Gransnet forums

Chat

The SNP is in a ‘tremendous mess’ apparently.

(499 Posts)
Urmstongran Mon 20-Mar-23 09:43:57

Since these two stepped down within weeks of one another the SNP seems to be imploding at a rate of knots.

What on Earth is going on? There is so much in-flighting.

Oreo Tue 21-Mar-23 18:31:37

Except you aren’t heading off Maremia what you mean is that you’d like to.Hardly the same thing.

SueDonim Tue 21-Mar-23 19:21:27

I haven’t seen anything to indicate that Kate Forbes would impose her religious beliefs on the rest of Scotland. Has she said she would ban abortion and sex before marriage?

Grayling1 Tue 21-Mar-23 19:34:42

Question - who is calling for the banning of alcohol in Scotland? Can someone tell me please?

Callistemon21 Tue 21-Mar-23 21:52:13

Grayling1

Question - who is calling for the banning of alcohol in Scotland? Can someone tell me please?

What - even whisky?

You cannot be serious!

volver3 Tue 21-Mar-23 22:12:48

Nobody is calling for the banning of alcohol in Scotland.

Callistemon21 Tue 21-Mar-23 22:23:53

Grayling1

Question - who is calling for the banning of alcohol in Scotland? Can someone tell me please?

It could be a proposed ban on advertising alcohol?

The rules are quite strict in the UK already.

paddyann54 Tue 21-Mar-23 22:48:42

copied from The Lancet.

Minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol has been linked to a 13% drop in deaths from alcohol consumption, according to a study.

The research, published in The Lancet, suggests 156 deaths per year on average in Scotland may have been prevented due to the pricing policy, which was implemented in May 2018.

Over the two years and eight months since the policy was implemented, researchers found there was a "significant" 13.4% reduction in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol consumption compared to an estimate, using data from England, of the deaths that would have occurred had the legislation not been implemented.

There was a 4.1% reduction in hospitalisations for conditions wholly attributable to alcohol consumption, equivalent to avoiding 411 hospitalisations per year, on average.

Researchers also found that significant reductions in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol consumption were greatest for men and for those living in the 40% most socio-economically deprived areas of Scotland.

paddyann54 Tue 21-Mar-23 22:50:03

Nota BAN on booze just trying to mitigate the damage from it...and its working !

Callistemon21 Tue 21-Mar-23 23:12:18

You can't use supermarket store vouchers or special offers to buy alcohol in Wales.

Wheniwasyourage Wed 22-Mar-23 14:12:03

You can't buy alcohol in Scotland before 10am and there are no multi-buy cheap offers. This has been the case for some time, and does not amount to banning alcohol!

M0nica Wed 22-Mar-23 16:02:21

I think the Scottish scheme to put minimum prices on units of alcohol makes much more sense that the British Governments sugar tax, which led to manufacturers replacing sugar in their products with artificial sweeteners, that are probably no better for us than sugar.

multicolourswapshop Wed 22-Mar-23 16:39:23

That’s me joined more to come

Aveline Wed 22-Mar-23 19:24:38

What? More lies and obfuscation? You must be a glutton for punishment. Unfortunately we all suffer under this useless 'government'.

Callistemon21 Wed 22-Mar-23 19:42:57

multicolourswapshop

That’s me joined more to come

How come you have only just joined?

I am curious - is this happening now that Ms Sturgeon has gone? I'd have thought the opposite would be happening.

volver3 Wed 22-Mar-23 19:45:14

Callistemon21

multicolourswapshop

That’s me joined more to come

How come you have only just joined?

I am curious - is this happening now that Ms Sturgeon has gone? I'd have thought the opposite would be happening.

Well how wrong can you be?

Maybe people weren't idolising Sturgeon after all, but just want independence.

Heavens to Betsy. 😲

Callistemon21 Wed 22-Mar-23 19:52:42

I goodness, I post and lo and behold, along comes volver to tell me how wrong I am 😂😂😂
Again.

In fact, was asking multicolourswapshop a question, not you.

volver3 Wed 22-Mar-23 19:56:17

We obviously come online at about the same time.

Its an online forum. Questions aren't secret. I can post anything within the rules.

And I did. 😉

Callistemon21 Wed 22-Mar-23 19:57:01

Callistemon21

multicolourswapshop

That’s me joined more to come

How come you have only just joined?

I am curious - is this happening now that Ms Sturgeon has gone? I'd have thought the opposite would be happening.

multicolouredswapshop
I am just curious why you have just joined.

Do you think a new leader, a fresh attitude towards this, might be better at achieving independence?

MerylStreep Wed 22-Mar-23 20:06:13

Callistemon21

I goodness, I post and lo and behold, along comes volver to tell me how wrong I am 😂😂😂
Again.

In fact, was asking multicolourswapshop a question, not you.

Callistemon
Surely you’re flattered that a poster is soooo interested in what you have to say 🤔

LadyHonoriaDedlock Wed 22-Mar-23 20:22:23

To get things in some kind of perspective, at the time Alec Salmond stood down from the leadership after the 2014 referendum, the SNP was still a wee party with just a few thousand members and a constitution that was geared to a small party – for example in determining the number of delegates could send to annual conference. The first time I went to conference at the Armadillo in Glasgow in autumn 2016 the whole centre was packed and not all delegates could get into the main auditorium for the leader's speech. Somebody showed me one of the small conference rooms in the complex that was where the whole conference took place a couple of years earlier. Even so, in 2006 there was still a sense that everybody knew everybody else and even somebody like me could rub shoulders with the movers and shakers.

Even if the membership has fallen off in the last few years, and Covid had a lot to do with that as well as some of the shine rubbing off, Nicola leaves the party much bigger and stronger than it was when she inherited it. Unfortunately it's also a party with many members who have grown used to power and the backstabbing and infighting has set in just as it does in the other major parties.

Aveline Wed 22-Mar-23 20:32:06

Yes. It happens to all parties.

Callistemon21 Wed 22-Mar-23 22:30:54

MerylStreep

Callistemon21

I goodness, I post and lo and behold, along comes volver to tell me how wrong I am 😂😂😂
Again.

In fact, was asking multicolourswapshop a question, not you.

Callistemon
Surely you’re flattered that a poster is soooo interested in what you have to say 🤔

I'm immensely flattered MerylStreep 😂

Callistemon21 Wed 22-Mar-23 22:35:21

Thanks LadyHonoriaDedlock

Interesting and confirms what I thought about the growth of the party.
Although Alec Salmond certainly brought more awareness of the SNP to the rest of the country.

Mollygo Wed 22-Mar-23 22:52:35

Callistemon21

I goodness, I post and lo and behold, along comes volver to tell me how wrong I am 😂😂😂
Again.

In fact, was asking multicolourswapshop a question, not you.

And you were surprised? Surely not.

LadyHonoriaDedlock Wed 22-Mar-23 23:26:14

I meant 2016 not 2006. Doh!