she is.

She has a new outfit.

Lucca Fri 25-Feb-22 22:05:12

Kdaking

I totally agree with the ‘monarchists’! If we did away with the Royal family who would we replace them with. Worth every penny. We could get a ‘Boris’, god forbid

Oh…didn’t you forget Blair Corbyn Trump and Putin?

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 22:37:54

volver

And here she is.

She has a new outfit.

You've lost weight!

volver Fri 25-Feb-22 23:22:49

I've never been so insulted ???

Callistemon21 Fri 25-Feb-22 23:24:18

Call that an insult?
It was meant to be a compliment!