Gransnet forums

Gransnet cafe

Welcome to the *Gransnet Café. This is a non-judgemental space for you to pop in for a cuppa with some virtual friends, seek out advice for a particular problem, or share an update on your life - important or trivial. Feel free to have your say and chat about your day, but please leave any arguments at the door. If you're struggling to find someone to talk to in real life, or are simply looking for a bit of a chat, this is the place for you.

Don’t Kill Cash Petition

(121 Posts)
Primrose53 Tue 04-Jul-23 12:34:21

This petition started yesterday evening and is up to nearly 50,000 already.

www.gbnews.com/cash

I hope some people on here will sign it because the idea of not having cash is dreadful. I like cash as I can keep track of it and I can spend it how I choose without Big Brother watching where I go, what I buy, etc.

I am not such a dinosaur that I don’t use my cards but I do like to give tips, give to street collections, pay tradespeople etc. I have also been in shops where the card machines pack up and you have no choice BUT to use cash.

bikergran Wed 14-Feb-24 13:36:49

Yes I can Understand that not all families are honest and that some may well be influenced and that stringent checks are in place, but my dad being old school just wanted to have the cash in his hand to say " there you are that's for you " it wasn't a vast amount. My dad was happy enough that he could give his great grandson money towards his driving lessons. (the driving instructor does not do card so has to be cash).

Theexwife Wed 14-Feb-24 12:42:33

I think it is a good thing that there are stringent checks on cash withdrawal, they didn’t know if you were influencing him to withdraw cash and with no paper trail it could have all been for you. There is no real reason why the monies could not be paid into the families bank accounts as far as the bank were concerned.

bikergran Wed 14-Feb-24 11:58:12

Just off topic slightly, but have you tried to take cash out! My dad wanted to take some out to distribute amongst family.

He is of old school, yes we and are aware that the bank has to ask certain questions fill in a scam form etc.

But they made my dad feel anxious and upset about drawing some of his! cash out.

The person at Halifax was almost insistent we gave her everyone's bank details and she would transfer the money that way. After putting my foot down and saying in a firm tone" it is my dad's money, my dad has worked/saved for it and he wants the cash in his hand so he can hand it to whoever" Had she gone on much longer I would have asked to speak to another person (she was the manager by the way)

On going back another day we dealt with a different lady who was lovely and because of the issue with the Manager we closed my dads account.

Jaxjacky Wed 14-Feb-24 11:38:46

Spuddy

It won't let me sign anything! I can't click onto the name/address etc. so I copied and pasted the link to Google and it still won't let my type anything!

Possibly expired, OP was July last year.

Spuddy Wed 14-Feb-24 11:34:55

It won't let me sign anything! I can't click onto the name/address etc. so I copied and pasted the link to Google and it still won't let my type anything!

JackyB Tue 07-Nov-23 18:17:35

Come to Germany. Many people are still sceptical about plastic money.

Fairycakes Tue 07-Nov-23 12:26:22

I don't know whether I am too late to sign the petition, but I have don so anyway. I too, am concerned about a cashless society. I like the freedom of giving to the homeless etc. and I don't like my spending being watched and monitored. It could all too easily lead to dictatorship.

Primrose53 Mon 06-Nov-23 22:44:55

I’m sure I posted on here earlier but I can’t find it.

Just today I used cash to buy a postage stamp, to give my niece’s kids a few quid each, to pay for a book in a charity shop, to buy a few potatoes, to buy a coffee.

I do use my card for large purchases and the weekly shop but there are all the little bits I like to use cash for.

PamelaJ1 Mon 06-Nov-23 19:23:21

Callistemon21

^When there is an event in our church it is cash only.^

Will the collection plate be changed to a card machine?

It is in use in some church’s but there is still a choice in most, if not in all.
We don’t have the option to donate in our church by any other method than cash but we do have a pile of flyers that have our details on so that anyone can pay by BACS if they want to. Any donation, however it is made, is very welcome.
As for the regular worshippers- they don’t seem to have a problem finding a bit of cash.

Grandmama Mon 06-Nov-23 16:21:49

I haven't read all the posts so sorry if I'm duplicating a point already made.

I use my credit card most of the time but I don't do internet banking. Yesterday evening I was with DD2 when we dropped off GD1 at the railway station. The car park (not the main car park, a small one round the back) was cashless. No problem for DD2 but if I were still driving (not had a car for some years) I suppose I'd be forced into internet banking.

biglouis Mon 06-Nov-23 16:14:20

A few years back two men in masks kicked in my door and demanded cash. I actually laughed at them and told them I rarely use cash or have it in the house because I buy everything online. I also pointed out that mine was the only house in the street without a car, that I did not wear jewellery or use a smart phone. Perhaps they should have gone to specsavers before they chose a house to rob. They left empty handed and probably feeling pretty foolish.

