Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Letter to my mother

(212 Posts)
Helenwaspushed Mon 21-Aug-23 20:01:22

The following is a letter to my mother that will not be sent. I went NC with her two years ago, and will never reopen that communication again. Please know that I will not debate my personal situation with the estranged parents on this forum. Any attempts to invalidate my experiences will be ignored. I am offering this in hopes that the estranging child's POV will be more represented here.

"It is okay that we don't see eye-to-eye. I am at peace with that. I have learned so much about childhood trauma, the mother wound, and my own mental health. I wish I could share this growth with you so that you could heal from your own traumas.

I know you're hurting, but that hurting started long before you had children. You didn't have the access I now have (as an adult with my own insurance and income). I understand what happened and why. I understand that life was hard for you as it was for me. I'm sorry you never moved beyond that.

You tried your best, but our relationship was unsustainable for both of us. I was your everything, and I couldn't take it anymore. The decision to move on from our relationship was so difficult. I don't want this, but I know it's right. My idea of family has changed. I need to surround myself with people who validate my experiences and support my life direction. You hurt me irreparably when you discounted a decade of my hard work and dedication to defend a conspiracy theory. Your refusal to acknowledge the pain I went through or your faults as a mother make repairing our relationship impossible.

I spent my childhood taking care of you, although I know you don't see it that way. I feel like we spent our whole relationship trying to change each other. It was my job to keep you happy after the divorce. I spent my childhood as your emotional caretaker.

When I moved away I realized that I didnt have my own identity. It was so wrapped up in who you needed me to be.

I have my own life and I am my own person now. The political climate was shown me how different we are fundamentally. When I started to live my values, you tightened you grip on me. My whole being rejects the beliefs that you taught me, and you couldn't let me go. I had to choose between what is right for the world and what is right for my mother. If I hadn't met my husband and experienced unconditional love for the first time, you and I would still be in this cycle. I realize now that although we are mother and daughter, you have never been a mom to me and I don't owe you more of my life.

I hope you find peace in time. I hope you reach out and find a community to support you. I accept whatever blame you need to place on me in order to find your healing. I don't need or want that accountability from you. If my happiness is what you want, know that I've found it. The decision is made, and we will never speak again. I'm no longer a daughter."

keepingquiet Tue 22-Jul-25 09:21:06

Yes, and I need to get of GN this morning and get my breakfast!

Smileless2012 Tue 22-Jul-25 09:16:23

That comment was made almost 2 years ago hmm.

Glasweegran Mon 21-Jul-25 20:38:24

eddiecat78

I'm sure you do not mean to but you do appear to be trying to provoke a negative response purely in order to be able to say it doesn't bother you!

So if you just don't rise to that, then there isn't a problem.

Babs03 Thu 02-Jan-25 15:25:15

Yes I am also blessed with a good man, my best friend and rock in life. 46 years now, can’t imagine being without him but to those who have lost their soul mates will say that at least you were lucky to share your lives with the love of your life.
Not everyone is so lucky.
🙏🏾🙏🏾❤️

DiamondLily Thu 02-Jan-25 15:02:56

Fartooold

Thankyou ladies! Despite my “family” I was so lucky to have the best husband ever I miss him so much.
DL I know exactly where you are coming from although it is 2.5 years I still think he is with me, who do I rant about politics!
A good happy 2025 to all you lovely ladies thanks
Forgot to mention my father was fantastic teaching me morals.

And you. I miss him so much after nearly two years, But, he told me to get out and find my light, laughter and joy again, because that’s how I do best, and I’m getting there. 🙂👍

Very best wishes,🌺

Ziggy62 Thu 02-Jan-25 10:06:00

As mentioned earlier "not everyone should have children"

Sending hugs and strength to keep going xxx

Fartooold Thu 02-Jan-25 09:50:51

Thankyou ladies! Despite my “family” I was so lucky to have the best husband ever I miss him so much.
DL I know exactly where you are coming from although it is 2.5 years I still think he is with me, who do I rant about politics!
A good happy 2025 to all you lovely ladies thanks
Forgot to mention my father was fantastic teaching me morals.

Smileless2012 Thu 02-Jan-25 09:35:37

I can't even begin to imagine how hard it must be DL flowers.

I wouldn't change a single thing either. If I could turn the clock back and marry someone else therefore avoiding being estranged by an AC, I'd still marry him in a heart beat smile.

DiamondLily Thu 02-Jan-25 09:10:34

Smileless2012

I agree with everything that Babs has written Fartooold. Your mum and half sister will never know how lucky they would have been if they'd had you in their lives flowers.

Mr. S. and I have unconditional love for one another. Aren't we and everyone whose been blessed with a happy marriage, so lucky smile.

Yes, I wouldn’t change a single thing of our life together, Hard when it ends though.🙂

Smileless2012 Thu 02-Jan-25 09:07:13

I agree with everything that Babs has written Fartooold. Your mum and half sister will never know how lucky they would have been if they'd had you in their lives flowers.

