Gransnet forums

Chat

Women’s anatomy and medical students

(44 Posts)
Floriel Sun 01-May-22 22:29:07

Just watched a most interesting piece on BBC news about medical students having a fantastic new resource to study with - a completely accurate, 3D women’s anatomy. Totally shocked that for years the default study has been on the male body, almost as though women are just a smaller version with bits on! I naively thought this would have been done many years ago.

Pepper59 Mon 02-May-22 03:05:26

It's shocking how nearly all research has been done only on male health. We are half the population. I only hope this new medical marvel can help educate them in women's health, particularly the thyroid gland where ignorance abounds,in particular educate GP's and Endocrinologists. I was told by my own GP ( now retired). ' I know nothing about the thyroid gland'. If I had a pound for each time I heard this from different people, I'd be a very rich woman.

grandMattie Mon 02-May-22 04:53:30

It shocking, isn’t it?
Try reading “Invisible Women” by Caroline Criado Perez, and you will be horrified. Would easily turn me into a radicalised feminist.

absent Mon 02-May-22 05:57:38

Throughout nature the longer-living creature is, barring accidents, always the female because she bears and nurtures the next generation. Every species does this. It is why peahens, for example, look dull, drab and can easily conceal themselves from predators but peacocks are colourful to attract mates.

I think I read some serious article quite a while ago about how the "default" for a foetus is always female. Think about inherited diseases or problems that affect only those with Y chromosomes.

It is no surprise to me that medical science still regards male as the "norm". This has less to do with science and everything to do with so many centuries of the way women were regarded. It takes a very long time to undermine preconceptions

M0nica Mon 02-May-22 06:52:44

I suspect this ignorance of the female body may go far back in time when strict rules of modesty governed women and there was a reticence in using the female body as a naked and displayed the female body carried a elelment that only prostitutes bared their body to the male gaze.

Mind you, in the days before the internet, we had a medical book that included pictures of the stripped of skin male and female bodies.

Ladyleftfieldlover Mon 02-May-22 06:54:29

grandMattie

It shocking, isn’t it?
Try reading “Invisible Women” by Caroline Criado Perez, and you will be horrified. Would easily turn me into a radicalised feminist.

A friend lent me that book. I was so annoyed that I had to stop reading it! Unbelievable.

Oopsadaisy1 Mon 02-May-22 07:51:19

Is it illegal yet to perform internal examinations on anaesthetised Women?
Sometimes students were ‘invited’ to perform pelvic examinations on women who were already in the operating theatre for other reasons, sometimes more than one student. This was for Training purposes.
Read the consent form before you sign if you don’t want this to happen as I’m not sure if the practice has been stopped.

snowberryZ Mon 02-May-22 07:57:23

Yes there are SO many differences between women and men.
Its not just a case of outward appearances.
Can't argue with science.

Hetty58 Mon 02-May-22 08:08:59

Floriel, yes, I saw that - a bit horrified that they've only now got around to changing things.

argymargy Mon 02-May-22 08:11:30

Pepper59

It's shocking how nearly all research has been done only on male health. We are half the population. I only hope this new medical marvel can help educate them in women's health, particularly the thyroid gland where ignorance abounds,in particular educate GP's and Endocrinologists. I was told by my own GP ( now retired). ' I know nothing about the thyroid gland'. If I had a pound for each time I heard this from different people, I'd be a very rich woman.

It may shock you to know that men have a thyroid too. GPS cannot possibly know about the entirety of the human body and its vagaries - hence we have specialists.

JackyB Mon 02-May-22 08:35:17

We often hear too that things like the menopause and PMT are not sufficiently researched. I'm not sure how true this is, but it is often mentioned on science podcasts and radio programmes.

Pepper59 Mon 02-May-22 11:41:01

Argy margy, Im quite aware men have a thyroid gland, in a support group I attended there were many fewer men with thyroid issues. Sadly some men seemed to be ignored just as much as women were. Attitudes to women by medical professionals in my and others experience is far worse. They also tend to talk to you like you are a four year old. I hope you never get thyroid issues and meet the attitudes I have. Go onto the forums at Thyroid UK, read the experiences of thousands of women on the forums there and some awful stories. Then compare the amount of men on that forum. I hope you never suffer and I mean suffer with any thyroid issue. It's destroyed health, careers, relationships, yet we are the poor relatives for health care. You are either depressed or overeating. Anything but taken seriously. There was one man in my group who gave up going to the doctor at all. Other people spent thousands on private treatment. Most Endocrinoligists are patronising and follow outdated treatment from about 30 years ago and it's a worldwide problem, not just here.

BlueSky Mon 02-May-22 12:09:56

Oopsadaisy I was going to say, there’s bound to be a consent form to sign where this would be mentioned.

Fleur20 Mon 02-May-22 12:15:10

EVERYTHING is designed for the male body.
Seats, table heights, cars, ladders.... all the things we use every day are based on being used primarily by men.

FarNorth Mon 02-May-22 12:21:51

BlueSky I'd take a wild guess that it isn't stated clearly on the consent form but is in disguised language so that patients don't realise unless they are looking for it .

snowberryZ Mon 02-May-22 14:17:27

Fleur20

EVERYTHING is designed for the male body.
Seats, table heights, cars, ladders.... all the things we use every day are based on being used primarily by men.

So true.
Not forgetting seatbelts.
Also, in-ear head phones are designed for mens bigger lugholes.
They don't always fit properly in our 'often smaller' much narrower ear canals.

snowberryZ Mon 02-May-22 15:19:25

This goes to prove once and for all all and beyond all reasonable doubt that men and women are completely different and in more ways than we realise.

Its very brave of these people to do this
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-61258731

FarNorth Mon 02-May-22 15:53:43

Clearly they don't consider it brave, just factual .

snowberryZ Mon 02-May-22 19:56:15

That's what's so refreshing
Facts have been put first, before feelings.
For a change.

Treetops05 Tue 03-May-22 11:26:19

I have an unusual medical condition, and have to explain it to every single Dr I meet; apart from one Specialist in London. There are amazing gaps in medical training which worry me greatly...

Nanatoone Tue 03-May-22 11:47:40

Whilst there is a huge amount of truth in what is said here, I don’t think men’s health is prioritised. Having lost my husband to prostate cancer, where a simple blood test, done early enough would have saved his life. Medics won’t test based on false positives but oh I so wish I’d known we could have asked.

Bazza Tue 03-May-22 11:48:20

I also saw this piece on the news and could hardly believe it was true! Female anatomies are inevitably more complex than male. How on earth do you show where a uterus, ovaries or fallopian tubes are on a male anatomy?

Grantanow Tue 03-May-22 11:50:30

Many years ago I visited a medical school dissection room for a research project and I saw they had both male and female cadavers for the students to study. Obviously they were not focussing solely on the male body.

Tuskanini Tue 03-May-22 12:17:07

I think the program was exaggerating rather. But yes, there should be a whole branch of medicine focussing on women's issues. Hold on, there is. Gynaecology.

Tinydancer Tue 03-May-22 12:23:27

Heart attack symptoms can be extremely different for men and women but for years it was only ever the male symptoms that were warned about. As a young female with a blocked coronary artery my gp dismissed me inspite of a strong family history at a young aage.At my request she even said she would do a private referral and then didn't bother. The private consultant in the following letter to her described me as having all the symptoms, in other words a mild telling off. Her behaviour afterwards was even worse. So I think as I was a female she just didn't think it possible.