Gransnet forums

House and home

Woodwork - Satin or gloss?

(30 Posts)
PinkCosmos Wed 28-Apr-21 16:41:00

I have found a few old threads about satin or gloss (from 2014) but was wondering if there was any more up to date info.

I need to paint the woodwork my hallway and stairs. This involves 9 doors plus door frames and skirtings, so it's a big job.

It is currently gloss white. It was done about ten years ago and is looking really yellow in some parts as it was oil based paint

At the moment I can't decide between satin or gloss. I have always used gloss in the past.

The gloss is too glossy and the satin looks a bit like undercoat to me as it is too matt. I sound like Goldilocks!

In the older threads the comments were that the water based satin was hard to clean and not hard wearing.

On the other hand, is gloss a bit old fashioned?

Is there a water based gloss that won't yellow but will be hard wearing and a bit less glossy, because it isn't oil based!

I usually use Dulux trade paint - though I am only a diy-er.

Any advice or specific recommendations for good paint would be welcome.

Patsy70 Wed 28-Apr-21 16:47:47

We use satinwood and always very happy with it.

NotSpaghetti Wed 28-Apr-21 16:56:49

If you are painting over gloss why not look at an oil based eggshell? We have this in our hallway and it's been pretty durable without the stark shine of a gloss.

NotSpaghetti Wed 28-Apr-21 17:00:23

Re eggshell... We have water-based eggshell in the kitchen and it's not as durable by the way.

Also, I'm not sure you can over-paint an oil based paint with a water based one if you want it to stick. You may need to remove the gloss first, rough it up significantly, or maybe use a coat of something specialised in between?
You maybe should check this out.

BBbevan Wed 28-Apr-21 17:09:44

Satin, we don’t like shiny

M0nica Wed 28-Apr-21 17:10:43

I have painted waterbase satin finish over white oil -based gloss without any problem at all. If it gets marked or stained and it will not wipe off, i just lick another coat of paint over the mark.

Mind you I am bone idle, I always look for the quickest easiest way of doing anything and only when that fails do I do start reading and starting to follow the rules.

tanith Wed 28-Apr-21 17:23:09

Satin finish all day long.

Polarbear2 Wed 28-Apr-21 17:29:38

Satin here?

Katyj Wed 28-Apr-21 17:36:01

Satin ?

Sara1954 Wed 28-Apr-21 17:56:47

Used satinwood for years, still like it, but have recently gone back to gloss, I love it in really dark colours, all shiny and sleek.

Calendargirl Wed 28-Apr-21 17:58:55

Satin.

Lovetopaint037 Wed 28-Apr-21 19:03:03

Egg shell if you don’t want a glossy finish. However, you need to rub down with fine sand paper if you intend to use a water based (acrylic) paint. However, We had to paint over oil painted fitted wardrobes but found a primer that was a bit more expensive than normal primer but was able to cover any surface. It was great, so easy and provided a really good surface. Dh has just found it. It is called ZINSSER Cover Stain. It says on the tin “works on all surfaces without sanding”.

Kim19 Wed 28-Apr-21 19:16:46

I love gloss and only ever use Dulux Once. Find it reflects light everywhere and that pleases me. Confess it does go cream in time but then I just add another coat as and where it is annoying me.

Redhead56 Wed 28-Apr-21 21:03:56

I do small paint jobs but we got a firm to do main hall landing etc. They recommended satin as gloss is not fashionable now. The results were lovely I won't use gloss again.

Nannagarra Wed 28-Apr-21 21:26:39

Satinwood for me. Mine has stayed white, has a slight sheen and cleans well with a damp cloth.

BlackSheep46 Sun 02-May-21 10:34:45

Satin finish every time. Gloss is soooo dated yuk !

Caragran Sun 02-May-21 10:45:29

Satin wood. Dulux Timeless. Never goes off colour.

Willow500 Sun 02-May-21 13:46:53

We had a decorator in a few weeks ago to do all the paintwork and ceilings in the house we were moving into - he recommended satinwood which he's used throughout over the gloss - it looks very nice.

Bridie22 Sun 02-May-21 13:59:48

satin.

Lin52 Sun 02-May-21 16:15:19

Personally use eggshell matt, very hard wearing and doesn’t go yellow like gloss. Find satinwood chips easily

Gwan1 Sun 02-May-21 17:34:49

Lin52 Can I ask the make of eggshell mat you used?

Diane7 Sun 02-May-21 17:55:51

I know someone who alternates, she does like decorating and does it regularly, so that she can see where she has re-painted ?

kathsue Sun 02-May-21 18:35:10

I use water based satin. No problem keeping it clean. Washing out the brushes is SO much easier.

TrendyNannie6 Sun 02-May-21 22:06:20

Satin finish for us, can’t stand gloss

dogsmother Sun 02-May-21 22:48:29

Another vote for Satin.