Mr. S. and I have unconditional love for one another. Aren't we and everyone whose been blessed with a happy marriage, so lucky smile.

Babs03 Thu 02-Jan-25 08:28:06

Fartooold

Another one here who had unconditional love from the best husband in the world.
As for my mother she left me on Paddington Station when I was 6 (no jokes please) my father picked me up after only probably 5 minutes. When I was about 40 I wrote her a short letter telling her about my life, address obtained from her brother. Had a reply telling me not to contact her again I reminded her of the worst time of her life!!
Also contacted her daughter my half sister who has also blanked me…am I that awful!
Thanks for reading.

Am so sorry you were abandoned like that and then rejected in later life, and ‘no’ you are not that awful and had the love of your husband to prove this.
Please don’t think for a second that any of this is your fault. Think only of those who love or have loved you.
Wishing you all the very best 🙏🏾🌺

Fartooold Thu 02-Jan-25 07:40:04

Another one here who had unconditional love from the best husband in the world.
As for my mother she left me on Paddington Station when I was 6 (no jokes please) my father picked me up after only probably 5 minutes. When I was about 40 I wrote her a short letter telling her about my life, address obtained from her brother. Had a reply telling me not to contact her again I reminded her of the worst time of her life!!
Also contacted her daughter my half sister who has also blanked me…am I that awful!
Thanks for reading.

Allsorts Thu 02-Jan-25 05:27:21

I have had unconditional love, from my husband, my mother and father and my best friend, now dead. It must be very sad not to have had that. You do have to be the person to give it too though. To have an open heart.

DiamondLily Thu 02-Jan-25 04:20:41

Whiff

flappergirl User is right that was unkind. I had unconditional love from my husband until the day he died . We went through a lot together but he was always there for me and I him.

So did I Whiff - DH loved me, unconditionally, until the day he died. As I did him. 🙂

But, you and I both had wonderful marriages, and, obviously, not everyone does. 😉

Whiff Thu 02-Jan-25 04:02:52

flappergirl User is right that was unkind. I had unconditional love from my husband until the day he died . We went through a lot together but he was always there for me and I him.

User138562 Thu 02-Jan-25 03:00:28

Seems like an unkind thing to say, flappergirl. The OP is probably long gone but you still got a snide comment on so good for you.

flappergirl Wed 01-Jan-25 13:21:42

The OP says she has found "unconditional love" with her husband. Personally, I don't think there's any such thing. Unless possibly from a dog.

Smileless2012 Wed 01-Jan-25 11:34:14

Let's hope that 2025 brings all who are peace and happiness.

Ziggy62 Wed 01-Jan-25 11:28:48

I totally agree "not everyone should have children "
What a lovely, positive, supportive post
Thinking of everyone coping with estrangement on the first day of this new year xx

Andora Wed 01-Jan-25 11:18:29

Hi Helen. Thank you for being so transparent and brave to share. You have no idea how helpful your letter has been helpful and validated my own experience and some of the choices I have made. I wish for you continued peace and happiness. I totally understand why you had to let go. That step couldn't have been easy for you. Peace and Safety can not be understated. Emotional welfare and health is important. You did what you had to do. I do not understand some of the hostility directed at you by some in this stream over a letter that was not even sent where you were simply sharing your own experience as an abused child in an adult voice. Not everyone should have children. Your letter is an important pov and has nought to do with intolerance.

FenellaFootstrap Mon 18-Sept-23 16:21:50

I think that the Mum's response to the letter would be interesting.

Franbern Mon 18-Sept-23 16:04:07

Fleurpepper

I've read it with tears in my eyes.

And with huge gratitude, that this a letter I would never have had to send to my mother, and that my daughters will hopefully never send to me.

So much pain and sadness, I can't possibly imagine. I won't comment further.

Totally agree with your comments Fleurpepper. It ade e cry reading it, and made me cry thinking of the Mum

Smileless2012 Sat 16-Sept-23 17:16:13

Thank you Urmstongran for your understanding. You've summed it up very well and yes we were crushed but we're OK now, well as OK as we'll ever be.

Urmstongran Sat 16-Sept-23 16:58:08

I’m beginning to understand what happened to you and your husband Smileless (such a poignant user name). Your ES and you were very close. Happy. Until he met his wife who was jealous of the relationship you had with your son. She even admitted that to you? Wow. Slowly it seems she pulled him away. If that’s a fair assessment of what went wrong then you and your husband weren’t at fault.

My god that must’ve crushed you. Who’d have imagined one could love one’s own children too much? Beyond sad. I think the more people that love and care for one another in a family the nicer it is. Seems my views are naive at best.

eddiecat78 Sat 16-Sept-23 16:53:48

VioletSky the OP was the only person who put their opinions and "need for attention" before the feelings of others