I have downloaded literally hundreds of papers from the learned journals and in the press (I produce a current affairs email for a local group) and this is the most appalling over-reaction to a respiratory virus ever! Using the current criteria, we would have to lock down in the flu season EVERY year. Tom Jefferson and Carl Heneghan from the Oxford Centre for Evidence Based Medicine have handed the PM a blueprint: Planning the Way Forward, which is complete common sense and based on established practices for dealing with pandemic infections. This virus is not Ebola, it is not Spanish Flu, it is not the Black Death (I know, that's bacterial), it has an Infection Fatality Rate of between 0.1 and 0.2%. That's one or two per thousand infected, with the very elderly disproportionately infected (x1000) as opposed to seasonal flu, which kills some children and young people every year. We had a low flu season last winter, and sadly, Covid is taking away the elderly frail who would have died of the flu, or even a cold. Is it actually worse to die of Covid or of flu? SAGE is stuffed full of mathematical modellers and sociologists who are working to models and projections. It has become an echo chamber and they are now determined to 'prove' that their initial modelling is correct. However, as the physicist Richard Feynman said: "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong." Well, the 'experiment' is real-world data: the fact is that the Death Rate is NORMAL for the time of year. Having 85 - 90% intensive care bed occupancy is NORMAL - would you want your intensive care beds running at 60%. Only 48 Nightingale Hospital beds were ever used. Does it matter that the infection rate, based on a hundreds of thousands of tests, is running higher than the 'reasonable worst case scenario'? No, it doesn't, because what matters is hospitalisation and death rates, which are NORMAL. The Zoe Covid Symptom App and study, with 4 million app users, is showing that the infection rate is mainly passing harmlessly among young and healthy people, and that the infection rate is either levelling off, or coming down. The PM is inexperienced at governing, ignorant of science, and terrified of admitting that they got it wrong. He has been taken in thrall by SAGE, who will never have to suffer redundancy, penury and the other consequences of Lockdown, and can never be voted out. Remember, infections are coming down NOW. they will claim it was their lockdown which did it, just as in the Spring, when the infection rate had already peaked. As Richard Feynman also said: "I believe that a scientist looking at nonscientific problems is just as dumb as the next guy." Time for Boris and the whole cabinet to look at the wider harms and issues, and put them on the balance sheet. Time for some rational thinking and honesty!