Gransnet forums

Health

Getting a misdiagnosis officially changed

(39 Posts)
M0nica Thu 08-Aug-24 22:51:40

Has anyone ever succeded in getting a medical misdiagnosis officially overturned?

Last year I was twice diagnosed as having had a TIA, despite not having a single credible symptom. I got caught between my practice, one of several providing subjects for a vascular research project, who were under pressure because not enough potential stroke victims were being referred and a very young enthusiastic research fellow, who seemed to think her job was to prove every candidate sent in had had a stroke, regardless of the evidence. I had all kinds of scans and tests and none provided any evudence I had had a stroke.

Within weeks doctors in other departments I was being seen by, read the description of my symptoms and also expressed doubts about it being a stroke.

Then I had what, in retrospect, was a panic attack but DH rang 111, and after describing my symptoms and my strokes they sent an ambulance and I was rushed to A&E. The doctor who finally saw me was clearly a senior consultant, a man in his 50s, with that ineffable air of authority that seems to surround such people. He told me quite clearly that he had spent some time studying my medical record in depth and his conclusion was that neither of my reported events were strokes.

Since then I have been seen by several other doctors dealing with the real cause of the original problem. It is a physical problem and they have carried out tests that show the cause quite conclusively. I also had another milder recurrence of the problems that started this whole stroke business, as a result I was able to identify something I had done that set it off and as a result the doctors have identified another problem I have that had not been previously indentified.

The reason I want this misdiagnosis reversed and contradicted is because being identified wrongly with a stroke is causing me lots of unnecessary problems. To begin with I am now taking a lot of medications everyday, that I really should not be taking if I haven’t had a stroke. One of the medications I am taking inhibits the effectiveness of a drug I am taking for another proven condition

As well as that, the cost of my annual travel insurance has trebled from around £300 to nearly £1,000, it also affects my car insurance.

So, please, has anyone ever challenged and got a misdiagnosis officially cancelled. What did you do and how did you do it? I am at a loss about where to start.

Norah Fri 09-Aug-24 22:36:28

M0nica The problem is Norah thaat being misdiagnosed with a stroke has many ramifications into my wider life and is currently costing me about £1,000 a year.

I understand what you posted.

As I said, my solution to my condition, which has a 10 yr life expectancy if left untreated, was to seek different (private) consult/treatment. Apparently the misdiagnosis (in my records) was removed by the operation that corrected the problem. There remain no affects to the prior misdiagnosis, my travel insurance and car insurance have reverted to my prior normal cost.

Callistemon213 Fri 09-Aug-24 22:48:34

Iam64

As for the accuracy of medical records, like Callistemon, I had someone else’s records mixed with mine. The letter to my consultant cardiologist listed my existing physical medical conditions accurately. It referred to my severe depression, my psychotic episode over the millenium when I believed the world would end and to my schizophrenia. Luckily I opened and read the referral letter before the appointment. The secretary who typed it didnt apologise, she mumbled an excuse that she’d had two screens open and transposed them. I did get the practice manager to remove the letter from my records

It seems we have to be on the ball. I’d try the practice manager and Pals, MOnica
Is it worth considering a private appointment with a consultant prepared to correctly diagnose?

I apparently had had a sterilisation (amongst other things).
I pointed out to the GP that I'd managed to give birth twice since then, a miracle!

Not long ago I had this person's medication put in with mine at the chemist's so now know what meds she is on.

Iam64 Sat 10-Aug-24 08:21:15

It really highlights the difficulty MOnica faces when we notice how much incorrect information is on our records - that we don’t know about

NotSpaghetti Sat 10-Aug-24 09:03:33

I had Polycystic Kidneys appear in my notes because they had "mixed me up" with someone else in the rheumatology department (I was told by the department).
The "formal" response was that a tick box had been activated.

They did apologise and added ]This is completely unacceptable, and as you rightly point out, contravenes Information Governance regulations.

It's so annoying though.

petra Sat 10-Aug-24 09:12:33

The same thing happened to a friend of mine this year.
He’s a type 1 diabetic. For whatever reason he did something stupid with his medication.
Rushed to hospital where he was told he had had a stroke.
He knew he hadn’t as he had had a stroke before.
Whilst in hospital he really stood his ground to get this diagnosis changed: no joy.
He was not far off from having his holiday of a lifetime in the Canadian Rockies.
His insurance went sky high 😡

albertina Sun 11-Aug-24 11:41:26

So sorry to hear about your misdiagnosis.

