Gransnet forums

Legal, pensions and money

Gifting Money to adult child to buy home: good or bad idea?

(47 Posts)
GdadJam Sat 10-May-25 22:08:28

My wife and I live in the USA, are both 63, have 3 adult, independent children ranging from 31 to 35. Two are married, one is single and we have 3 grandchildren. All 3 adult kids are friends and the spouses get along great.
Our oldest child and husband, owns 2 homes, and rent one. Middle child just finished college and moved back home with us 2 weeks ago, to start his job search.
The youngest is our daughter, age 31. She and her husband are the topic of my post here. They have a 20 month old child and they lived 2 ½ hours away from us for over 5 years. She’s a full-time mom, so they are a one income family. They were approved to buy their first home last Fall near where they live.
But just as they were about to close on the home, the husband was laid off, so the mortgage approval fell through. After searching for a job for 6 months, he got a great job in the same town and me and my wife. The mortgage loan company told him that if he stays in that job a min of 6 mos, they will approve his loan again.
So, since the job is close to us, they moved in with us for the six months, paying no rent or expenses, so they can save for the downpayment for their next home purchase.
We love having them live with us and we get to see our grandson every day. But now, they are ready to find and buy a home.
They have been in our home for about 5 months and they recently started looking in this city for a home to buy but found the prices in our city higher and they can’t find a home that they can afford (not many 1 income families can afford to buy a home). They were very discouraged. They had rented for 5 years and decided they’d probably be stuck renting again. I very much want to help them make the step to become homeowners, especially since our daughter and husband are trying to make it in life as a one income family.
By the way, they are very frugal, industrious, hard-working and very careful with their money. That’s another reason that encourages us to help them.
So, like many of you, we felt so much empathy we want to help them financially. And we have the money to help, too.
So about a week ago, we offered $50,000 as a gift toward the purchase of a home (I have not told them but I am willing to give them more, up to $100K, if needed). The home price range they are looking at is about $400K. They are again looking for a home to buy. We have not given them any money, but are planning to make the gift directly to the home buyer at the time of purchase (or something like that, so the gift is applied to a home purchase).
We have the money now. Why wait until I’m dead (which I hope will be 30 years from now) to give it to them? Right? They need the help NOW.
The daughter (and family) in this story is the only child now who has any financial need.
I’m looking for advice:
My question and my concern is: if I give money to one child to buy a home I don’t want this gift to ever cause any rift between our children. I don’t think it will. But – as many of us have seen in life, money can and does ruin families. I’d hate for our generosity to ever cause bitterness and division.
Have any of you have been in a similar situation?
If we do give a gift of money to our daughter to help buy a house:
I don’t think we should keep it a secret in the family. That would never work. All siblings will eventually find out. So, maybe my wife and I should meet with all 3 kids, be very honest about what we are doing to help one child (and because they get along so well, they will be supportive). And, maybe I should tell them that I am willing to help them financially too, if that day comes and if they want help. My goal as a dad is to try to continue to treat them equally.

If you have been in this situation, what’s your advice? Am I smart? Or about to make a huge mistake?

Thank you in advance friends. smile

NotSpaghetti Mon 12-May-25 17:03:10

mabon1 - going back to my thoughts earlier maybe you should add interest between the gift and your demise to the share of the others (if you see what I mean).
£12,000 would have been "worth" much more even 5 years ago... in another 5 or 10 years it could be worth £24,000.

mabon1 Mon 12-May-25 16:09:45

You should give the other chidren the same amount. My friend gave her daughter £25,000.00. I asked her if she had given her son the same amount, she was astonished that saying that her son already had a nice home and that no daughter of theirs was going to live in a 2 up 2 down which was all she and her partner could afford at the time.. I gave one of my boys £12,000.00 when they were on their knees but have stated in my Will that he is to receive £12,000.00 less than the other two from my estate.

NotSpaghetti Mon 12-May-25 16:01:23

I have a problem with people declaring that they think it's AI (as if their opinion is fact) and scaring off responders to what can just as well be a genuine post.

I feel like this too, OldFrill - and feel it more acutely if it's a new person looking for help. Potentially all the rudeness around bot-calling could put the more timid amongst us right off.

Allira Mon 12-May-25 15:34:53

what’s your advice?

Treat them all equally.

Don't die within seven years.

Allira Mon 12-May-25 15:32:49

keepingquiet

How come Bots have so much money?

😂😂😂

OldFrill Mon 12-May-25 14:41:08

Elowen33

If these are AI generated posts it would probably be to generate traffic on here. Gransnet only has a few posters now and I would think will be at risk of closure if it becomes any less used.

Yes, and even if they are AI generated they often lead to good information exchange and discussion. I don't see the problem. I have a problem with people declaring that they think it's AI (as if their opinion is fact) and scaring off responders to what can just as well be a genuine post.

escaped Mon 12-May-25 13:55:56

Some of you are making me smile remembering our 20 year old daughter at the time dreaming in her head of how many Louis Vuitton handbags and pairs of Jimmy Choo shoes she would be able to buy!
A bit a lot of guidance from us was needed, infact we even put the property details under her nose. Her siblings were older and wiser, but we just wanted to sort them all out fairly in one go. Of course you never know, but we were fortunate.

Grandma70s Mon 12-May-25 12:07:14

I gave my sons equal amounts. My father, a victim of an unequal bequest himself, was very careful to leave me and my brother equal amounts in his will. However, as I had been widowed young with young children, and had a much smaller income than my brother, he used to give me cash regularly. I think I would do the same if one of my sons was in a difficult situation.

