Gransnet forums

Health

Sharing medical appointments with others.

(85 Posts)
M0nica Sat 06-Oct-18 20:23:21

In the north east they are experimenting with seeing some patients with problems like diabetes, high blood pressure, rheumatoid arthritis in groups of up to 15 in sessions that last up to 2 hours. Everyone signs a confidentiality agreement and it is believed it helps people get more information about their condition and has the reassurance that others have the problems they have. They seem to be quite popular.

As I said currently the sessions are up to 2 hours long. Perhaps I am over cynical but I am willing to bet that once the system is established, they will start to chip away at the length of the sessions and eventually they will reduce the sessions to little more than half an hour and all they have time for is a few tests and a quick 'OK everybody?' Cannot take questions today we are running out of time. Why not go over the road to Tesco and discuss your problems over a cup of coffee.'

CocoPops Wed 10-Oct-18 03:20:17

Group education sessions for chronic conditions are one thing but a definite No to group consultation sessions for reasons of privacy and confidentiality.

annep Wed 10-Oct-18 05:11:45

Probably a better idea Cocopops.

notanan2 Wed 10-Oct-18 12:52:34

.

As I said currently the sessions are up to 2 hours long. Perhaps I am over cynical but I am willing to bet that once the system is established, they will start to chip away at the length of the sessions

These groups have been running successfully for years elsewhere and have not been chipped away.
Not sure why the North east is late to the game, or why it is suddenly news, but they are already well established in lots of regions and have proven successful.

Marydoll Wed 10-Oct-18 13:51:21

Notanan, I think part of the negativity about this is a result of some people not really understanding what is involved in these groups.
No-one has come on here so far and reported that they were a participant who either found it all a total waste of time or their confidential medical history was made public.
In my experience of them, individual diagnoses are not made at these groups, they are for people who have already been diagnosed with long term conditions and need support to manage them.
They are so successful in my Health Board that there is a long waiting list to attend. I remember one lady bursting into tears when she realised that the symptoms she was experiencing were part of her condition and most people in the group were also experiencing them. She thought she was the only person who felt like this.

annep Wed 10-Oct-18 13:56:28

That's good to hear Marydoll

notanan2 Wed 10-Oct-18 13:57:43

Well exactly Mary doll

Despite posters who have ATTENDED stating otherwise, some posters can't get past the headline's implications that we'll all be group squatting into pee pots every time we get a UTI!

The press is not on your side on this.
Either it was a slow week
Or lazy journalism
Or something more sinister/political

FernandoAAA Mon 31-May-21 15:06:09

ааDoctors only want to profit from our problems.

MollyMallone Mon 31-May-21 15:10:23

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BlueBelle Mon 31-May-21 17:16:03

There have always been group work and it can be very useful
I ran smoking cessation groups 20 years ago I have a friend who attended a diabetic group just before lock down and found it very helpful I have another friend with bi poler who also attended a group and found it helpful to realise so many people shared her ups and downs
Look at AA successfully run groups for ever
I do think you are being cynical monica
There is nothing like realising you are not the only one, to dilute a problem and yes Anniebach mental health groups can work and some people need to talk it out with others who have experienced similar
They are not for everyone but can be extremely useful and as I say have been run for years in NHS and in charities for various illnesses