Gransnet forums

News & politics

Breaking News - Allegedly 10 people killed at office of satirical magazine in Paris

(923 Posts)
TerriBull Wed 07-Jan-15 11:50:23

Whilst we don't have all the facts, I have read that at least ten people have been killed at the offices of a satirical French magazine in Paris where gunmen have opened fire.

Given the troubled times we are living in should publications try to rein in the content of anything that might be deemed controversial to certain groups because scenarios like this one will make it hardly worth the loss of life/ves, or should free speech prevail at all costs?

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:15:25

I think that the hate-Muslims thing is beginning to show up in lots of people and articles.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:15:52

The veneer is slipping.

Soutra Fri 16-Jan-15 12:26:18

OK then , please clarify why Pope Francis, who is generally seen to be one of the most "human" religious leaders today, should be obliged to resign in your opinion? And what does having a "clean" or otherwise mind have to do with anything????

GillT57 Fri 16-Jan-15 12:36:07

Sara Khan has been on Tv quite a lot lately, and I like most of what she says, a brave woman. soon could you stop distorting this discussion with your talk of the Pope?

Elegran Fri 16-Jan-15 12:37:06

Definition of "snookered himself" (for soontobe who has not heard that term) -

In a game of snooker - Subject (oneself or one’s opponent) to a snooker:
"He potted yellow and green, and then snookered Davis on the brown" "Hendry led, but then snookered himself"

General - Leave (someone) in a difficult position; thwart: "I managed to lose my flat keys—that was me snookered"

No double meaning, soontobe, so your clean mind doesn't have to worry.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:40:37

Oh good Elegran. Thanks.

Mishap Fri 16-Jan-15 12:42:49

"it is fatuous to pretend that there is anything such as unbridled free speech." I agree with that. The question is, should there be? I think not.

Her stance that those who take advantage of the freedoms in the west, but persist in feeling that they are hard done by, should take themselves off somewhere that accords better with their views, is fine and understandable, but can they escape the western view of democracy anywhere? Historically and currently we challenge those countries where reason and democracy have been supplanted by primitive prejudice, sometimes using propaganda and sometimes with bombs. It is a small world now, and they cannot escape the west's reach - we cannot turn the other cheek to the point of ignoring the atrocities, particularly towards women. Is that what we should be doing? - ejecting them and leaving their cruel societies to flourish while we look the other way?

And as for global economic interests - what a can of worms is that.

Sometimes I wish that international travel and communications had never been invented, then ignorance could be bliss.

There is nothing simple about this conundrum.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:43:45

I responded to NFK about the pope Gill. That is all.
Believe me, I dont wish some of the conversations to be all about what I wrote either.
But people respond, and there doesnt appear to be any way to stop that.
So if you have an idea, please feel free to tell me what it is.
Otherwise, I do suppose I have the option to be rude and not reply to some questions that are put to me. Perhaps that is what I should do? I have been pondering that for a while, but hate to be or appear to be rude to people.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:44:58

Gill, gransnet have said that they dont mind that people ask me questions on a thread that is not much about the thread. So I dont feel that I have anywhere to go on the issue.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:45:48

So I think you and Mishap and others are going to have to put up with it.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 12:47:57

Soutra, I think you need to reread better what I wrote about the pope.

Mishap Fri 16-Jan-15 12:49:18

Soon - there is nothing for me to put up with - I think you are mixing me up with someone else - I have not criticised your contributions.

Elegran Fri 16-Jan-15 13:27:04

You don't have to reply if you don't want to - often a reply doesn't appear until the conversation has moved on, so it leads to confusion. Leaving it even later means that no-one will even notice if you don't send it at all.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 13:32:00

Oh. Sorry. That is good. Thanks.

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 13:33:14

My reply was to Mishap but it equally applies to Elegran's post! smile

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 16-Jan-15 13:54:29

All soontobe meant about the pope was that he might have to resign because he seemed to advocate biffing on the chin anyone who insults one's mother. (good for him. quite right too)

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 16-Jan-15 13:55:48

Oh heck! Missed off the oh-so-important wink and grin!

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 16-Jan-15 13:57:09

soontobe I agree with your post of 12:15:52 today. "The veneer is slipping".

merlotgran Fri 16-Jan-15 14:00:55

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2913242/BREAKING-NEWS-New-Paris-hostage-terror-Gunman-claiming-armed-grenades-Kalashnikov-takes-two-people-captive-post-office.html

Kicking off again??

Soutra Fri 16-Jan-15 14:09:48

Hear, hear about Pope Francis's comment. I'd like to think any child of mine would stand up for me but don't understand why soontobe had to go all round the houses. Sounded like anti-Catholic point scoring and yet another example of ill- informed speaking first and thinking second.
I read exactlly what you said about the Pope and found it a cheap jibe.

^I wonder if the Pope will have to end up stop (sic) being Pope. (I don't know if the Catholic church works that way)
I think that he has totally snookered himself with that comment.^

There is little ambiguity in your remark confused
So what and why?

thatbags Fri 16-Jan-15 14:11:55

Don't talk such bollocks about people hating Muslims. There is no suggestion of that in any of the articles. It's hatred of oppression, which at the moment seems to be centred in Islamist thought, that is the issue. Describing something as "Islamist" or "jihadist" is a completely different thing from hating Muslims.

As if one could hate all Muslims anyway. That's a stupid idea.

I can hate aspects of the Catholic Church without hating a single Catholic person. Same applies to any other religion. It doesn't even mean I hate everything about the Catholic Church, just some things.

Riverwalk Fri 16-Jan-15 14:15:15

soon you didn't answer my question about the Pope (Benedict) - not that you're obliged to of course!

Soutra Fri 16-Jan-15 14:16:47

Maybe silence speaks volumes -or alternatively egg on face?

soontobe Fri 16-Jan-15 14:37:32

I am not anti catholic.

I dont see how the pope can preach about 1/2 of his sermons from now on after talking about punching someone.

No ambiguity either. I cant see how he can carry on being pope.

Riverwalk - apparently I can ignore everyone if I so choose smile wink
Benedict resigned of his own accord.
The pope may end up getting pushed out? I dont know if that can happen in the Catholic church?

GillT57 Fri 16-Jan-15 14:49:10

stop being so silly soon. This is a serious subject on this thread.