Norah Mon 12-May-25 11:56:43

Bobbysgirl19

CV2020

My advice— check out your tax position re gifting money to your children etc.
as it can be a minefield. I’m in the UK so don’t know American tax rules

I agree with the above. You have provided so much information and I really think you should be discussing this on a USA site, as different rules apply over there.

Agreed.

We've quite restrictive gift rules, perhaps ask an American solicitor?

Cossy Mon 12-May-25 11:49:51

I wish I could do more financially for our children, but I would always give all of them the same irrespective of their circumstances

Elowen33 Mon 12-May-25 11:40:16

If these are AI generated posts it would probably be to generate traffic on here. Gransnet only has a few posters now and I would think will be at risk of closure if it becomes any less used.

NotSpaghetti Mon 12-May-25 10:46:22

Allsorts you are right.
The £1,000 gifted 20 years ago is not at all the equivalent of £1,000 gifted today.

NotSpaghetti Mon 12-May-25 10:41:23

I have two things to say here.

One. A gift shouldn't depend on what it's spent on

Two. Gifting one adult child more because they have less in the first place is understandable but not fair or logical.

So re 1 - if you gift £50 or £50,000 to someone it's one thing to say "you might like to put it towards..." a deposit, a "work" suit, or whatever you think they need - but they know what is going on in their life. Do not assume a fancy car is less valuable than a property - or a lampshade is less important than a suit.

Re 2. .. Given that we chose a life that was never going to make us rich, by looking at this logically, in a family situation we would have had more and more spent on us/gifted to us. This is clearly wrong.
We all make choices and wealth is not always financial.

We have one adult child (of the 5) that will never have as much as her siblings - the path she and her husband have chosen means they are earning less now than 10 or 12 years ago.

Whilst I want to help her where we can, I am conscious that she has relationships with her siblings that I mustn't jeopardise. Their relationships are good - but who knows what the future may bring?

In our case (like the OP) we wanted to give her something "to help".
We had a relatively small sum to gift at a time when they had already committed to buying their first home. . We gave them enough (we guessed) to cover roughly the fees and moving costs - and gave the others the same in cash. We did not ask our less comfortable daughter not to spend it going to a destination wedding of a friend.

GdadJam please be even handed with your gifting. My daughter's siblings deserve to be treated evenly. Nothing can really make their lives "fair" in a world where a care worker or a groundsman or a cleaner earns less than the banker or "influencer".
Show them your children are equally valuable to you.
If one of them (say) travels the world and "bums around" on it. Why worry.

I accept I would struggle if they were a drug/alcohol/gambling addict though. I can be certain I'd do something different in that case! No idea what.
🙏

butterandjam Mon 12-May-25 10:06:44

It makes sense to help the one who really needs it, now when they do. I'd tell the wealthier children what you're doing, and say that this is an "advance inheritance" from the parents' estate .

The rest of your money stays in your control until needed, according to the twists life brings. Perhaps a child divorces, a grandchild has special needs, or the parents become so decrepit/ frail they need to buy in care and assistance.

When the last parent dies, the three children share the remaining estate, with "adjustment" for any advances they received.

In the past year we've re-made our Wills, re-arranged Powers of Attorney ( enables the offspring to manage our health and assets if we become incapable) .

OldFrill Sun 11-May-25 22:51:27

Skydancer

I don’t understand what bots are or why they post on Gransnet? I mean who is behind it?

Automated software programme. Noone would know who's behind it or the reason. Gransnet will have software to counter them but may not be 100%. Given how many Petra (who could be a Bot herself or operating some) thinks there are they would be hardly any posts on GN that aren't Bots. If you're worried about them, report them and let the higher beings deal with it.

Allsorts Sun 11-May-25 22:50:47

It's up to you, if you have the money give them both some, if you live 20 years the amount you give now will have risen significantly so in effect the other child would be getting less if you only want to help one. I have always treated mine the same but if you are open about it they can have their say.

OldFrill Sun 11-May-25 22:46:51

petra

I see the Bot hasn’t replied. 😂

Every OP who doesn't reply is a Bot?

Skydancer Sun 11-May-25 22:38:51

I don’t understand what bots are or why they post on Gransnet? I mean who is behind it?

Macadia Sun 11-May-25 19:16:32

I dont think its a Bot - just a feeling.

Welcome and thanks for posting, GdadJam.

I agree to give while alive - must be a new trend as I am doing the same.

Update your will so that you give 33% to each and 33% - 50k for the youngest until all sums have been equally distributed.

keepingquiet Sun 11-May-25 19:00:18

How come Bots have so much money?

petra Sun 11-May-25 18:52:32

I see the Bot hasn’t replied. 😂

Bobbysgirl19 Sun 11-May-25 18:51:48

petra

The op isn’t a real person.
You are replying to an AI ChatBot.

Could well be right! It’s so hard to identify them these days!

Bobbysgirl19 Sun 11-May-25 18:48:49

CV2020

My advice— check out your tax position re gifting money to your children etc.
as it can be a minefield. I’m in the UK so don’t know American tax rules

I agree with the above. You have provided so much information and I really think you should be discussing this on a USA site, as different rules apply over there.

CV2020 Sun 11-May-25 16:54:09

My advice— check out your tax position re gifting money to your children etc.
as it can be a minefield. I’m in the UK so don’t know American tax rules

cc Sun 11-May-25 15:00:20

(sorry, type there which I don't apear to be able to edit now, obviously should be "luxury")