Gransnet forums

News & politics

National service??

(35 Posts)
Ariadne Thu 19-Sept-13 09:21:07

Heard on breakfast news this morning that a bill on National Service is proposed. It would include community work, not apply to those already employed, be for one year.

I am not at all sure about this; I think it has the potential to be socially divisive, and I also think it would be extremely difficult to enforce. I could foresee demonstrations etc.

On the other hand, one of the speakers talked about giving structure to young people's lives.

What do we think?

JessM Sat 21-Sept-13 20:59:04

Its a private member's bill. They never get anywhere unless they get government support.
If it was army related the army are going to hate the idea aren't they. Last thing they want to be lumbered with.
If not army related then govt would have to set up a whole structure and finance to make it happen.
dead duck.

jerryatric Sun 22-Sept-13 16:09:01

I agree with Jackthelad I too did national service in 1948 and then TA can only say these were some of the best years .Proud to have served under both our present Queen and her father,

Ariadne Sun 22-Sept-13 16:39:01

I am quite sure that, for those who want to do it, Service education and training is of immense benefit. I saw it all in action for nearly thirty years. But I still think that it would be impossible to enforce National Service of the old kind in today's society - post war people saw the need, I guess. None of our self serving political parties would dare to implement it, as other posters have already said.

It is interesting to read the nostalgia of those who did NS, and I commend them, but then, one never hears from those who detested it. There must have been some? Men in my age group missed it, of course, and we are in our late sixties, so it feels like history.

Anniebach Sun 22-Sept-13 18:32:38

FlicketyB, thank you again for replying, yes very chintzy sums it up at that time, fifties and sixties

absent Sun 22-Sept-13 19:40:52

Ariadne National service was often talked about and plays for television, radio and the theatre were written in the 1950s and 60s just after it had ended. The picture painted at this time was far from rosy. Chips with Everything by Arnold Wesker, although primarily concerned with class, is set during National Service basic training and is probably the best known play.

annodomini Sun 22-Sept-13 20:14:13

Singing from the same hymn sheet, Jess! I have noticed that we often get aerated about proposals which are just that and never stood a cat in hell's chance of passing into statute!

JessM Mon 23-Sept-13 08:07:37

quite anno
just realised that the wonderful writetothem.com has a great resume of one's MP and what they are up to.
www.theyworkforyou.com/mp/24947/iain_stewart/milton_keynes_south

Ariadne Mon 23-Sept-13 09:39:19

Absent thank you! I was desperately trying to remember the name of the play?

I agree - I don't think it stands a cat in hell's chance, (as I think I said) but was interested to explore the idea. You hear a lot of "bring back National Service" to sort out today's young people!

Riverwalk Mon 23-Sept-13 10:34:27

It's as irritating as 'Bring back matron'!