I agree with you GandTea that whatever diet you decide on, you can lose weight if you stick to it, and I suspect you are having a lighthearted dig? at the dieting industry, and the entrenched positions that fat v carbs protagonists may take. I think you'll see if you read through postings on here (may take weeks) that we are a fun lot, not too prescriptive and very supportive. Many of us want to reduce blood sugar because we have a problem and are insulin resistant, indeed many have this problem and are blissfully unaware, unless they have a blood test. The concern with carbs is that some do not know that they convert to sugar in bloodstream, eg small plain baked potato can raise blood sugar as much as 9 teaspoons of sugar. Many avoid sugary stuff, but when carbs reach the blood stream there is no difference, and I would echo what Mamie has said. OK lecture over.......I like alcohol too!