In my case the stroke consultant agreed over the phone 3 months later, and no driving for 4 weeks and horrible blood thinners etc, that I hadn't had a TIA.

I am hoping that her word is enough.

I also hope you can get your situation sorted out, preferably in writing. As Iam64 says here " we have to be on the ball"

sandelf Sun 11-Aug-24 12:02:03

Contact The Patient's Association www.patients-association.org.uk/ They have a helpline for just this sort of problem.

Sasta Sun 11-Aug-24 12:30:03

Very frustrating M0nica. I hope you managed get it deleted. In complete contrast to your diagnosis, I actually had a stroke in my 40s. I was repeatedly told by the consultant at the hospital it was a ‘menopausal headache’ and to stop worrying about myself. A second milder stroke 15 months later was put down to ‘having eaten something spicy’ which I hadn’t anyway. I could write a book about the awful medical treatment I’ve had over the years. I wish you well and hope it all gets sorted.

winterwhite Sun 11-Aug-24 12:31:16

Maybe it's quite difficult to actually prove that a person didn't have a stroke, and the balance of probabilities and subsequent opinions might not be enough to erase it from the record. They should be enough, though, to ensure that it doesn't affect any future diagnoses or medication.

Re the £1,000 travel insurance - could you change companies and not declare it?

RosesAreRed21 Sun 11-Aug-24 13:57:13

Totally agree with you. I was diagnosed with having Asthma by the doctor and put on 2 inhalers (that didn’t work) after being on them for several months I finally got an appt to see the asthma nurse who order tests and turns out I haven’t got it - recently I found this was still on my notes as a doctor mentioned it - had I gone on holiday and had to have hospital treatment my insurance company wouldn’t have paid up as it would be on my records and I hadn’t “declared” it at the least I would have had a fight on my hands

Doctors I feel are too quick to diagnose and put you on medications without doing further investigations

stewaris Sun 11-Aug-24 14:04:29

#M0nica I was diagnosed about 20 years ago with paroxysmal AF. For some reason I was also diagnosed with high blood pressure and put on all the relevant medication. I have never had high blood pressure in my life, including when I was pregnant, but my GP wouldn't take me off the blood pressure tablets because the hospital had put me on them. I wrote to my cardiologist and explained the problem. I was sent an appointment, he took my blood pressure and told me I was right. Immediately stopped the tablets and amended/made a note on my records. I would suggest writing to your consultant. I found mine very helpful. I hope it works for you.

icanhandthemback Sun 11-Aug-24 19:10:28

The thing is, having the wrong diagnosis can affect travel insurance and other things. My mother was admitted to hospital with a supposed UTI, the wrong next of kin and the wrong address details given which has caused havoc. All the information was given by the care home whose lack of care in recording information caused the admission to hospital in the first place. My mother aspirated something because eating causes her to sneeze, the care home recorded as choking on something so the advice given by 111 was for the wrong treatment. She should have been given antibiotics as a foreign body had entered her lung so when she wasn't she got pneumonia. The care home assumed it was a UTI as this was something she'd had on many occasions before. When she got to the hospital, they treated her for a UTI she never had so it was only when I got there I informed them of the aspiration event. It took a while to convince them I was her next of kin with an LPA so more time was wasted. Eventually they treated the pneumonia. However, whenever they discussed her case, the first thing they referred to was Mum had come in with a UTI. They also kept having to be reminded that they needed to speak to me as Mum had Dementia and her partner was not Next of Kin and never been NOK!
Discharge to a new care home was a potential mine field because she needed to be watched whilst she ate just in case she aspirated again through sneezing. Sorry, not in her care plan, she's had a UTI. No, she doesn't need CHC as she only had a UTI. No complaint acted on by the CHQC because the care home couldn't be held responsible for a UTI and they were given the right advice for a choking incident! Honestly, it was painful.
Finally on discharge where the letter said she'd been in hospital for a UTI, all her appointments went to the wrong address. I tried to get them to change the record but to no avail!

M0nica Sun 11-Aug-24 22:51:01

sandelf

Contact The Patient's Association www.patients-association.org.uk/ They have a helpline for just this sort of problem.

Thank you for this I will follow it up.

I have got the forms for getting copies of my hospital records, which should include the letter and A&E note from the doctors who have queried my diagnosis.