Gransnet forums

Food

Trouble opening tin of salmon.

(48 Posts)
shysal Mon 17-Mar-25 13:13:07

Not for the first time I have struggled to open a small tin of red salmon. I have tried in vain to find a ring pull can in this size. I first tried the ratchet opener which is the easiest for other cans. It usually takes off the rim and lid, but it wouldn't budge despite prising with a knife. Next I tried the 2 convential ones which would not turn. In the end I resorted to the pointy tool with which we used to pierce evaporated milk lids. Any advice for future attempts? The larger size comes with a ring pull but I only wanted one sandwich!

Caleo Tue 18-Mar-25 16:19:16

A chain saw and protective clothing.

Caleo Tue 18-Mar-25 16:24:00

Trouble with electric openers one size does not fit all. I was using mine one day on a Fray Bentos pie in a tin. The fit was so bad that two carpet fitters in my house at the time rushed to see what was causing a noise in the kitchen like a car crash .

wibblywobblywobblebottom Tue 18-Mar-25 16:50:04

You buy tinned salmon???

crazyH Tue 18-Mar-25 17:00:35

With corn beef , you got to open both ends and then push from the narrow end.

Barleyfields Tue 18-Mar-25 17:32:03

wibblywobblywobblebottom

You buy tinned salmon???

And why not???

Cateq Tue 18-Mar-25 17:42:05

I had a fancy can opener which was the most difficult one to use. It was an expensive gift from a friend who liked to splash her cash and felt it must be superior to a standard version. I tried to open a tin of salmon but it got the better of and I threw the thing in the bin and rummaged through my cupboards to find the one I paid £3 from a supermarket, it worked a treat.

Sallyforth Tue 18-Mar-25 18:25:56

I'm safer eating tinned salmon. I have a bad reaction to farmed salmon.

Mojack26 Tue 18-Mar-25 18:46:24

Get an electric can opener it opens every size of tin ring pull or not

DrWatson Tue 18-Mar-25 20:40:11

Some odd comments on here! "No working freezer" -- well, simple solution. "Fish stinks the fridge"? If you don't use all the contents, put them into a plastic storage box - - they come with a tight lid -- and label when you did that. Or use cling film over the original tin, you won't be leaving it weeks, will you? But some interesting points re tin openers.

Grandam47 Tue 18-Mar-25 21:14:17

I have a problem opening dog food ring pull cans. So, I put the handle of the metal spoon through the ring and lever the can open. Works every time.

Allira Tue 18-Mar-25 22:08:48

Barleyfields

wibblywobblywobblebottom

You buy tinned salmon???

And why not???

I buy tinned tomatoes 😯
And sardines. They're so difficult to catch.

Trisha99 Wed 19-Mar-25 07:56:32

Grandam47

I have a problem opening dog food ring pull cans. So, I put the handle of the metal spoon through the ring and lever the can open. Works every time.

Same, as you say works every time. I do it with all ringpull cans as my twisted fingers won’t fit in the ‘ring’.

travelsafar Wed 19-Mar-25 08:52:32

I bought an electric can opener for this very reason.....wouldn't be without.

jocork Wed 19-Mar-25 09:50:37

My old basic can opener that I got as a student still does most things fine, however Fray Bentos Steak and Kidney pies are tricky! I haven't found small tins of salmon a problem with that opener. It must be 50 years old!

Caleo Wed 19-Mar-25 10:04:03

I too place a lever through the ring and push on the lever. My lever of choice is a wooden spoon and I keep one beside the tins. I often need to prepare the ring by raising it slightly with a knife handle as I don't have strong finger nails.

BlueSapphire Wed 19-Mar-25 14:33:12

I also recommend an electric can opener, easy-peasy!

welbeck Fri 09-May-25 08:59:03

Lidl have them for 8 pounds.
4 AA batteries included.
Arrived yesterday so may sell out.

To raise ring pulls I keep old milk lids. Force under the ring pull and twist. Much easier than trying to prise it.

annodomini Fri 09-May-25 10:09:10

To lever the top off a ring-pull can, I also use the spoon through the ring method but, having bent a few metal spoons, I now use my smallest wooden spoon which neither bends nor breaks.

Cabbie21 Fri 09-May-25 10:21:32

Yesterday, in memory of my mum whose birthday it would have been and as a salute to the war and post-war days of my childhood, I decided to open an ancient tin of corned beef. It had the traditional side key. After a struggle at the start not knowing quite which way to turn it, it actually worked! The contents came out easily and tasted good. No additional implements required.

Blossoming Fri 09-May-25 10:42:38

DrWatson

Some odd comments on here! "No working freezer" -- well, simple solution. "Fish stinks the fridge"? If you don't use all the contents, put them into a plastic storage box - - they come with a tight lid -- and label when you did that. Or use cling film over the original tin, you won't be leaving it weeks, will you? But some interesting points re tin openers.

So, if you need to freeze half a tin of salmon, just buy a freezer. Simples! grin

Solution 2 only works if you still have the matching lids for your plastic containers and they still fit tightly.

Solution 3 your fridge will still smell of salmon long after the salmon has departed.

Esmay Fri 09-May-25 16:10:36

I have trouble opening lots of things and it's not a new problem .
I save up things that have to be opened for my neighbour..
I can't open Listerine .
She opened it with ease .
And then closed it.
I can't reopen it and have ended up cutting the top off the bottle and decanting it .
I can't get mayonnaise out of those squeezy bottles .

tanith Fri 09-May-25 16:32:39

I love a tinned red salmon sandwich, it was a treat when I was a child. Red salmon with a sprinkle of vinegar crusty bread and lettuce. I always buy the larger tin no trouble opening it with my basic tin opener then put the rest in a glass container with lid for the next day. 😋
Sorry you’ve found it such a faff but lots of good advice.