Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Toxic Mother

(346 Posts)
Gampsy Tue 24-Aug-21 22:11:51

Hi All,
This is my first time posting and I would really appreciate your thoughts and comments on my relationship with my Mum. To cut a long story short, my brother and I have spent our lives walking on eggshells with her and she has always tried to play us off against each other. Our children have watched her emotionally abuse us but we have remained loyal and steadfast out of a sense of duty and begrudging love. She is now in her 80’s and since our Dad died she has unleashed her full toxicity on her friends, shop staff and us. She thinks that she can sulk, belittle and abuse us and when we push back she denies everything and says she doesn’t care about anyone and that she wishes she was dead - something she’s been saying for over 30 years when she feels called out on her bs. My brother had Covid and she didn’t even call to see how he was and when I said, imagine something happened to him, she said “well I could die anytime”. I phone her and get her shopping twice a week but apparently her neighbour’s son goes round three times a week!!! She is now not talking to my brother or his wife because she upset them and THEY haven’t apologised to her. I tried today to rationalise with her but she’s adamant she doesn’t care about anyone and I know when i phone her I will get the silent treatment to make me feel guilty. I’m wondering if I should cut ties with her even though I know I will feel guilty but my mental, physical and emotional health have taken a battering for many years and I can’t take much more. If she was an abusive partner I would have walked years ago so why are we allowing her to treat us like this? Please help.

Madgran77 Tue 07-Sept-21 09:00:36

Susan56 A wake up call indeed! flowers

Grandmabatty Tue 07-Sept-21 12:41:47

Susan I'm sorry to hear that you are unwell. You owe your mum nothing and can well do without added stress. ?

maddyone Tue 07-Sept-21 12:54:27

Susan, Grandmabatty is right, you need to concentrate on getting well. flowers

Lizzy60 Thu 09-Sept-21 06:21:19

Sounds like depression to me , don't be too hard on the lady . She may be deeply unhappy in her later years . Remain in contact but keep the conversation light . This is what we do as carers of the elderly . Its no fun being old in today's society , afterall !

VioletSky Thu 09-Sept-21 11:15:19

It was believed for a long time that physical problems were the worst and anything mental was not a big deal. Everyone remembers that saying:

Stick and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me.

I think that's why we have ended up with so many people who sadly have abusive parents. Not only did a lot of parents not deal with their own emotional wounds growing up, they they then passed it on to their children.

Mental health matters and emotional abuse can cause just as serious and long term consequences as physical abuse. Emotional abuse literally makes changes in the brain. Those physical changes can cause more susceptibility to illnesses triggered by stress, addiction, anxiety, depression, and even personality disorders.

We have so many adults responsible for fixing themselves because of this, even if that's just learning healthy boundaries and being able to protect ourselves.

We can do it. We can be happy and healthy and we can break the cycle. That's the important thing. Just small positive changes.

Sometimes we have to mother ourselves.

Hithere Thu 09-Sept-21 11:51:38

Amazing post, violetsky

maddyone Thu 09-Sept-21 12:53:12

Good post VioletSky.

Smileless2012 Thu 09-Sept-21 13:18:57

Whatever decisions you may or may not make Gampsy put your own long term well being first, and for me that includes considering how you might feel if you do decide to break all contact with your mum. A point I made earlier on, on this thread.

As long as you are protecting yourself, any decision you make will be the right one for you, and that's all that mattersflowers.

Whiff Thu 09-Sept-21 13:54:34

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Millie22 Thu 09-Sept-21 14:35:05

I'm confused by all this name changing. I thought I didn't recognise you VioletSky but forgot about this thread where you have given such a lot of good advice. It's a bit of a mystery.

VioletSky Thu 09-Sept-21 15:20:48

Thank you, I'm so glad if it helped people

Allsorts Thu 09-Sept-21 15:46:11

I think I know who Violet sky is, I left the forum because of the posts and rejoined under a new name. I said I wouldn’t look at any others in a similar vein.

Smileless2012 Thu 09-Sept-21 15:54:16

It's a shame when people leave because of unpleasantness Allsorts and it's good to see that you've returnedsmile

welbeck Thu 09-Sept-21 17:11:49

for those battling, or trying to survive toxic people in their lives, when they become abusive, could you try talking about yourselves almost, rather than reacting or worse bottling the negative emotion.
eg say, i've been advised not to linger in company that is destructive to my self worth. for the good of my health.
and leave/ end call.
so you are making a statement about yourself, but not then discussing it, just acting in self protection, as advised.
eg someone who finds it difficult to decline a drink in company, may find it easier to say, no thank you, doctor's orders.
so you can say you have been advised to have only positive influences in your life. you don't have to give further details.
which is true. we've advised it. and then calmly leave.
good luck.

Smileless2012 Thu 09-Sept-21 18:19:42

Some good advice there welbecksmile.

topcat223 Fri 08-Oct-21 15:22:38

Gampsy,

Sorry for the late reply, but better late than never...

