Gransnet forums

Chat

Trees Are Conscious

(86 Posts)
Caleo Tue 23-Apr-24 11:27:39

All things that strive to live are conscious.

Artificial intelligence things don't strive to live so those are not conscious.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 25-Apr-24 20:16:29

Yes, when I walk through woods or really anywhere where there are trees, I can feel their wisdom and gentleness. I can’t explain it, but I always come home spiritually refreshed.

Anniebach Thu 25-Apr-24 20:20:15

Same for me Whitewave

Callistemon21 Thu 25-Apr-24 22:49:41

I talk to the trees
But they don't listen to me 🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵

Perhaps they do 🙂

maddyone Thu 25-Apr-24 23:02:22

All of nature is uplifting. Being out of doors is known to be good for people. That doesn’t mean trees have consciousness, it means being in the great outdoors among nature is good for us, both physically and mentally.

Callistemon21 Thu 25-Apr-24 23:17:51

You know grass and tree do have consciousness, maddyone, you must have heard the song 😃

www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3D10dmK7O-KSY&ved=2ahUKEwibuLj9sd6FAxUQX0EAHZWUB98QtwJ6BAgaEAE&usg=AOvVaw1FV3s7S4Uuji6okcJGwV94

maddyone Thu 25-Apr-24 23:52:56

Haha, oh yes, whispering grass.

I think I’ll believe trees have consciousness when, if I speak to one, it answers me 😂

Curtaintwitcher Fri 26-Apr-24 07:03:14

It has been proven that different trees give off different energies, so the old folklore about them may well be true. Druids honoured the oak tree as a source of very positive energy. However, this does not make them sentient.

Ali08 Fri 26-Apr-24 08:17:21

Let's hope AI never gets conscious!!

keepcalmandcavachon Fri 26-Apr-24 08:22:42

Whitewavemark2

Yes, when I walk through woods or really anywhere where there are trees, I can feel their wisdom and gentleness. I can’t explain it, but I always come home spiritually refreshed.

Me too sunshinesunshinesunshine

M0nica Fri 26-Apr-24 08:46:50

maddyone you are confusing cosnciousness with consciousnes with being sentient. Plants react when damaged.

britannica.com/story/do-plants-feel-painhttps://www.britannica.com/story/do-plants-feel-pain

vegansrock Fri 26-Apr-24 08:51:07

Well plants are living things, but do not have a brain or central nervous system so are certainly not conscious or aware in the same way as humans. It’s a bit wooo to say they are spiritual beings , you can’t extrapolate human physical pains or emotions to plants.

MissAdventure Fri 26-Apr-24 09:51:46

They're not sentient beings, as far as my thoughts go, which is admittedly not very far.

maddyone Fri 26-Apr-24 10:14:06

Plants are neither sentient nor have consciousness. They are alive but have no consciousness. If people believe they do and it makes them feel happy, then fine, believe it if you wish. It doesn’t mean it’s true, but strangely some who reject the idea of a God or anything religious, are making claims that trees are sentient or have consciousness.
They don’t.
But each to his/her own. It doesn’t do any harm, and if it makes a person feel better, so be it.

maddyone Fri 26-Apr-24 10:15:02

I agree with vegansrock and MissA.

Callistemon21 Fri 26-Apr-24 10:18:58

maddyone

Haha, oh yes, whispering grass.

I think I’ll believe trees have consciousness when, if I speak to one, it answers me 😂

It will just blabber your secrets to all the others plants in the forest.
Never trust a blabbering tree.

Callistemon21 Fri 26-Apr-24 10:21:22

I do talk to them sometimes . And to other plants.
And stroke their bark.

maddyone Fri 26-Apr-24 10:27:31

I’d run a mile if I heard a tree blabber Calli.

Callistemon21 Fri 26-Apr-24 10:28:45

It's ok, you just have to threaten it by saying "Chop, chop"

Mollygo Fri 26-Apr-24 10:43:35

Callistemon21
Thanks for that link. I’ve enjoyed the video several times already today and I’m singing it in my head!

Callistemon21 Fri 26-Apr-24 10:51:07

Glad you enjoyed it!

It's my ear worm for the weekend 😁

Making a change from Fernando (the ABBA thread) and Lwave Right Now (the car radio)

Callistemon21 Fri 26-Apr-24 10:51:37

Leave!!

Whispering Leaves .....

Athrawes Fri 26-Apr-24 11:03:45

I love trees. We have a lovely big tree in our garden and its whispering branches in the breeze are delightful.
Funnily enough I saw an old film on TV yesterday about an elderly man trying to find out if trees and flowers responded to being attacked eg by scissors for flowers and an axe for a tree. He had devised a device to find out the answer and got a doctor to listen in who found it uncanny.

Oreo Fri 26-Apr-24 12:09:20

maddyone

All of nature is uplifting. Being out of doors is known to be good for people. That doesn’t mean trees have consciousness, it means being in the great outdoors among nature is good for us, both physically and mentally.

I agree.
Being amongst nature really is uplifting, but trees don’t have consciousness and they’re not wise.

Oreo Fri 26-Apr-24 12:10:05

Callistemon21

I do talk to them sometimes . And to other plants.
And stroke their bark.

Did they consent to this stroking?😲

vegansrock Fri 26-Apr-24 13:09:32

We may feel uplifted when out in nature, but that doesn’t mean trees have awareness of our feelings.