Gransnet forums

Legal, pensions and money

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 12-Feb-15 17:32:53

My battle with a frozen pension

To be closer to her son, 79 year old Rita Young decided to relocate from Peterborough to Australia. But she soon discovered that upon leaving the UK her state pension had been frozen, and would remain so throughout her time there. Unable to finance the move and with no one left to call upon, she explains the harsh injustice of this government policy.

Rita Young

My battle with a frozen pension

Posted on: Thu 12-Feb-15 17:32:53

(153 comments )

Lead photo

Rita Young

When my son Colin moved to Australia in 1981 to start a family of his own, I missed him dearly. The thought of not seeing him and my future grandchildren (my granddaughter married in December) grow up deeply troubled me – a feeling I’m sure many of you can relate to.

So, after retiring in 2002 my late husband and I made plans to relocate to Australia to be closer to our family. But when we looked into what this would mean financially, we were completely shocked to find that if we moved our state pensions would be frozen at the rate as when we left – and for the rest of our time there. We knew that year on year we would become progressively worse off and wouldn’t be able to afford to live without being a burden to our son and daughter-in-law – something we weren’t prepared to do, so we decided to stay in the UK.

I now find myself alone, with no family around me after my husband died in 2004, having to make do with a weekly Skype call to Australia. Whilst I’m still perfectly capable and independent now, I worry about the future and what will happen to me when my health deteriorates and I’m left with nobody close by to call upon.

Like all of us affected, I believed while I was working and paying national insurance contributions until the age of 67 that I was safeguarding my future financial security wherever I chose to live.


In some ways I consider myself lucky that I found out about frozen pensions when I did. Given the fact that the policy isn’t widely publicised, thousands of British pensioners move overseas only to find their pensions frozen. As a result, some 560,000 British pensioners living in more than 120 countries worldwide (ironically largely Commonwealth countries such as Australia, Canada, South Africa and New Zealand) are affected, whilst those living in places such as Europe and the US receive annual increases to their state payments as if they lived in the UK. The policy really is illogical as it sounds; a result of half-finished bilateral agreements with overseas governments.

But it’s the complete injustice of the whole situation that still gets to me. Had my son moved to a different country, I would be able to live near him but because he chose Australia, I can’t. Like all of us affected, I believed while I was working and paying national insurance contributions until the age of 67 that I was safeguarding my future financial security wherever I chose to live. Now I sacrifice a social life so that I can save money for trips to Australia once every few years.

Through this archaic frozen pension policy, the government continues to force people like me to make a choice between being close to family and making ends meet. If you are considering moving to be closer to your loved ones that have moved away or perhaps just want to retire abroad, you need to be aware of what this might mean for your pension and for your future well-being.

All we ask the government is to be treated as equals.

The International Consortium of British Pensioners (ICBP) are campaigning for the half a million British pensioners affected by this cruel government policy. For more information including a full list of affected countries visit the website.

By Rita Young

Twitter: @pensionjustice

anniegold195 Sun 17-May-15 14:02:31

One of the main reasons hubby and I left South Africa was because of the frozen pension system. That was 15 yrs ago and at that time his weekly UK pension was £30.00. We had no choice but to return in 1996, after 33 years working in 3 different African countries, as we knew that by 2015 we would be unable to live a normal life. And no - we werent eligible for a SA pension. We looked into every avenue in this respect. However, we also knew that a S.A. born citizen, who was married to a Brit, received a portion of his UK pension on his death. How fair is that!

Possiejim Thu 23-Feb-17 11:22:16

I know of Rita Young who for several years has railed against the appalling UK Government's pension behaviour. www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/money/article4104695.ece .

It is so un-British to index the pensions in some countries but not in others. Where is the fairness in that? Fairness is supposedly in UK Governments' DNA! From a UK Government committee report in 1997;- “Britain was alone among the OECD countries in discriminating between pensioners in different overseas countries, rejecting any suggestion of compromise”. From the same report it continues, “Surely no-one would have deliberately designed a policy of paying pensions to people living abroad intending to end up in the position we are at today… A simple change in British law could enable up-ratings to be paid in any or all overseas countries, provided the political will was there to do so".

Moreover did you know that if the UK government was to make a courageous move and increase all the NI contributions per contributor to fund the GBPs600 million to up-rate all the frozen pensions, the average weekly cost per NI contributor, of whom there are over 30 million, would be less than 40pence per week or about 7pence per day? Who'd miss that from their pay packet? Not many I'd guess. It is less than the cost per week of one cheap fag.

But this shows how miserly and thoughtless the UK government is; so pathetic that they cannot see this disgraceful episode of their miserly pension policy will be affecting their relationship, at a critical time now, with most of the Commonwealth governments. Us disgusted expats are now encouraging the Commonwealth governments to turn on the UK government and will soon be calling for the UK to be suspended from the Commonwealth. www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/pensions/10251775/Suspend-Britain-from-Commonwealth-over-unfair-expat-pensions.html

This action we are encouraging is because the UK government is in breach of the Commonwealth Charter. This Royal Charter only signed by The Queen in 2013 states;- "We are implacably opposed to all forms of discrimination", which of course is not true for it's not the way the British Government treats many of us expats, living overseas. It is an immoral example of blatant discrimination, this freezing of some expats' pensions. www.maturetimes.co.uk/join-fight-end-pension-discrimination/. Feel ashamed now to be British living in the UK.

Riverwalk Thu 23-Feb-17 11:47:43

I don't know why this damp squib of a 'Blog' has been resurrected.

Apart from the opening blurb, Rita never did make an appearance and respond to any of the comments!

Jayanna9040 Thu 23-Feb-17 13:37:53

Think it will be evened up durhamjen, once we leave the EU. Frozen pensions for everyone abroad then.