Estrangement is often referred too as a living bereavement IntoTheEther because we grieve for and mourn the loss of the adult child whose estranged us.
You say that you used your daughter for emotional support due to the problems you were having with your son which you now see was wrong, and for which you have spent the last 19 months apologising for.
You mentioned neglect, which I understand to mean neglecting her needs when relying on her for emotional support and creating a 'glass child'; a child that is not seen/seen through, and yet you also talk of you and her father dividing your time so she wouldn't miss out on the things she wanted to do because of her brothers, while also ensuring that you had 1 to 1 time with her.
I am in no way attempting to underplay how she would have felt about and struggled with being an emotional support for you, just pointing out that there were also aspects of your parenting that were an attempt to mitigate some of the negative impact on her childhood, because of her siblings.
You didn't get everything right, no parent ever does and having listened too and taken on board what she's told you, have apologised which is all any of us can do.
My husband and I never instigated attempts to communicate with our son when he estranged us. Having received a hand written note on Christmas Eve that we were no longer a part of his and our GS's lives, I did pen a brief response.
Several months later through his brother, he requested a meeting with his father but that didn't go well due to the level of anger and bitterness he exhibited, for which there was no explanation.
Just over 3 years later when we were moving out of the area I emailed him to say 'goodbye' and assuring him that my love would always remain. His response was so vile that I simply emailed my thanks because he'd shown me that saying goodbye was the right thing to do.
It can be as you say a 'catch 22'; you can be damned if you do keep trying to make contact, and damned if you don't. She may see you failing to make contact as a sign that you don't love her but on the other hand, she may see your non acceptance of her wish for no contact by continuing to do so, as not loving her either.
You D during your row told you that she never felt she was loved by you and her father. A couple of years into our estrangement while visiting our eldest son in Aus., he told me that his brother didn't know if we loved him. I told him that if the first 27 years of his brother's life weren't evident of our love, then nothing we could do or say now could make it any plainer.
If you were to ask for my advice,it would be to send one final message to your D. Tell her you love and miss her which is why you've been continually whatsapping, but you realise you shouldn't have been because for her sake and your own, you need to accept her decision. So that is what you're going to do and why you'll no longer try contacting her again in the future.
It wont be easy but IMO this should also include birthday cards and cards at Christmas. We have seen estranging adult children here on GN, saying how they dread getting a card from the parent(s) they've estranged when it's their birthday or at Christmas.
No contact means no contact and the only one who is in a position to change this, is the one who initiates it.
7 months is still early days although for you it will feel like a lifetime so she may change her mind, and you may have more chance of her doing so if you leave her alone to see if spending the rest of her life without her mum in it, is something she really wants
.
What has survived in your garden with minimal or no watering?
Odd - weird and wonderful - almost unbelievable - or is it just me?
Spider deterrent……. Not….🕷️🕷️🕷️🕷️🕷️🕷️
Today the High Court has agreed that children can be given puberty blockers.


.
.