Gransnet forums

Grandparenting

My ex DIL is arranging boyfriends to pick up GC from day care

(118 Posts)
Annali Sat 26-Sept-20 06:21:20

Hello everyone
I’m at my wits end with worry for my son and 2 yr GC. Long story short - the relationship has broken down, they are seperated and DIL has new boyfriend (a couple actually in past 6 months). She has told my son that in future, her current BF will be picking up GC from daycare. My son knows nothing about this new man in GC life. My son has been seen lawyer and a letter will soon be sent to DIL re: law about joint guardianship and need to include my son in decisions re: welfare of GC. DIL is persisting - through series of texts - that she will do what she sees right for ‘her child’. My son is an emotional and anxious mess. How do I help him?

BlueBelle Sat 26-Sept-20 13:30:09

People are very trusting, is all I can say

The reason so many adults need counselling for childhood abuse

MissAdventure Sat 26-Sept-20 13:26:17

Exactly.

BlueBelle Sat 26-Sept-20 13:24:16

galaxy up to a point I agree I don’t do the ‘there there you poor darling it ll all be fine‘ but there are ways of delivering instructions with a little kindness and thought, I find Bibbitys posts informative, probably accurate but as hard as nailsdelivered with a Miss Trunchbull bullet
‘The sun will make you take your coat off quicker than a harsh wind’ that’s my thought for the day ?

Jo1960 Sat 26-Sept-20 13:23:42

Annali, in my working life I came across a lot of MILs who (understandably) believed everything their sons told them. A couple of these women facilitated unsupervised contact between their GS and GC when it shouldn't have happened, resulting in them no longer able to see their GC. I'm not for one minute suggesting that you are in that category but please be aware that there may be things you don't know.

If you and your DS genuinely feel your DIL is endangering your GS and is so horrendous, you should refer to Social Services. Before doing that however, I'd ask yourself why your DS felt confident with her parenting skills during their marriage and left his adored son in her care when the relationship ended. This may sound harsh but is coming from my professional and some personal experience. I hope that emotions calm down and that you and your son can have a lovely relationship with your GC. thanks

Galaxy Sat 26-Sept-20 13:21:58

Not trusting at all, just pointing out what can legally be done in this situation.

MissAdventure Sat 26-Sept-20 13:19:15

People are very trusting, is all I can say.

Lolo81 Sat 26-Sept-20 13:16:22

Also want to pipe up to say that the advice from Bibbity has been sound, factual advice.
The child’s mother has every right to make decisions about who meets/cares for/interacts with the child on her time - as does the father on his. Is this morally what people expect? Probably not, but unless there is tangible evidence of the child being exposed to someone dangerous then each parent is expected to trust the other to properly care for the child when they have them.

fluttERBY123 Sat 26-Sept-20 13:00:11

Stay neutral, if possible maintaining good relationships with all. You could be a good go-between and a good example to gc and maintain at least a semblance of a together family in the eyes of the child. Part of it needs to be trusting the dil, difficult though that might be.

Galaxy Sat 26-Sept-20 13:00:01

Bibbity has been completely sensible in her advice, telling people what they want to hear is not actually being kind.

autumnsun Sat 26-Sept-20 12:53:54

Bibby
Well it is called GRANSNET for a reason the clues in the name!! 'Echo chamber' ' Narrative " oh good god

Whatdayisit Sat 26-Sept-20 12:27:45

Nannan2

Hasn't this been discussed previously on here? Someone's always at their 'wits end' with something on this site. Usually over something that can just be solved with some common sense.?Unless you know something about this 'other man',which could endanger the child, then you must leave it up to both child's parents I'm afraid.Neither will thank you for interfering.

That's not coming across as being very kind. People are often at their wits end that's one of the good things about supportive chat groups like this - supposedly. It's not compulsory to read or reply.

Bibbity Sat 26-Sept-20 12:24:18

How are they not helpful? Is it because they don’t feed into the narrative of the echo chamber?
I have clearly stated what his rights are and are not.
Sending a solicitors letter that holds zero weight can be seen as inflammatory and will not help the relationship at all.

Is being a grandparent necessary to participate in this conversation? No. Therefore it has no bearing on my answers.
The Op wants to know how to help him. To do that it would be helpful to know what actual resources and laws he has.

autumnsun Sat 26-Sept-20 12:03:15

Bibby

I take it your NOT a grandmother because your response is very defensive & not really helpful

wondergran Sat 26-Sept-20 11:54:28

Does your dil see your son as the reason they separated? If she has this in her head...ie he had an affair for example she will do her utmost to 'punish' and exclude your son now. I hate it when one partner, usually the mother, starts referring to the child as HER child....they will always be their child! Can your son apply for joint custody so he will have 50/50 share of access to the child? It's a nightmare scenario and one which may well rage on for many years. Say as little as possible so as to be seen as impartial and I hope to goodness that things resolve themselves without too much more upset.

BlueBelle Sat 26-Sept-20 11:53:28

readymeals there is no step father she has a new boyfriend of 6 months quite different to a step father

annali you have my total empathy it would have killed me I was lucky in a way that mine buggered went off to another country after not bothering to turn up for the custody hearing so although they didn’t have a father figure (my dad took on a lot of that role) they didn’t have the to-ing and fro- ing and worry of new introductions
I can only repeat what others have said support your son and keep up your care and interest in your grandchild and say a big prayer that he is a decent chap and be prepared it may be a different one in 6 months time with a half brother or sister around
Being factual is good bibbity a little compassion makes a good balance There are ways to say things
I think it’s a very good idea to have a check done on any boyfriends that are going to be in the child’s world and the same would apply if the daughter in law was concerned about any new partner you son may have and if she feels there are any concerns
If they can avoid confrontation and nastiness that is by far the best way forward and yes mediation can be very helpful
Good luck

quizqueen Sat 26-Sept-20 11:49:33

A parent or parents can nominate anyone they deem suitable to collect their child from nursery/school as long as the setting is informed beforehand. It could be a friend or neighbour or another parent may take them home with them. You son may not know them either. Your son also may have a girlfriend whom he asks to do things with his child at some time in the future. Would he expect the mother of his child to object to her?

