Learning languages with Duolingo

It has inspired me I have to say. I'm off to the Gaelic college on the Isle of Skye as a result of a mix of Duolingo and an online course.
My DS is learning Italian the same way

They are indeed, Foxygloves 😊

I tried learning Italian with Duolingo during the pandemic but found its “phrase book” style without any indication of the grammar underpinning the phrases pretty useless.
A whole session of saying “I am a man/woman” was pretty boring too! As a linguist I appreciate a balance of colloquial phrases, an idea of the grammatical framework to support building my own phrases or sentences and a variety of vocabulary.
But deep down there is no substitute for listening to and speaking a language if possible in the country in question for the full immersive experience.
I remember our French teacher at school saying “Go to France and get a French boyfriend, that’s how to learn French”
(Other countries and nationalities of boyfriend are of course available.)

-I put up with this as I am using it to revise my knowledge of German, but as they never explain grammar at all, I doubt you could actually learn the language properly using duolingo.-

Grandtante, have you tried listening to “Easy German” ( a misnomer imo) where native speakers go auf der Strasse and chat with other native speakers on various topics. Subtitles are given. I use this quite a lot. I gave up on Duolingo.

I’ve been learning Spanish for over 2 or 3 years continuously with DuoLingo.

I have only recently started to pay an annual fee as it said I could make more than 5 errors and it would be tailored to my weak areas. Well the errors bit is right but they haven’t changed the format or given me tips when I make errors. I’m rather disappointed.

I like their Guide Books but would like a hard copy to re-read and learn from. In the end I have found online some grammar rules which I have printed off.

Lastly they keep adding new words and verbs which I write down in a book but they don’t repeat them enough for me to learn them at 76 !

To be honest I’m feeling rather disheartened but I won’t give up.

I would like to stop but have a 247 day streak and am reluctant to break it. I started just to keep my mind active, I should really do something that would be of more use to me.

I still don't feel that I can speak or understand spoken french well but am ok at reading and writing it.

It is possible to listen via podcasts but I don't.

ixion

Where is StarDreamer when you need him?

In a distant Galaxy, far, far away?

FannyCornforth

JackyB if I were to learn a language it would probably be Polish.
A gentleman that I randomly met in Waterstones told me that for English speakers, Polish was one of the hardest languages to learn.
What are your thoughts?

For me the hardest is Welsh. I feel like I’ve been doing Duolingo forever. My favourite activity is learning French as a Dutch speaker.

I have been using Duolingo since I first saw this post, but frankly their German course is appalling.

They write their English sentences to be translated into German in such slangy American English that at times they are incomprehensible, they expect you to translate the simple past tense to the German perfect tense, even in instances where no native German speaker would, a good many of their listening exercises are so inaudable that you cannot avoid making mistakes, and they use slangy German expressions quite often in preference to more correct German.

I find these things infuriating, and there is no way you can complain to whoever runs duolingo that I can find.

Most maddening of all, they adore sentences such as "When are you leaving?" and only accept one out of three possible German tranlations. As there is no reading exercise or any other form of context "you" in this kind of sentence could mean either "du" singular informal, "ihr" plural informal, or "Sie" singular and plural formal German pronouns.

I put up with this as I am using it to revise my knowledge of German, but as they never explain grammar at all, I doubt you could actually learn the language properly using duolingo.

And they insist upon telling us what else we could have written in English - rather unnecessarily as it is German we are trying to learn!

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Where is StarDreamer when you need him?

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Duolingo is a very good app, I learned Spanish there at one time

The units look to be arranged differently but I haven’t tried to do my next lesson yet.

Duolingo have updated their website. On my laptop I can't seem to get back to the exercises I was on until today, although on my phone I can.

Anyone else affected in this way?

I am on various mailing lists by choice.

A link to the following arrived today.

LINK > www.dictionary.com/e/hardestlanguage

I have a 23 day streak . I like to spend some time on it every day, repetition is important in recovering and maintaining function after brain injury, whether cognitive or physical. And it’s fun too.

Knowing some Esperanto has helped me understand more about languages generally, because Esperanto has enough to carry out the function of being a language, yet without the irregulrities that many natural languages have.

It is a like a work of art and a scientific mechanism at the same time.

Hi FarNorth.

I am learning Welsh. I am finding it fascinating.

I am also going through the Esperanto course.

I got an advanced placement with Esperanto but I wiped it so that I could go through it from the start, as I learned what I know of Esperanto from the Teach Yourself Esperanto book many years ago.

I am glad I am doing that as there is vocabulary that i did not know previously.

With the Welsh I have completed eight "circles" at the learning level and there are two more circles until what looks like a small castle.

I have also completed some of the higher levels for the earlier circles.

Esperanto is a really beautiful language.

Esperanto estas belega lingvo.

Thank you .
I don't feel particularly drawn to Italian, or Italy, but I'll give this a go as something different.

In case anyone is interested, there is the plan to try to learn some Italian from the Duolingo course, starting from the beginning, at the rate of one lesson each day, and discussing it and posting a sentence or two in Italian, as an optional part of the acivity of the

LINK > www.gransnet.com/forums/culture_arts/1314201-Venice-and-the-river-Po-a-virtual-cruise

thread.

The plan is to try to start on Monday, but if anyone wants to start earlier and do the first lesson before Monday, please do.

Wheniwasyourage

Not in Gaelic, I would bet, Ailidh!

?????????

Thank you for the tips , I’m off to see what I can do ?

Ailidh

Aggie - if you open a French lesson, go up to the top of the page and click on the (presumably French) flag on the left hand side, it'll open up the flags of any other languages you might be doing. Click on the Scottish flag.

Fàilte! Welcome! (haven't learned how to say "welcome back" yet.....)

And also offers the opportunity to add another language.

Not in Gaelic, I would bet, Ailidh!