Harris27 Mon 06-Nov-23 16:03:39

I always carry cash just habit.

Spuddy Mon 06-Nov-23 15:55:05

Signed!

Spuddy Sat 12-Aug-23 12:04:22

Signed!

Oldnproud Wed 05-Jul-23 19:17:05

Primrose53

Oldnproud

Here in the countryside, people sell a few excess eggs or fruit / veg outside their homes for next to nothing when they have a glut. I am sure that they are making no profit as such. No one would bother doing this with the hassle of card or phone payment. What a shame it would be to lose an old tradition like this if cash disappeared.

@Oldnproud

have you seen this advert for a guy who stops at a roadside stall to buy some potatoes?

youtu.be/YT8RXgFDbA4

Yes, it always makes me smile 😁

Tweedle24 Wed 05-Jul-23 18:42:32

Callistemon Our church already has most regulars making their collection donations by direct debit.

However, as you say, church events, plant sales etc. are strictly cash. Cash machines are not cheap to rent anyway, so it would be impractical for small organisations to use them.

I am the secretary of a local club aimed at the retired. We ask for the subs to be paid by BACS where possible, but some members do not have a cheque book or access to the internet.

Lovetopaint037 Wed 05-Jul-23 18:08:20

Perhaps we should refuse to purchase unless we are allowed to use cash. I can understand a situation like a Nespresso outlet situated in the middle aisle of a busy shopping mall refusing to take cash due to their vulnerability. However, the same refusal was made in Peter Jones (John Lewis) where another Nespresso concession is available. We went to the V&Aand lined up for something to eat and again at the Dulwich Gallery etc.; all refusing cash. I use cash in the local Co-Op, pharmacy etc. I must admit on these occasions I do feel like a dinosaur.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 05-Jul-23 18:06:36

They do here too. And flowers and honey. They make very little but it all helps and buyers appreciate fresh produce. It depends on the good old honesty box for which you need cash. I really don’t see cash disappearing in our lifetimes, but I feel that businesses should remain free to require payment by card if they wish.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 05-Jul-23 18:06:32

In our SME we take cash, credit card or debit card, a sale is a sale…

Primrose53 Wed 05-Jul-23 17:59:34

Oldnproud

Here in the countryside, people sell a few excess eggs or fruit / veg outside their homes for next to nothing when they have a glut. I am sure that they are making no profit as such. No one would bother doing this with the hassle of card or phone payment. What a shame it would be to lose an old tradition like this if cash disappeared.

@Oldnproud

have you seen this advert for a guy who stops at a roadside stall to buy some potatoes?

youtu.be/YT8RXgFDbA4

Oldnproud Wed 05-Jul-23 17:46:44

Here in the countryside, people sell a few excess eggs or fruit / veg outside their homes for next to nothing when they have a glut. I am sure that they are making no profit as such. No one would bother doing this with the hassle of card or phone payment. What a shame it would be to lose an old tradition like this if cash disappeared.

Norah Wed 05-Jul-23 14:50:40

biglouis I agree with GSM that the petition is poorly worded but I would not like to see cash disappear and doubt if it will in my lifetime. As for small businesses most post offices allow you to pay in cash for a main bank account so I dont see a problem there. I would prefer to see a petition which makes it compulsary to accept cash as a payment method.

It must be very difficult to manage without cash if you are homeless or have very little money. Cash can still be widely used in the supermarket, on public transport, and for paying other people who do jobs for you.

I'd dislike cash to disappear for a myriad of reasons.

Plus how would we give little gifts to GC, they love cash? smile

Daddima Wed 05-Jul-23 14:47:26

Callistemon21

^When there is an event in our church it is cash only.^

Will the collection plate be changed to a card machine?

Already happening in Paris!

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 05-Jul-23 14:38:16

You have an annual allowance of £6k of capital gains before tax kicks in and you can carry unused amounts of allowance forward to the next year so for most of us any increase in value of an asset between acquisition and disposal won’t be taxable.
You’re absolutely right that a regular pattern of buying and selling can be trading which is a totally different thing and professional advice is needed if you’re doing that.

PamelaJ1 Wed 05-Jul-23 13:48:29

Well most things that I sell certainly haven’t made any gains. It’s usually when a local charity holds a table top sale and they go for next to nothing.
Whilst what GSD says about capital gains may have some merit I can just see the Inland Revenue being totally delighted to hear from me reporting that I’ve just made a couple of hundred £ on a table I bought 4years ago from an auction. They are another service that can’t cope with their workload.
If I was selling a painting for a few hundred thousand more than I paid for it then it would be a matter for my accountant.
If I was selling lots of things on a regular basis I think it could be perceived that I was running a small business. A totally different thing.