Separations and divorces usually do get very messy, sadly. You say your DIL is trouble but this is the woman your son chose to marry and have a child with so he has to also take some responsibility for his past bad judgement of her character, if what you say is true. Both you and him need to keep on as good terms as possible with her and anyone else in her life so the child does not become aware of any aggravation, I'm afraid. That's how it is now.

paddyanne Sat 26-Sept-20 11:48:19

If your son isn't able to pick the child up and the mother is working ...what would you suggest happens? Surely a boyfriend the child knows is a decent option?
If your son only sees the child twice a week do you think the mother must be available the other 5 days ?
My son and his partner split when their child was just over a year old ....he worked ,she worked .They made a rota of people who could collect the wee one .As I'm self employed I featured on it A LOT ...because I can juggle most things to suit .However there were days I couldn't make it the 15 miles there in time and other granny stepped in ..or ex;s boyfriend.He was the reason for the split
.The CHILD has to come first and unless your son can make himself available to be more hands on then he has to accept the mother will need other support .
Our wee one stayed half the week with each parent and while Dad worked I looked after her .She has only recently lived that half week with her father and his new partner but still thinks of this as home and has a room here ....as well as one at other granny's ,one at mums and one at dads .Its all very complicated some times
.Worth it though if you can figure it out for your GC,ours is a joy and a happier child would be hard to find .Dont make the child a bargaining tool ,just love him an do your best .That means you never criticise his mum in his hearing ,Hope it works out for you

Starblaze Sat 26-Sept-20 11:46:52

I too would feel uncomfortable but mum does have the right to a new relationship and that new relationship will be involved in the child's life. The timescales for this I might have done differently but I don't know how long she has known her new partner.

I would repeat what others say and stay neutral, encourage your son to keep things friendly with the mother of his child. A good coparenting relationship is what is best for the child and the court route causes a lot of stress and upset for everyone involved, including any children. It really should be a last resort if he is not getting fair scheduled contact.

MissAdventure Sat 26-Sept-20 11:39:43

I would welcome checks on new people in a child's life; I certainly wouldn't be happy with them having sole charge.

Nannan2 Sat 26-Sept-20 11:39:20

Hasn't this been discussed previously on here? Someone's always at their 'wits end' with something on this site. Usually over something that can just be solved with some common sense.?Unless you know something about this 'other man',which could endanger the child, then you must leave it up to both child's parents I'm afraid.Neither will thank you for interfering.

Jo1960 Sat 26-Sept-20 11:37:34

@Annali, with respect, you have only one side of the story. DIL is entitled to have boyfriends and 2 in 6 months isn't excessive; your headline suggests that she has several random bfs who take turns in picking him up which isn't the case. Your post doesn't mention how much contact you or your DS have with your GC and appears to be mainly a criticism of your DIL. Under the Children Act 1989, the child's welfare is paramount, not your DS's (or DIL's). Your DS must have had faith in your DIL's parenting ability and decision making or he would surely not have left your GC in her care?

Unless your DS & DIL had agreed that he would pick up GC from daycare, which would mean DIL is effectively changing that arrangement or DS has evidence the BF is a danger to the child, then he really doesn't have much of a case. It reads more like DS is feeling like he's losing control of the situation and is angry with his ex. You don't know her position or views.

You don't mention what contact you have with your GC, however, as others have said trying to appear neutral & maintaining a positive relationship with your DIL, is the best way of keeping contact with your GC and of being a positive figure in your GC's life. It's also better for your GC that the adults in his life try to put away their own hurts and work together to parent him. Good luck shamrock

spabbygirl Sat 26-Sept-20 11:35:23

I think you have to work with it as much as possible because the parent with the child does hold the power and will win any power battle. I think you have to be on his side but don't encourage him to be angry and confrontational but to show him how to work with his ex, not against. you get some solicitors who will work by encouraging a kind, inclusive style and others who like firing off letters threatening all sorts of stuff a court/social services can't enforce. I was a child protection social worker and you see lots of battles between ex's & it becomes expensive and helps an unhelpful atmosphere if both play out their possibly justifiable anger

twinnytwin Sat 26-Sept-20 11:29:36

I was in a similar situation many many years ago and was extremely upset when my ex husband straight away mixed my children with his new partner. I can reasssure you that my children have grown up to be fine wonderful people, with close relationships with all their extended family. I can only ask what you would think if your DS started a relationship with a new lady that you've met and really liked. Would you be doing all the checks on her, would you not allow her to be alone with your DGS if they lived together? This time will pass. Support your DS but don't alienate your DiL either.

Bibbity Sat 26-Sept-20 11:29:17

It’s a waste of money because the same concerns could’ve been written by him in an email and still carried the same weight.

rafichagran Sat 26-Sept-20 11:25:18

Sorry if this has been said before, but are you in the UK, only some of the wording sounds like you are in the US, where things maybe different.
Bibbity I dont think it is a waste of time or money to get a letter sent to the ex. His concerns are now put in writing if anything goes wrong.