Gransnet forums

Food

Uncooked Mince Pies!

(27 Posts)
HowNowBrownCow Mon 04-Nov-24 22:31:03

I love Morrisons freshly baked mince pies from the in store bakery however more often than not the pastry just isn’t cooked on the bottom. I have complained for several years when they’re not cooked properly and they always say my feedback is valuable to them and promise to feed back to the bakery to improve in future. Today I purchased 6, obviously to check the quality in readiness for the festive season and Lo and behold the bottoms are that horrible doughy not cooked state again. Not a good start so I’m abandoning Morrisons and looking for recommendations for a good bakery fresh mince pie as due to Disability I am unable to make my own. Huge thanks Gransnetters.

Theexwife Mon 04-Nov-24 23:32:21

I thought this would just be a local problem as the Morrisons in our town often has raw baked goods, I assumed they were cooked on the premises but maybe they are not.

Coolgran65 Tue 05-Nov-24 00:43:31

I always check our butcher's cooked steak pie. They are excellent but like your mince pies they are often not quite done to my liking on the bottom. I finish them off by popping them into a high oven upside down. 15 minutes and they are perfect.

Redhead56 Tue 05-Nov-24 01:11:20

Check out fruit crumbles they are slimy concoctions because the crumble is not cooked properly underneath. I have bought from different stores in the past when I had sudden visitors arrive. I make my own I don’t trust any of them no matter what store or brand they lack quality.

Marmin Tue 05-Nov-24 10:51:49

Morrisons are to remove signage in stores following a complaint to trading standards. Other supermarkets are affected. It may be that the mince pies are made elsewhere (possibly even overseas) and delivered to the stores frozen. All the shop does is reheat.

Witzend Tue 05-Nov-24 11:53:47

I make my own, but an ex colleague loves M&S mince pies!

Jane43 Tue 05-Nov-24 11:56:34

Sainsburys mince pies are good, no soggy bottoms and you can get a pack of four for £1.

HowNowBrownCow Tue 05-Nov-24 21:08:07

Thanks all for your tips and info, I’ll certainly try Sainsbury’s and if affordable the M&S ones 😊

Babs03 Tue 05-Nov-24 21:46:40

Lidl and Aldi do excellent mince pies. No soggy bottoms, and am talking about the pastry here 🤣

Georgesgran Wed 06-Nov-24 01:04:57

I’ve just watched an advert on tv for Morrison’s mince pies and it states they are freshly baked in-store, although probably made elsewhere and delivered frozen or chilled?

I can’t comment as I can’t ’do’ anything with dried fruit.

Grantanow Wed 06-Nov-24 13:18:24

Waitrose mince pies are good.

SingingRabbits Wed 06-Nov-24 13:19:31

Don’t know which region you’re in but Wenzels are specialist bakers who do excellent mince pies.

ordinarygirl Wed 06-Nov-24 13:52:13

I like the Co-ops.

missdeke Wed 06-Nov-24 14:01:58

I know in a survey last year The Co-op topped all others including artisan bakeries. If I get any I think I'll get mine from them.

Secondwind Wed 06-Nov-24 14:27:54

Iceland deluxe mince pies hit the spot for me!

Fae1 Wed 06-Nov-24 14:41:44

Mince pies are not mandatory for Christmas. Plenty of other goodies around! Personally I don't like them in any case.

4allweknow Wed 06-Nov-24 17:10:44

I'd give Aldi ago. Year on year, they seem to be either first or second choice for quality after testing by a popular testing magazine. Last year M & S was top but the price was v. high.

grandtanteJE65 Wed 06-Nov-24 17:35:52

Jane43

Sainsburys mince pies are good, no soggy bottoms and you can get a pack of four for £1.

That made me laugh. I doubt any of us thought we were discussing nappies!

Kathmaggie Wed 06-Nov-24 18:20:41

Too rich for me but late DH loved Aldi and Iceland mince pies. Both were rated highly in GH magazine

Lilyflower Wed 06-Nov-24 19:48:25

I have been holding out for Tesco to reduce the price of their £3 for six Finest mince pies. Hooray! They are half price so I bought two packs of six.

I have one and a half warmed for 20 seconds in the microwave with a dash of single cream.

Heaven!

Witzend Wed 06-Nov-24 19:56:27

Fae1

Mince pies are not mandatory for Christmas. Plenty of other goodies around! Personally I don't like them in any case.

I beg to differ! They’re certainly mandatory in this house - but homemade, first batch will be on 1st December, or the first day of Advent, whichever comes first.

flappergirl Wed 06-Nov-24 20:15:36

I wish deep filled mince pies had never been invented. They crept in about 30 odd years ago and now they are ubiquitous. I love mince meat but there's just too much of it to the ratio of pastry. My local bakery still does the most wonderful all butter pastry mince pies which are traditional "shallow" ones.

Aldom Wed 06-Nov-24 20:54:39

Jane43

Sainsburys mince pies are good, no soggy bottoms and you can get a pack of four for £1.

I prefer the Sainsbury's mince pies to the Marks and Spencer ones. Sainsbury's are much closer to home made, especially if gently warmed.

Peaches7 Thu 07-Nov-24 08:19:59

If you have a gregs near you,their mince pies are lovely

J52 Thu 07-Nov-24 08:59:21

ordinarygirl

I like the Co-ops.

So do we. I recently bought some very expensive ones from Betty’s Tea Room. They were under cooked and inedible, even after some extra time in the oven. If I’d lived nearer I’d have taken them back.