I speak from experience and found that although I am still in contact with my mother - the occasional phone call etc, I had to go through a period of mourning so to speak for the mother I never had or never will have - I won't lie this was very painful and difficult, took me nearly two years before I came out the other end, but once you have done this life and your relationship becomes much easier - also limit contact and if your mother starts the blame game just say got to go now and put the phone down - once you've done this a few times they get the message and start to monitor their remarks more.. you have to let go of hoping for a different outcome either from the past or the future - you will need help and guidance for this but just google it and you will find what you need to get you through. If your mother shuns you then she is only hurting herself in the long run and will end up contacting you once she realizes you are serious - The best of luck and remember that you have been betrayed in one way or another throughout your whole life by the very person who should have given you unconditional love.

Allsorts Fri 08-Oct-21 16:08:51

I do think it’s a shame waiting until someone is in their 80’s and needing help, to decide this is the time to distance from a toxic parent. Surely this difficult person should have had a frank discussion years ago, to enable change or get used to not having family support.

VioletSky Fri 08-Oct-21 17:19:40

It's never too late to put boundaries in place and take measures to protect our own mental health.

maddyone Fri 08-Oct-21 17:20:19

Allsorts from your post I would guess you’ve not had a toxic parent. I hope that is the case for your sake. However many, many people, including many on Gransnet, have had extremely difficult parents, even toxic parents. It’s really difficult to admit this as an adult, and as a child you don’t recognise the reality. However your parent treats you as a child, you think that’s normal. As you grow up, you seek to escape. I took myself off 250 miles away from my mother, although she moved here after my father died. My mother did, and said the most appalling things and I eventually came to the conclusion that she is probably narcissistic, but of course it’s never been diagnosed. All of this realisation takes years, and it is only later in life that many people actually realise that everything they have been subjected to isn’t normal. The thing is that they’ve been brainwashed as a child to do what the parent says and are conditioned to obey. Eventually as the parent ages, the adult child becomes more and more resentful of the unreasonable demands that are being placed upon them. I think that it often takes until the parent reaches old age before the adult child realises how badly they’ve been treated.

Smileless2012 Fri 08-Oct-21 18:30:09

You both make valid points Allsorts and maddyone.

As an adult, if you're facing abuse from your AC and/or their partner, it's a difficult decision to call it out for fear of being estranged. If you don't then you are faced with the prospect of being an enabler.

When the abuser is a parent, a child is in no position to call out the behaviour. Other family members may be enablers if they're aware of what's happening but as those of us who have experienced abuse either as adults, or from childhood know only too well how this can be hidden.

There's a 'public' face to deceive others into believing that they are perfectly normal and decent people. There are also those whose relationship with the abusive person becomes so dependant, that they are unable or unwilling to see their true nature.

An adult can of sometimes is brainwashed by their partner so much so that they end up estranging their own parents and their entire family.

You appear to have found a way to manage your relationship with your mum topcat, which is a good thing.

Reducing the contact you have with your mum has enabled you to have some contact, even thought that is limited and has prevented the difficult and final decision to estrange.

Whether you're the one who takes the decision to estrange, or the one who is estranged, the end of a relationship that should have been or was once close, does need to be grieved for.

Smileless2012 Fri 08-Oct-21 18:32:45

sorry, that should have read An adult can of course sometimes be brainwashed

Allsorts Fri 08-Oct-21 19:33:01

I must admit I find it difficult to understand. Everyone must do what they think is right, as an outsider no one knows the whole story of any family dynamics. As estranged from my own daughter I am in no position to judge, I just know if a frank discussion as what it was that made her dislike me so much to estrange, I would have done anything to put it right, as it is too late now for reconciliation I just hope she’s happy, because I genuinely love her with all my heart.
However, I couldn’t read my paper today for crying about that evil couple that killed their beautiful son, anyone would have wanted him and love him, but not his parents, they don’t deserve to live.

agnurse Fri 08-Oct-21 21:41:07

Allsorts

What you have to keep in mind is that a sit-down such as you have described doesn't end well in most cases. It tends to sort of go this way: "I didn't do it. But if I did do it, it wasn't so bad. But if it was so bad, you/circumstances made me do it. It couldn't possibly have been MY fault. Or if circumstances/you didn't make me do it, I did it because I'd had worse done to me, and you can be thankful it wasn't worse."

Not something you can really reason with.

VioletSky Fri 08-Oct-21 21:50:11

agnurse can confirm, tried I person and in type. Completely Frank, unexaggeratedand and as kindly as I could.

It never happened

It was just a joke

I'm just too oversensitive

But what about my behaviour when I was 8

VioletSky Fri 08-Oct-21 21:54:35

Ooo errors

But as explained to my brother recently, coming at me from a place where my estranging is worse than the reasons that caused me to estrange is never going to change anything.