Gransnet forums

House and home

Alternative to my Dyson

(64 Posts)
Allsorts Thu 21-Aug-25 07:42:27

My Dyson is five years old, I have had to buy a new battery, two new heads and numerous filters and they are all expensive, I hate cleaning the thing, I thought you would just empty, but no, it has to be washed, dust gets into the crevices, two filters have to be washed and replaced, I think of my old Hoover upright with longing, I gave good old Henry, nothing cleans like he does but he's so heavy.
Any ideas please for something light, that doesnt rely on a battery and cleans carpets.

Astitchintime Thu 21-Aug-25 07:50:29

I have a Shark Liftaway but again, the filters need washing occasionally and only last week I washed out the ‘tank’ after emptying it as the dust does cling to the insides.
The old fashioned vacuum cleaners where we would just empty or replace the bag must have been minging inside though.
Actually, that reminds me of an occasion many years ago when my neighbours vacuum cleaners where packed up and I let her borrow mine………big mistake as she has a sheltie dog with very long fluffy hair that it constantly shed. The neighbour didn’t even bother to empty my vacuum cleaner and even after I had done so the smell of dog infiltrated me home for weeks! Lesson learned…….I no longer let anyone borrow my vacuum cleaner!

kittylester Thu 21-Aug-25 07:57:45

I have a Shark lift away and find it really heavy and cumbersome. DD2 has a Shark rechargeable and loves it.

Aldom Thu 21-Aug-25 08:04:44

I have a Gtech. It's rechargeable, but very light and manouverable.
I've had mine for eight years.
It's not much trouble to maintain.
Love it and would buy another when this one needs replacing.

Trisha99 Thu 21-Aug-25 08:13:37

I replaced my ancient Dyson stick vacuum with a Shark one, anti hair wrap etc etc but found I was always unblocking it, washing the filter and the dust tank.
I decided I was fed up with this and the clouds of dust on emptying so have now got a Henry Quick.
It’s their version of a cordless stick hoover, the difference is it uses a paper canister to line the dust tank and this is ejected when full.
It’s brilliant, so clean. It picks up well, only downside is every now and then clearing threads/hair twisted round the brushes.
Other consideration is the cost every so often of the paper canister, but I haven’t had to change it yet and it’s been a month. I should say I vacuum every other day, three bedroom bungalow with a dog.
I do have a Shark handheld to deal with the odd small mess of crumbs etc.
I know you wanted recommendations for something without a battery Allsorts but I thought I’d put a word in for the Henry.

Flippinheck Thu 21-Aug-25 08:33:30

Cordless Shark.
While my Henry is the most efficient and reliable cleaner, he is now too heavy for me so is semi-retired. The Shark is remarkably effective, light, manoeuvrable, flexible and with good battery life. It really makes cleaning a much lighter job. Comes with tools to let you clean your stairs and car. The best cordless I have ever had, far better than the Dyson.

J52 Thu 21-Aug-25 08:44:13

Watching this thread as our cordless Dyson is playing up. DH has taken it apart and something seems to be wrong with the switch mechanism. Fortunately, like others we have a dear old Henry, not as convenient but cleans amazingly.

mum2three Thu 21-Aug-25 09:00:03

I'm finding this thread of interest. I have small rooms with a lot of furniture and vaccuuming is awkward. I have a Henry which is very powerful and does a good job of cleaning. The bags last a long time too. Trouble is, it is rather cumbersome and the attachments only slide on so keep coming off. I want something light and easy to manoevre. I have an old-fashioned carpet sweeper, which is ideal...very easy to use and empty, and it's surprising how much it picks up.

keepingquiet Thu 21-Aug-25 09:16:10

I also swear by my Henry, but have a separate old Shark upstairs because Henry's are heavy to lug around.

I have never had a Dyson- so many more alternatives around and much cheaper.

Trisha99 Thu 21-Aug-25 10:53:04

*Just after posting this I put a fresh dust canister in this morning.

Bukkie Thu 21-Aug-25 14:17:07

Nothing comes close to a Henry. Mine is old and heavy but still the best vacuum by a country mile. I talk to mine as we go around the houseconfused

Chardy Thu 21-Aug-25 15:04:13

I have a Shark too. Not very heavy, but not light. I wash the easily accessible sponge filter out occasionally, and take the detritus off the bottom sometimes. The wand easily comes off the body for stairs and carpet edges.
Yes, I'll buy another

butterandjam Fri 22-Aug-25 13:13:07

I've got a SEBO automatic, I've had it 17 + years and still perfect. Not cheap, but brilliantly worth it.

LadyGracie Fri 22-Aug-25 14:17:56

I bought a Shark when my Dyson packed up, I wish I’d bought another Dyson.

Allira Fri 22-Aug-25 14:30:50

When I rang up to order a new battery for my Dyson and was told the cost shock, I said I wouldn't bother and would buy a different make instead. Threy sent me a free battery .

It is rather awkward to empty but I don't wash it. I use a slim screwdriver to poke the fluff and dust out.

Gfplux Sat 23-Aug-25 13:38:50

Just remember Dyson supported Brexit. I can never buy a Dyson because of that betrayal.

Silvertwigs Sat 23-Aug-25 13:43:03

Allsorts, try a Numatic PRH 180 lite, it’s brilliant

Sashasmum Sat 23-Aug-25 13:44:06

I recently replaced my Henry with a Gtech as it was getting too heavy. I chose this one as I have weak hands and couldn't cope with the 'stick' cleaners with the weight is at the top. The Gtech is great. Cleans well. Yes you do occasionally have to clean the filters but not very often.

Berd Sat 23-Aug-25 13:47:22

Love love love my GTech! If you buy the bundle you can get a hand-held with it.

VerbenaGirl Sat 23-Aug-25 13:53:59

We replaced our Dyson with a Shark Liftaway and haven't looked back.

Sarah65 Sat 23-Aug-25 14:00:07

I've recently bought a Shark Classic corded vacuum cleaner which I'm very happy with so far. It is quite heavy but comes apart to hoover the stairs, high shelves etc and is very easy to empty. I decided against a cordless one as they obviously need to be charged up & I assume a new battery pack would be expensive.

Foxyferret Sat 23-Aug-25 14:11:31

I have a Miele cat and dog. Excellent but heavy, picks up hair very well.

Annma Sat 23-Aug-25 14:15:34

I have aSebo Titan cylinder with a really long cord.It is old but robust and works really well.Ihave a Shark Rocket for everyday crumb cleaning around grandchildren.It does a good job and is lightweight.Ihad Dysons in the past but think they are way overpricedd.

Vintagegirl Sat 23-Aug-25 14:19:25

I got a Gtech following rave reviews on here. Sadly the battery failed and was not covered by warranty as old stock. Cost of new battery put me off but I did love it for ease of use. I have gone back to old favourite Miele with bag. This is for upstairs and still have old faithful Nilfisk for downstairs but heavy, corded and bagged.

Lallylou Sat 23-Aug-25 14:29:49

Just want to say, years ago I had small Dyson on wheels which clipped on to change it you had to unclip with a button. I dropped it on my foot and broke three toes. Sorry Dyson you are overpriced rubbish lallylou