Gransnet forums

Food

High Rise Scones?

(65 Posts)
Carillion Thu 20-Jun-19 21:16:33

I've read the thread on Fruit Scones but think I need to ask this anyway...my scones turn out like what they describe in America as 'breakfast biscuits'. I'd love to make scones that are Tall when baked...can anyone help me?

WOODMOUSE49 Fri 21-Jun-19 10:13:43

Plain flour and lots of baking powder. Been making these for 20 years and been asked for the recipe so many times because they rise so much. Cheese scones great too. I use a 6cm cutter. Great for Cornish Cream and homemade strawberry jam. I feel baking session coming on. Good luck.

Funnygran Fri 21-Jun-19 10:21:16

I’m interested to see both plain and SR flour mentioned. My DM’s recipe used plain flour, bicarb and cream of tartar and worked for years. Recently my scones have been flat although taste ok. So next time I will try the SR flour and egg version and see if they are any better. Everyone else’s scones always look so much better than mine.

Charlieb Fri 21-Jun-19 10:31:18

I use Buttermilk in the mix to make scones, they always come out great.

Fernbergien Fri 21-Jun-19 10:35:27

Mary Berry uses the same recipe as me. But I don’t weigh anything.

Gizzy48 Fri 21-Jun-19 10:56:26

I'd just like to add that I read the heading at first as "high risk scones" and I wondered...

Carillion Fri 21-Jun-19 11:15:14

Thanks molly I'll get onto that. I'd love to have a copy again.

Carillion Fri 21-Jun-19 11:17:14

Thank you Woodmouse is that a recipe from one of the Hamlyn Cookbooks?

frankie74 Fri 21-Jun-19 11:19:15

I always keep at least one pack of Greens Scone Mix, in case of sudden need! grin

GrannyMosh Fri 21-Jun-19 11:39:02

All good tips here. Another is to make sure that when you glaze the tops of the scones, none of the glaze runs down the sides. It makes a difference!

Hattiehelga Fri 21-Jun-19 11:54:51

My scones used to be like rock cakes until I stumbled on the National Trust scone recipe since when I haven't looked back and am always complimented. Google the recipe and your problem solved.

Farawaynanny Fri 21-Jun-19 12:04:26

I use Mary Berry’s recipe. Never lets me down. I think the secret is also to not handle the dough too much.

Hm999 Fri 21-Jun-19 12:16:08

Have recently reduced carbs so ordinary flour is out. My scones are suffering if I use coconut flour, and little better with almond flour. I'm going to try the yogurt, and the milk and yogurt warming. Anyone had success with other flours for scone-making?

Marydoll Fri 21-Jun-19 12:20:48

I have three Bero books and each time I buy a new one, some of the previous recipes have been removed and new ones added.

dragonfly46 Fri 21-Jun-19 12:26:36

Gosh Carillion I still have my original Bero book

Bluesindy1 Fri 21-Jun-19 13:18:57

I use the Lemonade recipe, works everytime, lovely light, rich scones, I've also used cherries and mixed fruit no problem x

lindiann Fri 21-Jun-19 13:25:12

Oh thanks just spent a lovely time (Should have been doing housework!) with a nice cuppa looking at Be=Ro website recipes and ordering book smile

Patticake123 Fri 21-Jun-19 13:28:32

Some good a here but I don’t think anyone has mentioned the glaze. If any milk drips down the sides, the scones don’t rise. Happy baking.

aquafish Fri 21-Jun-19 13:57:08

All of the above with a tweek-
Warm the milk slightly then add a good squeeze of fresh lemon juice to it.
Seems to result in a good rise every time!
Must go and make a batch now you’ve all put the idea in my head! Enjoy

Carillion Fri 21-Jun-19 14:02:33

dragonfly have been on the BE-RO website and worked out to try and find the edition of the book my Mother had that I remember as a youngster... think I'd need to find the 32nd edition!!?

EmilyHarburn Fri 21-Jun-19 14:11:15

We do scones for the National Garden Scheme teas. As Grey duster says they need eggs.

Scones 25 to a mix.

1kg SR flour
250 g Butter
4 tsp baking powder
4 eggs
250 g sugar
Milk to bind.

200 fan oven; 220 other oven for 10 – 12 mins. Cut with 2.5 inches or 6.4 cm diameter ring

Carillion Fri 21-Jun-19 14:29:04

Thank you Emily got the gateau flour an hour ago and have some baking powder which I brought back last time I was in the UK so I'm going to re-read the thread now and use the fab tips that are there then...I'm good to go! (Also! Bought some Le Lait Ribot, Lait Fermente which I think is a substitute for full milk/ buttermilk)

annodomini Fri 21-Jun-19 14:49:23

Instead of buttermilk (or sour milk), I have sometimes used yoghurt which worked very well.

NotSpaghetti Fri 21-Jun-19 16:12:12

I don't cut mine. I pat the sour milk scone mix into big rounds and score into 6s. They are triangular like shortbread fans.

kwest Fri 21-Jun-19 18:28:30

Diana Henry wrote about the best scone recipe ever which is an American recipe. It was in Waitrose newspaper two weeks ago and I guess you could just look it up.

phoenix Fri 21-Jun-19 18:59:22

Just to add, I always just use "ordinary" milk, and as others have mentioned, never roll, just pat into shape.